13 Best Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Items To Try in 2025

The Jersey Mike’s secret menu is no longer a well-kept secret. It offers new ways to tempt your taste buds and feed your appetite, comprised of staff-concocted varieties and fan-favorite specialty subs, both hot and cold.

Curious about which sandwiches reign supreme on Jersey Mike’s secret menu? Wondering how to place an order or even add your signature creation to the list of Jersey Mike’s hidden menu options? Let’s dive in and uncover the delicious secrets that await.

 Jump to Section

• Does Jersey Mike's Have a Secret Menu?
• Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Cold Subs
• Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Hot Subs
• Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Salads and Vegetarian Options
• How We Create This Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Guide

Does Jersey Mike's Have a Secret Menu?

Jersey Mike's doesn't formally advertise a secret menu, but most locations are flexible with customizations or offer off-menu items upon request. While there's no standardized Jersey Mike’s secret menu, creative customers and accommodating staff sometimes create unique combinations that differ from the regular menu.

All you have to do to get them is arrive in the store with the ingredients list. Remember to be patient with the staff and understanding if the custom order can't be created as well. 

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Cold Subs

1. Surf 'n' Turf

Does roast beef and tuna sound like an odd combination, or does it intrigue you? The unique pairing of meat from the sea and the land makes it a standout selection on Jersey Mike’s secret menu. 

The flavor of this Jersey Mike's secret menu item is hearty and salty, with a touch of smokiness from the roast beef. Add your favorite vegetables to create a complete and satisfying meal or keep it simple with just the beef, tuna and mayonnaise.

How To Order

• #9 Club Supreme
• Remove: Turkey
• Remove: Swiss Cheese
• Remove: Bacon (optional)
• Add: Tuna 

2. The Martian

Craving a flavor-packed surprise? Picture this: the bold fusion of salami and pepperoni, plus creamy provolone, in one mouthwatering Jersey Mike’s secret menu sandwich.

Somewhat unconventional yet undeniably delicious, this culinary creation is sure to tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving more. It's almost like a meat pizza in a sub!

In terms of flavor profile, the mildness of the cheese perfectly balances the spiciness of the meats, making this one of the most crowd-pleasing options among all the Jersey Mike’s sandwiches hacks.

How To Order

• #5 The Super Sub
• Remove: Ham
• Remove: Prosciutto
• Add: Salami
• Add: Pepperoni

3. Cuban Supreme

Transport yourself to Havana with this tantalizing Jersey Mike’s secret menu sub. Packed with tender prosciutto, salted capicola and succulent ham, plus Swiss cheese, zesty pickles and spicy mustard, it's a taste sensation not to be missed. We also recommend getting this Jersey Mike's off-menu creation toasted if you prefer a hot sandwich. 

How To Order

• #5 The Super Sub
• Remove: Provolone
• Add: Swiss Cheese
• Add: Pickles
• Add: Mustard

4. Turkey Bacon Ranch Sub

Enjoy the classic turkey sub with a hint of salty bacon, fresh crisped vegetables and creamy ranch dressing by opting for this next Jersey Mike's hidden menu sandwich.

If your two favorite sandwiches are a traditional turkey sandwich and BLT, this combo choice from the Jersey Mike’s secret menu is sure to become your new favorite thing! Ranch lovers won't be disappointed by the hit of dressing either. 

How To Order

• #1 BLT
• Remove: Mayonnaise (optional)
• Add: Turkey
• Add: Ranch Dressing 

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Hot Subs

5. Big Kahuna Cheese Steak With Chipotle Mayo

This sub from the Jersey Mike's secret menu is a great choice for anyone who enjoys a classic cheesesteak sandwich but wants it a little spicier than the traditional recipe. Also known as Jersey Mike's 99, this creation includes tender grilled steak, aromatic onions, mushrooms, peppers and melted cheese.

What sets the 99 at Jersey Mike's apart from other Jersey Mike's sandwiches is the fiery kick from jalapeños and the creamy richness of chipotle mayonnaise. If you're looking for indulgent, spicy and filling lunch food ideas, we can't recommend this Jersey Mike's secret menu item enough!

How To Order

• #56 Big Kahuna Cheese Steak
• Add: Chipotle Mayonnaise

6. The Chick-Fila-Roni

Give this Jersey Mike's hidden menu sandwich a try if you want to try another twist on the classic Philly cheesesteak. This flavorful sandwich (sometimes called the Chick-Pilla-Roni) swaps out traditional steak for grilled chicken and adds a kick of spicy pepperoni.

It's a good choice if you want a treat food but still want to prioritize lean proteins. Packed with bold flavors, it's guaranteed to satisfy your appetite in a whole new way!

How To Order

• #17 Jersey Mike’s Famous Philly
• Remove: Steak
• Add: Chicken
• Add: Pepperoni

7. Pepperoni Pizza Sub

How does succulent pepperoni slices and gooey melted cheese nestled between two soft buns sound? This is the Jersey Mike’s secret menu item to choose from when you yearn for pizza, but the rest of the family wants subs.

While it may sound a little simple compared to some items featured in this Jersey Mike's secret menu guide, don't knock it until you try it. In fact, we rank this as one of the best hidden menu items at Jersey Mike's, thanks to its simplicity and classic, crowd-pleasing flavors.

If you like your pizza extra cheesy, we suggest adding Swiss alongside the provolone. As the base of this Jersey Mike's off-menu item is a cold sandwich, don't forget to ask for it to be heated as well. 

How To Order

• #3 Ham and Provolone
• Remove: Ham
• Add: Pepperoni 
• Add: Red Sauce
• Add: Swiss Cheese (optional)
• Request that the sandwich be heated 

8. Cafeteria Classic

Sink your teeth into a warm, toasted bun filled with savory ham slices and melted Swiss cheese by ordering this next Jersey Mike's secret menu item.

