12 Tasty Long John Silver's Secret Menu Items To Order in 2025

When it comes to good seafood, Long John Silver’s certainly has us hook, line and sinker, and while you may love the official menu options, did you know that there’s a Long John Silver’s secret menu?

The unofficial secret menu features a range of customizations for your favorite fish and seafood dishes, allowing you to enjoy them in a whole different way. To find out exactly what hidden menu hacks you can implement, keep reading for the 12 top items you need to order from Long John Silver’s secret menu. 

 Jump to Section

• Does Long John Silver's Have a Secret Menu?
• 12 Best Long John Silver's Secret Menu Items
• How We Created This Long John Silver’s Secret Menu Guide

Does Long John Silver's Have a Secret Menu?

Yes, along with the extensive official menu, there’s also a Long John Silver’s secret menu comprised of custom orders and menu hacks that fans of the chain have concocted and shared.

Given that diners want more and more customization options, as explained by Kadence International, it's not surprising that a secret menu for Long John Silver’s has developed. 

Just remember that you may not be able to get these Long John Silver’s hidden menu items at every location. It’s also always a good idea to arrive with the order, including the complete list of customizations and ingredients, ready for the staff. Remember to be understanding if the order can't be made as well.

12 Best Long John Silver's Secret Menu Items

1. Spicy Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich 

The first item on this list of Long John Silver’s secret menu items is the Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich, but with a twist. The official menu item is one of the best fast food fish sandwiches on the market and usually comes with battered pollock, plus pickles and tartar sauce.

However, the secret menu version adds a spicy twist by swapping the tartar sauce for Baja sauce, and we like it a lot more than the original, as many other spicy food lovers likely will as well.

Depending on which Long John Silver’s location you visit, you can also try some other secret combos, like substituting the original sauce with a sweet and mild malt vinegar or a rich cocktail sauce. Some locations will also allow substitutes like classic ketchup, hot sauce, sweet honey mustard or ranch. 

How To Order

• Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich
• Remove: Tartar Sauce
• Add: Baja Sauce

2. Healthier Shrimp and Fish Tacos 

It’s no secret that while tacos are mouthwateringly good, some of the sauces and other additions can make them a little unhealthy. If you want to enjoy healthier tacos, this Long John Silver’s secret menu trick is for you!

When ordering the grilled shrimp or grilled salmon tacos, simply skip the Baja sauce or ask for less to be used. You could also ask for extra vegetables to be added.

While Long John Silver's may not be considered the absolute healthiest fast food chain, this hack goes a long way in making your meal here a little better for you.

How To Order

• Grilled Shrimp or Grilled Salmon Tacos
• Remove: Baja Sauce
• Add: Extra Vegetables (optional)

3. Surf and Turf Sliders 

Chicken and fish are both something this franchise knows how to do well. This next Long John Silver’s secret menu allows you to combine the two, with the addition of buttery biscuits.

The one thing to note about this secret menu hack is that you’ll need to get the biscuits elsewhere. However, many Long John Silver’s are combined with KFCs, where you can get the biscuits.

To create Surf and Turf Sliders, order a chicken meal and a fish meal (or just a piece of battered fish and a piece of battered chicken if you don’t want fries and coleslaw) from Long John Silver’s, plus the biscuits from KFC. Once you have both, add the protein to the biscuits as a sandwich filling. 

You could only use the battered fish and chicken as a filling or also add in coleslaw or one of the many sauces on the Long John Silver's menu. If you can’t get biscuits, we suggest combining fish and chicken in a bun from Long John Silver’s for a Surf and Turf sandwich.  

How To Order

Without Sides

• Battered Fish
• Battered Chicken
• Biscuits (from elsewhere)

With Sides

• Fish Meal
• Chicken Meal
• Biscuits (from elsewhere)

4. Fried Clams 

This is one of the most sought-after meals from the Long John Silver’s secret menu. While these are often on the official menu, not all locations serve fried clams, so it's a bit of luck if you can get them.

These crispy and salty appetizers feature delicious strips of tender clam in a breaded coating, served with a side of rich tartar sauce. For a spicy twist, we recommend swapping out the tartar sauce with Baja sauce.

How To Order: Ask for this Long John Silver's off-menu item by name and add Baja sauce in place of tartar sauce if desired.

5. Spicy Grilled Salmon Meal

If there’s one thing that Long John Silver’s does well besides fish sandwiches, it's the grilled salmon meals. One of Long John Silver's secret menu items that you can try is the grilled salmon meal with an extra kick. 

The next time you order this meal, ask for sweet chili or Baja sauce on the side. The theory is that if the salmon tacos and rice bowls can come with spicy sauces, then you can ask for these sauces on the side of your grilled salmon meal.

