15 Best Biggby Coffee Secret Menu Items To Try in 2026
If you’re based in Michigan or a handful of other states in the Midwestern U.S., you’ve likely heard of (and even frequent) Biggby, but did you know that there’s a Biggby Coffee secret menu that can take your regular order to a new level?
Since its origins in 1995, Biggby Coffee has become a Midwestern classic with over 450 locations across 13 states. The chain has recently announced a brand refresh as well, in part to attract even more loyal customers.
With that type of growing popularity, it follows that legions of fans have come up with a range of Biggby off-menu items that extend the already excellent selection of beverages.
Whether you head into this chain frequently or are checking it out for the first time, getting the inside scoop on the best Biggby Coffee secret menu items can make your experience a little more unique.
So, if you’re feeling like a change, one of these 15 Biggby Coffee off-menu items should liven up your coffee run just fine!
Jump to Section
- The 15 Best Biggby Secret Menu Items
- More Ways To Customize Biggby Coffee Drinks
- How We Created This Biggby Coffee Secret Menu Guide
The 15 Best Biggby Secret Menu Items
1. Zebra Mocha
This Biggby Coffee secret menu drink is best for those who believe that the best flavored coffee sneaks in more than a little chocolate.
In fact, the Zebra Mocha secret menu drink at Biggby Coffee gets two kinds in one drink: the traditional dark chocolate of a mocha, and a white chocolate addition for smoothness and some less-nuanced sweetness to cut the bitterness of coffee.
Plus, it’s super easy to order. Simply get a mocha latte and ask for the chocolate to be half white chocolate and half dark chocolate. If you want a little extra treat, ask for this Biggby hidden menu drink to be topped with whipped cream and some extra chocolate drizzle.
Should you wish to start your day with a hit of overwhelming chocolatey sweetness, this might just be the Biggby Coffee off-menu item of your dreams
How To Order
- Hot or Iced Mocha
- Half White Chocolate Syrup
- Half Dark Chocolate Syrup
- Whipped Cream (optional)
2. Almond Joy Latte
With the right combination of syrups, it’s possible to make a latte at Biggby Coffee taste like just about anything. In fact, that concept is the basis for a great deal of these Biggby Coffee secret menu offerings, like this one.
If you think that Almond Joy is the best chocolate bar, you won’t want to miss out on this one! This candy bar-inspired Biggby Coffee secret menu drink is sugary-sweet, but the coffee still comes through well and cuts through some of that sweetness in a very welcome and tasty way.
So, what does it comprise exactly? It starts with an iced or hot mocha latte base, which is then paired with equal portions of marshmallow and coconut syrups. If you prefer a more coconut-heavy drink, use the coconut crème latte as the base to which you add marshmallow and chocolate syrups.
The result may not exactly replicate one of the nation’s most polarizing Halloween candies, but it’ll give you just enough of a fix to get you by until next October – or, let’s be real, your next run through a grocery store aisle with a temptingly-placed candy section.
There really is a secret menu drink at Biggby Coffee for everything, isn’t there?
How To Order
- Hot or Iced Mocha
- Marshmallow Syrup
- Coconut Syrup
or
- Coconut Crème Latte
- Marshmallow Syrup
- Chocolate Syrup
3. Budget Latte
So you’re going broke buying your daily latte? If so, you may think that means the end of your morning coffee runs, right? Wrong.
Innovative fans of the Biggby Coffee secret menu have added a listing tailor-made for cases such as this: a drink that imitates a latte at a much lower price. All you have to do is get two shots of espresso, then add sweet foam and finish off with a pump of vanilla, and you’ve got a nifty little knockoff latte in your hands.
This kind of clever workaround is exactly what the customization-friendly philosophy of Biggby Coffee is hoping to encourage, so go ahead and order that Budget Latte with your head held high.
How To Order
- 2 Shots of Espresso
- Sweet Foam
- Vanilla Syrup
4. Caramel Poison Apple
This is yet another staff-created drink that was whipped up as a seasonal secret menu drink. In honor of Halloween, staffers recommended ordering a frozen green apple steamer with copious amounts of caramel drizzle.
It hits that sweet-tart balance beautifully and is a refreshing autumnal coffee-shop order that doesn’t involve pumpkin spice anything. If your cashier doesn’t know the drink by name, simply order a frozen green apple steamer with as many pumps of caramel as your heart desires.
This is, happily, one of the simplest Biggby Coffee secret menu drinks to order. If you can’t imagine going without caffeine, you can add green apple syrup (if seasonally available) and caramel syrup to a coffee drink of your choice for a unique, fall flavor.
How To Order
- Frozen Green Apple Steamer
- Caramel Drizzle
or
- Coffee Drink of Your Choice
- Green Apple Syrup
- Caramel Syrup
5. Fruity Hot Chocolate
The concept for this Biggby Coffee secret menu item originated in an Instagram post about a DIY orange hot chocolate inspired by chocolate orange candy.
But seeing as that orange syrup isn’t always available across seasons and locations, the idea was expanded a little by future customers to encompass the whole range of Biggby Coffee’s fruit syrup line. Strawberry is one pick we especially recommend for a chocolate-covered-strawberry vibe.