The rich flavors mingle harmoniously in each bite of this Jersey Mike’s secret menu classic, creating a comforting sensation that envelops your palate. Effectively a ham and cheese toastie, it's a classic that diners of all ages will love. 

How To Order

• #3 Ham and Provolone
• Remove: Provolone
• Add: Swiss
• Add: Mustard 
• Request that the sandwich be heated 

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Salads and Vegetarian Options

9. Sub in a Tub

This Jersey Mike’s secret menu hack lets you take your favorite sub and transform it into a salad. It's ideal for anyone who's looking for the best low-calorie fast food, but we also love it when we simply want something a little lighter for our midday meal. 

The removal of the bread also makes this Jersey Mike's secret menu item one of the best low-carb fast food options on the market. Best of all, this keto-friendly fast food dish works with any sandwich and is super customizable, so you can have a different Sub in a Tub each time you visit. 

How To Order

• Sandwich of Your Choice
• Remove: Bread
• Add: Extra Toppings and Dressings 

10. Sweet Pepper Wrap

If you've ever wondered, "Does Jersey Mike's have wraps?", it does on the secret menu! This is the ideal choice for Jersey Mike’s fans seeking a flavorful yet calorie-conscious option. It's also great for those who want to enjoy all of the chain's tasty fillings without a huge portion of bread. 

This healthy secret menu wrap combines the best qualities of a soft wrap with the bold flavors of grilled bell peppers, banana peppers and sweet onions. A dose of chipotle mayonnaise also adds smoky notes.

Of course, it can be customized as much as you want with meats, more vegetables, cheese and dressings. If you're searching for the healthiest fast food options that still taste great, this Jersey Mike's hidden menu item is a top pick.

How To Order

• Tortilla Wrap
• Grilled Bell Peppers
• Banana Peppers
• Sweet Onions
• Chipotle Mayonnaise
• Cheese (optional)

11. Lumberjack Salad

For a protein-packed lunch that is also filled with flavor, try the Jersey Mike’s secret menu Lumberjack Salad. This hearty and flavorful fast food salad includes black pepper ham, fresh roast beef and applewood smoked bacon, plus any other meats of your choice.

The meats are then coupled with sharp Swiss cheese, plenty of salad vegetables and your favorite dressing.

While this is a top pick for those looking for low-carb, high-protein fast food, we're sure anyone who enjoys a meat lover's sandwich but wants something a little healthier will be impressed by this Jersey Mike's hidden menu salad. 

How To Order

• #9 Club Supreme
• Remove: Bread
• Remove: Turkey (optional)
• Add: Ham
• Add: Salad Vegetables
• Add: Extra Meats (optional)
• Add: Dressing of Your Choice

12. Portobello Cheese Steak 

Vegetarians don't have to miss out on a filling and indulgent cheese steak with this Jersey Mike's secret menu hack. The chain offers meaty and savory portobello mushrooms as a filling, and these can be used to replace the steak in any of the cheese steak sandwiches. 

The easiest way to get this sandwich is by going for the #66 Portabella Cheese Steak and asking for the steak to be left out (ideally with some extra mushrooms also added). However, you can choose any other cheese steak and replace the meat with mushrooms, as all other ingredients are vegetarian-friendly.  

You could even use this Jersey Mike’s hack to get a vegan sandwich by also removing the cheese. However, it may not hold together as well without the melted cheese to bind all the other fillings. 

How To Order

• Any Cheese Steak Sandwich
• Remove: Meat
• Add: Portobello Mushrooms

13. Avocado Veggie Sub

Enjoy the health benefits of creamy, fresh avocado and various healthy vegetables in this satisfying and flavorful Jersey Mike’s secret menu vegetarian sub. This one is a cool, refreshing and healthy choice to enjoy during summer’s hottest months.

It's also one of the best vegetarian fast food items to go for when you want a filling sandwich instead of a salad or wrap. If you want a vegan fast food option, simply leave the mayonnaise off. You could also ask for some extra avocado to replace the creaminess that the mayo brings.  

Unlike many orders on this list, this Jersey Mike's secret menu sandwich will need to be ordered from scratch. However, it shouldn't be too difficult to do so. 

How To Order

• Bread of Your Choice
• Add: Avocado
• Add: Salad Vegetables
• Add: Mayonnaise
• Add: Other Condiments and Dressings (optional)

How We Create This Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Guide

The editorial team at Cozymeal has an extensive background in creating helpful and informative food guides across various topics, including fast food industry content. Thanks to this experience in the fast food space, we have discovered that most fast food chains, including Jersey Mike’s, have a range of secret menu items: delicious creations that aren’t available on the official menu.

To help you get the inside scoop on these secret menu items at Jersey Mike’s, we’ve rounded up the best options for you in one convenient guide. 

To do this, we turn to our industry experience and existing knowledge of the best secret menu items at Jersey Mike’s. Additionally, we undertake research, via the web and by consulting social media platforms that frequently share secret menu items, like Reddit, TikTok and Instagram. 

We even go as far as trying these items ourselves to see if they’re worth the order. Finally, we ensure you have the instructions needed to get each Jersey Mike’s secret menu item for yourself, making it easy to get a taste of these unique hidden menu creations.

When you want a change from the regular menu, Jersey Mike’s secret menu has some great options. Each sub, wrap or salad is packed with flavor and loaded with your favorite meats and vegetables, offering a great way to switch up your lunchtime routine.

Best of all, you can customize Jersey Mike's secret menu items even further to create a personalized dish with all your favorite ingredients. Who knows, you may even stumble upon the next viral Jersey Mike's hidden menu item by getting creative with your order! 

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.