We found that this custom hack makes a big difference despite being so simple. The result is a fresh and relatively healthy Long John Silver’s off-menu item with a delicious, tangy and spicy twist. 

How To Order

• Grilled Salmon Meal
• Sweet Chili or Baja Sauce

6. Extra Crumblies 

Looking for a unique side dish from Long John Silver’s secret menu? Ask for some extra ‘crumblies’ with your next order. These small fried bits of batter are one of the best parts about eating at this seafood franchise, and the staff is known to serve you a side of these crumblies if you ask them.

We love dipping the crispy batter pieces in dipping sauce for an additional treat alongside a main meal. This is also one of our favorite cheap fast food hacks that instantly makes any meal better!

How To Order: Just ask for extra crumblies; it's as easy as that!

7. Grilled Shrimp and Battered Chicken Platter 

Long John Silver’s is well-loved for the platters that they serve, but you can add even more variety to these dishes by swapping out some ingredients to create a customized Long John Silver's secret menu item. 

One of our favorite customizations involves ordering the shrimp and fish platter but changing out the salmon for crunchy battered chicken. For a healthy option that still includes some crispy chicken, get a grilled shrimp meal or grilled shrimp bowl and add a piece (or more) of battered chicken. 

If you're searching for some of the best high-protein fast food, you could also add the chicken to the platter without removing the salmon.

How To Order

• Shrimp and Fish Platter
• Remove: Salmon
• Add: Crispy Chicken

8. Free Chicken or Fish on “Talk Like a Pirate Day” 

This Long John Silver’s secret menu hack is seasonal, but worth taking advantage of when it’s around. On “Talk like a Pirate Day,” which happens every September 19th, you can score free food.

All you need to do is visit your nearest Long John Silver’s dressed like a pirate and order your meal talking like a real pirate! If you do this, you’ll get a free piece of fish or chicken with your meal. 

How To Order: Arrive dressed like a pirate and order talking like a pirate! In return, you'll get a free piece of fish or chicken with your meal.

9. Crab Cake Sandwich

While the Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich is a top menu item for a reason, switching up the filling can have great results. All you need to do is ask for a crab cake in place of the battered fish.

You can then stick with the tangy tartar sauce or switch it out for Baja sauce (or any other sauce you'd like). While the staff may honor this request, you can also order the regular fish sandwich and a crab cake and make the switch yourself.

How To Order

• Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich
• Remove: Battered Fish
• Add: Crab Cake 

10. Double Battered Fish 

Did you know that you can order double-battered fish from Long John Silver’s secret menu? To add some more crunch to your Alaska pollock, ask for your piece of fish to be battered twice before frying. You can also do this for any of the other battered items on the menu. 

How To Order: Ask for any battered item to be battered twice before frying. 

11. Cinnamon Sugar Hushpuppies 

A trip to Long John Silver’s is incomplete without getting hushpuppies, a deep-fried and crispy corn batter dough treat. However, if you’ve filled up on savory and want something sweet, you can add a sugary topping with this Long John Silver’s secret menu hack.

Simply ask for your hushpuppies to be rolled in light cinnamon sugar after frying to create a next-level dessert.

How To Order

• Hushpuppies
• Cinnamon Sugar 

12. Loaded Bloody Mary

This is another Long John Silver's secret menu item that includes an element you can't get at the restaurant, but it's definitely worth it!

For a unique brunch drink, pick up (or get delivered) whichever add-ons you want. Some of our favorite picks include battered fish, popcorn shrimp, grilled spicy shrimp and even hush puppies. Then, mix up a Bloody Mary at home and add your battered garnishes on top.

How To Order

• Add-ons of Your Choice, like: 
  • Battered Fish
  • Popcorn Shrimp
  • Grilled Spicy Shrimp
  • Hush Puppies 
• Bloody Mary (made at home)

How We Created This Long John Silver’s Secret Menu Guide

With over 10 years of experience in the food industry, the team at Cozymeal has a wealth of knowledge around the best restaurants, including fast food restaurants. In discovering the top orders and new items at fast food chains, we also discovered that many places have secret menus consisting of custom dishes that only those in the know can order.

One of the most unique secret menus we’ve tried is from Long John Silver’s. To share the Long John Silver’s secret menu with you, we rounded up our favorite menu hacks. Then, we consulted social media platforms and online forums like Reddit, Instagram and Facebook to find even more hidden menu items, adding the most popular and creative ones to our guide. 

The end result is a Long John Silver’s secret menu guide that includes the absolute best custom dishes along with tips on how to order them for yourself.

If you’ve been on the search to try some new and unique things from Long John Silver’s, this list of Long John Silver’s secret menu items should have given you some inspiration.

Whether you add a spicy twist to official menu items, double up on batter or choose to try cinnamon sugar-coated hushpuppies, you’ll have a great and tasty time trying these hidden menu treats!

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.