To order, all you have to do is ask for a plain hot chocolate and a few pumps of your favorite fruit-flavored syrup.
How To Order
- Hot Chocolate
- Fruit Syrup of Your Choice
Extra Customization Option: While not a fruit, we find frosted mint syrup also works well with this Biggby Coffee menu hack to make a minty and chocolatey treat.
6. Zimtsterne Chai Latte
This coffee shop favorite-with-a-twist comes courtesy of another Biggby Coffee location that suggested a spin on the classic South Asian drink.
To order it, you’ll start with a chai latte and then ask for pumps of almond, cinnamon and vanilla syrups, plus extra steamed milk to liven up the from-concentrate chai blend that is used to make the base drink.
Make sure to ask for whipped cream and a sprinkling of cinnamon on top to complete this comforting and flavor-packed Biggby Coffee secret menu item.
How To Order
- Chai Latte
- Almond Syrup
- Cinnamon Syrup
- Vanilla Syrup
- Steamed Milk
- Whipped Cream
- Sprinkle of Cinnamon
7. Raspberry Truffle Latte
Should you happen to be looking for a Valentine’s Day drink on the Biggby Coffee secret menu, this is probably one of your best bets. It plays on a tried-and-true combination of flavors that just happens to fit in well with the usual Biggby Coffee syrups.
This is probably one of the more straightforward Biggby Coffee secret menu drinks to order, too, making it a good choice if you’re just getting into the world of secret menu ordering. To get your raspberry truffle latte, just ask for your favorite latte with however many pumps of chocolate and raspberry syrup you fancy.
Like most Biggby Coffee secret menu items, it can be ordered hot or iced, but our seasonally-appropriate recommendation is to get this one hot. It’s almost like a raspberry hot chocolate with a caffeine kick, and you’ll be obsessed.
How To Order
- Iced or Hot Latte of Your Choice
- Raspberry Syrup
- Chocolate Syrup
8. Minty Melon Frozen Lemonade
Biggby Coffee’s crème freeze beverages rival the best fast food milkshakes, and in the summertime, it’s hard to get a more refreshing drink to sip on than this Biggby Coffee secret menu item.
You’ll start with a mix of seasonal melon and frosted mint crème freezes, then add a splash (or a few splashes) of lemonade to complete the fruity flavor profile of this Biggby Coffee secret menu smoothie.
It’s important to mention that both the melon and frosted mint flavors are limited edition and seasonal (usually available in the spring).
If mint is not on the menu when you go to order this Biggby Coffee secret menu item, you can add mint syrup to a melon freeze. Pair frosted mint with another fruity flavor (we recommend pineapple if available) if you don’t see melon on the menu board.
If neither is available, choose a tropical fruit crème freeze and add mint syrup to get a similarly refreshing and delicious beverage.
How To Order
- Frosted Mint Crème Freeze
- Melon Crème Freeze
9. The Terra
Mark this down for the cramming-for-a-test crowd: how does an iced coffee with two extra shots of espresso sound? That’s the basic idea of The Terra, a drink that one Biggby’s Coffee location began to publicize after a regular started ordering it.
This Biggby Coffee secret menu drink is basically a coffee-on-coffee caffeine-fest with a little caramel to cut the bitterness.
To order The Terra, start with black coffee. You’ll then need to ask for two shots of espresso and five pumps of caramel, followed by a splash of cream.
You can then round it out with cold foam. We also recommend mixing it frequently to ensure the caramel doesn’t settle at the bottom of the cup.
Though it’s somewhat bitter and it’s definitely intensely caffeinated, there are times when you need something like that in your life!
How To Order
- Iced Black Coffee
- 2 Espresso Shots
- 5 Pumps Caramel Syrup
- Splash of Cream
- Cold Foam (optional)
10. Mango-Strawberry Crème Freeze
Those who prefer caffeine-free beverages will be interested in getting a taste of this Biggby Coffee secret menu drink. This smoothie-like order is also easy to get as well, making it a great choice for those new to using secret menus.
Combining fruity strawberry syrup with tropical mango crème freeze, it's a delicious and refreshing summer sip from the Biggby Coffee secret menu that you'll want to get again and again!
Just note that a mango crème freeze isn't always available, as the flavor is usually paired with another fruit (currently it's mango and blood orange). Therefore, you will need to either remove the additional fruit syrup (just request this when ordering) or try it with an extra fruit flavor.
How To Order
- Mango Crème Freeze
- Strawberry Syrup
or
- Mango Blood Orange Crème Freeze
- Remove: Blood Orange Syrup
- Add: Strawberry Syrup
Top Tip: This Biggby Coffee secret menu hack works with all crème freeze flavors, so you get creative combining crème freeze base and fruity syrups.
11. Sweet Foam Mocktail
You may not guess it if you walked into a Biggby Coffee outpost for the first time without any context and read the menu board, but the word “mocktail” has its own meaning here: Red Bull. Yup. You heard that right.
