11 Best Cold Stone Secret Menu Items To Try in 2025

Are you curious about the possibilities of Cold Stone’s secret menu? Want to enjoy a whole new world of ice cream flavors? Then you’re in the right place!

Cold Stone Creamery already stands out in the expanding ice cream parlor market — Grand View Research reports this sector is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 5.1% from 2023 to 2030 — serving premium sweets crafted to the highest quality on its regular menu.

However, while the classic menu boasts fan favorite flavors, Cold Stone’s secret menu offers new combinations for the more adventurous.

No matter what you’re craving, there’s something for everyone, and we've got the scoop on the best custom orders in this guide to the most delicious Cold secret menu treats.

 Jump to Section

• Does Cold Stone Have a Secret Menu?
• The 11 Best Cold Stone Secret Menu Items
• How We Created This Cold Stone Creamery Secret Menu Guide

Does Cold Stone Have a Secret Menu?

Along with delicious classic flavors on the usual menu, there is a Cold Stone secret menu. These Cold Stone Creamery secret menu items are concocted by creative customers and shared online for others to also enjoy. Just remember that these treats may not be known by name, so fully explain the custom order to staff in-store. 

The 11 Best Cold Stone Secret Menu Items

1. Key Lime Pie 

Craving the tangy flavor of a Key lime pie as an ice cream treat? Then turn to this Cold Stone secret menu item!

It’s a slight twist on a popular Key West food, as it starts with a lemon sorbet base. To that, cake batter ice cream is added along with graham cracker pie crust and a delicate dollop of whipped cream to finish.

Despite featuring lemon instead of Key lime flavors, we found this Cold Stone off-menu item perfectly mimicked the classic pie and is one of the best fast food desserts for those who love zesty and refreshing flavors. 

How To Order

• Lemon Sorbet 
• Cake Batter Ice Cream
• Graham Cracker Pie Crust
• Whipped Cream

2. Dulce de Leche 

Dig into a sweet treat that emanates the Dulce de Leche flavors with this next Cold Stone secret menu item. This Latin American delicacy, traditionally made by slowly heating sweetened milk until it caramelizes into a thick, creamy sauce, holds a special place in many hearts.

To experience its richness, order a French vanilla ice cream as your base, topped with a light dusting of cinnamon and a generous drizzle of sweet caramel. While definitely not the healthiest ice cream customization, we also suggest adding some graham cracker pieces to this Cold Stone Creamery off-menu item if you want a little extra sweetness and a dulce de leche cheesecake-type treat. 

Although we absolutely loved this Cold Stone Creamery off-menu item, it is quite rich and very sweet, so it may not be for you if you want something more subtle in flavor. 

How To Order

• French Vanilla Ice Cream
• Cinnamon
• Caramel 
• Graham Cracker Pie Crust (optional)

3. Coconut Cream Pie

It’s fluffy. It’s smooth. It’s coconut cream pie! This next Cold Stone secret menu item is a frozen take on the dreamy, cloud-like dessert, perfect after a meal at any time of the year, especially in the summertime. 

Dating back to the early 1900s, this delicious flavor is a classic American innovation. Experience it by ordering a French vanilla ice cream as your base, topped with graham cracker pie crust, whipped cream and shredded coconut.

You could also lean even more into the coconut flavor by adding coconut ice cream, either in place of the French vanilla or alongside it. 

How To Order

• French Vanilla Ice Cream
• Graham Cracker Pie Crust
• Shredded Coconut
• Coconut Ice Cream (optional)

4. Pineapple Upside-Down Cake 

Leave the ice cream shop with a classic retro treat by ordering a pineapple upside-down cake from the Cold Stone secret menu. We think there's just something so joyful about an ice cream that mimics a fun dessert like this, and this Cold Stone Creamery off-menu item will definitely boost your mood!

To get this popular dessert in ice cream form, start with creamy cake batter ice cream as your base, then add yellow cake pieces and juicy pineapple bits for added texture and tropical sweetness. Top this secret menu creation off with maraschino cherries for an extra burst of flavor.

How To Order

• Cake Batter Ice Cream
• Yellow Cake Pieces 
• Pineapple Tidbits
• Maraschino Cherries

5. Strawberry Shortcake

This Cold Stone Creamery secret menu item is made especially for strawberry lovers. It’s an ice cream take on a classic strawberry shortcake, complete with real bites of cake. A deconstructed reimagining, if you will.

To try this Cold Stone secret menu flavor, order a strawberry ice cream for your base. Then, top that with juicy strawberries, tender yellow cake pieces and a dollop of fluffy whipped cream. We love finishing it with a maraschino cherry on top as well, primarily for aesthetic reasons. 

How To Order

• Strawberry Ice Cream
• Strawberries
• Yellow Cake Pieces
• Whipped Cream
• Maraschino Cherry (optional)

6. Cherry Cobbler 

This is the item to try for those looking for a reliable introduction to the Cold Stone secret menu. As the title suggests, it is a reimagining of a classic cherry cobbler pie, where the vibrant sweet-and-sour flavor of cherries pairs exceptionally well against the solid and reliable taste of vanilla. 

To try this Cold Stone secret menu flavor, order a French vanilla ice cream for your base, topped with golden yellow cake pieces, luscious cherry pie filling and a crumbly graham cracker pie crust. This treat is so tasty, we guarantee it will become one of your favorite Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors!

How To Order

• French Vanilla Ice Cream
• Golden Yellow Cake Pieces
• Cherry Pie Filling
• Graham Cracker Pie Crust

7. Arroz con Leche

An ice cream version of arroz con leche, also known as rice pudding, is one of the most popular Cold Stone secret menu items. Rooted in Spanish cuisine but also popular across Latin America today, this versatile dish can be served as either a savory or sweet option, depending on the combination of spices or sweeteners added to it.

To try it, you'll, surprisingly, ask for a swirl of cotton candy ice cream to be added to cinnamon ice cream. That's all there is to it! You’ll be enjoying a delicate balance of spice and rice flavors in no time.

If you want something even sweeter, you can use Cinnamon Bun Butter ice cream instead of standard cinnamon. Finishing the dessert with a sprinkle of cinnamon is also a great idea. 

How To Order

• Cinnamon Ice Cream
• Swirl of Cotton Candy Ice Cream
• Cinnamon (optional)

8. Peanut Butter and Jelly

There’s something so comforting about simple tried-and-true combinations, and peanut butter and jelly sandwiches are one of them. If you’re craving a hit of nostalgia and enjoy sweet-and-salty flavors, this Cold Stone secret menu item is for you.

It’s simpler than you think, too. Just order a peanut butter ice cream with raspberry sorbet. The result is a freezing-cold version of a classic childhood snack, sure to impress your taste buds.

You can also boost the flavors by adding toppings like real peanut butter or Reese's peanut butter sauce, alongside fresh raspberries or strawberries. However, we found that the combo of peanut butter ice cream and raspberry sorbet is enough to give you a taste of the classic PB and jelly combo. 

How To Order

• Peanut Butter Ice Cream
• Raspberry Sorbet
• Peanut Butter or Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce (optional)
• Fresh Raspberries or Strawberries (optional) 

9. Ants on a Log

This Cold Stone secret menu flavor is an unexpected reimagining of a healthy snack for kids, without the celery. Bring yourself back to days spent under the sun at the playground with this decked-out sweet and salty treat. 

The best part? It's great for all ages! To try this somewhat weird ice cream flavor, start by ordering a French vanilla ice cream for your base, then top it with chocolate-covered sea-salted pretzels, raisins and a drizzle of peanut butter sauce. 

How To Order

• French Vanilla Ice Cream
• Chocolate-Covered Sea Salt Pretzels
• Rasins
• Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce

10. Chocolate Gooey Butter Cake 

When it comes to Cold Stone's secret menu flavors, Chocolate Gooey Butter Cake takes the, well, cake. Perfect for chocolate lovers everywhere, this dessert is a decadent creation that stops at nothing to live up to its bold name. 

To cut a long story short, there's a lot of chocolate. To try this Cold Stone Creamery secret menu item, order a regular cake batter ice cream for your base, then add fudge and bits of both cake and brownie pieces.

If you want something over-the-top chocolately, we recommend opting for chocolate cake batter or fudge brownie batter ice cream as the base instead of cake batter. No matter which base you choose, you'll get a decadent and moreish treat that's one of the best Cold Stone creations for anyone with a major sweet tooth.

How To Order

• Cake Batter Ice Cream
• Yellow Cake Pieces 
• Brownie Pieces
• Fudge

11. Boston Cream Pie

Last, but by no means least, is Boston cream pie, a classic flavor when it comes to cakes, doughnuts, and, of course, ice cream. This classic American dessert was invented in 1856 for the grand opening of Boston’s Parker House, now Omni Parker House, which is still open today as one of the longest-operating hotels in America.

Try this flavor by ordering a French vanilla ice cream base, generously topped with tender bits of yellow cake, a dollop of creamy whipped cream and a gorgeous drizzle of rich fudge. While not traditional, finish this Cold Stone Creamery off-menu treat with rainbow sprinkles for a little extra fun!

How To Order

• French Vanilla Ice Cream
• Yellow Cake Pieces
• Whipped Cream
• Fudge 
• Rainbow Sprinkles (optional)

How We Created This Cold Stone Creamery Secret Menu Guide

The team at Cozymeal has more than 10 years of experience in the food industry, which includes creating a range of culinary content on topics ranging from cooking tips to the best restaurant chain orders. In uncovering the best orders, we’ve found that many chains have secret menus, including dessert chain Cold Stone Creamery. 

To share the best Cold Stone Creamery secret menu items with you, our team rounded up our favorite menu hacks while also conducting additional research. This included scouring platforms like Reddit, TikTok and Instagram for the most popular Cold Stone off-menu items.

The result is a guide to the most delicious and unique custom orders at Cold Stone Creamery; we even offer ingredient lists to make getting these items for yourself easy.

Ice cream has been a beloved dessert that's long been enjoyed by people worldwide. With the Cold Stone secret menu, this fascination reaches new heights as high-quality ice cream is paired with an array of popular flavors, transcending time and tradition.

Whether you're indulging in the nostalgia of childhood treats or exploring innovative flavor combinations, Cold Stone's secret menu promises a delightful culinary adventure. So why not treat yourself to a scoop or two and savor ice cream in all its creamy glory?

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.