Often considered the best energy drink, those who agree with that assessment will be pleased to learn that Red Bull makes up the base of anything called a “mocktail” at Biggby Coffee, and that includes secret menu drinks.
This particular Biggby Coffee secret menu drink consists of a Red Bull mocktail of your choice (current options include strawberry, raspberry, blackberry and “BlueRazz”) made with lemonade and finished with a sweet cold foam top.
If you’re looking for a drink that gives you that caffeine zing without forcing you to gulp down a whole cup of coffee, this one is among your more unique options.
While probably not winning the title of healthiest energy drink any time soon, this Biggby Coffee secret menu option is tailor-made for days you need a boost without a coffee taste or for late-night study sessions when you want something that tastes like a well-earned treat.
How To Order
- Red Bull Mocktail of Your Choice
- Lemonade
- Sweet Cream Foam
12. Cotton Candy Latte
It’s not uncommon for secret menu drinks to start as seasonal or otherwise limited edition items, and this Biggby Coffee secret menu drink is no exception.
Although it began its life as a special release for National Cotton Candy Day (December 7th every year, if anyone was wondering), this uber-sweet iced coffee is now a favorite Biggby Coffee secret menu item.
Its formula is as simple as it is blindingly sweet: into a vanilla latte go equal parts raspberry, blueberry and marshmallow syrups. That’s it!
If you’re looking for the sugariest drink on the Biggby Coffee secret menu, this might just be it.
How To Order
- Vanilla Latte
- Raspberry Syrup
- Blueberry Syrup
- Marshmallow Syrup
13. Cookie Bear
As its name suggests, this drink combines the Teddy Bear latte and chocolate chip cookie crème freeze flavors to make an indulgent Biggby Coffee secret menu drink. However, this interesting Biggby hidden menu drink doesn’t literally combine the two regular menu beverages.
Instead, you’ll start with a chocolate chip cookie base. From there, you’ll try to imitate the Teddy Bear latte flavor by adding caramel and White Lightning syrups.
Cookie Bear is definitely in the running for the best milkshake imitations on the Biggby Coffee secret menu, so if all you want is a sweet treat, this might be the way to go. You’re definitely headed for a sugar rush if you do, sure, but isn’t that what a coffee shop run is (sort of) for?
How To Order
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Crème Freeze
- Caramel Syrup
- White Lightning Syrup
14. Caramel Apple Cider Latte
Caramel apple cider is a beloved autumn drink at Biggby’s, featuring Michigan-made apple cider with creamy caramel and a cinnamon sprinkle. If you like that concept but you’re here for coffee and not cider, there’s an equally-popular Biggby Coffee secret menu for that.
This one could get a little tricky to order, since caramel apple cider is its own drink entirely. We suggest starting with a latte base and adding caramel, cinnamon sprinkles and a splash of Michigan apple cider.
While this is one of the more customized Biggby Coffee secret menu orders, you may get lucky with an employee who’s gotten this order before. Remember, it’s also a seasonal beverage, so if you have a craving for this in the summer, you’ll probably be out of luck.
How To Order
- Latte
- Caramel Syrup
- Splash of Apple Cider
- Sprinkle of Cinnamon
15. The Snickers Latte
Another candy-bar-inspired beverage, this Biggby Coffee secret menu drink can be enjoyed hot or cold and pairs a caramel latte with hazelnut syrup.
While some versions of this Biggby hidden menu drink stop there, you can add chocolate syrup if desired to add the chocolate hit that comes with the namesake candy bar.
While the drink uses hazelnut instead of peanut, the resemblance is very close and it has a perfect balance of sweet and creamy flavors.
How To Order
- Caramel Marvel Latte
- Hazelnut Syrup
- Chocolate Syrup (optional)
More Ways To Customize Biggby Coffee Drinks
Not all Biggby off-menu items are totally new drinks. As a matter of fact, most of the Biggby Coffee secret menu actually consists of small tweaks you might not know you could make.
Along with the popular Biggby hidden menu drinks we’ve outlined above, here are a few extra tricks you can use to switch up your order and make a beverage customized just to your taste.
Biggby Coffee Customization Options
- Milk Swaps: If you have dairy sensitivities or prefer an alternative milk, you can opt out of the default dairy milk and ask for a plant-based milk like soy, oat, almond, or coconut.
- Seasonal Specialties: Add pumpkin syrup to your drink in the autumn, peppermint during winter, lavender or raspberry in spring, or that year’s seasonal fruit syrups in summertime to give your drink a pop of seasonal flavor.
- Custom Syrups: You can add a pump of just about any Biggby syrup to your drink, no matter what it is. Mixing and matching multiple syrups together is also a fun idea and can create one-of-a-kind flavor combos.
- Keep it Light: Both a no-whip option and a handful of sugar-free syrups (like hazelnut, caramel and vanilla) are available if you’re looking to cut down on sugar or calories.
- Sweetness: “Half-sweet” drinks halve the pumps of syrup you’ll get or you can request extra pumps of syrup for an even sweeter beverage.
As you can see, if there’s no dedicated secret menu drink at Biggby Coffee that strikes your fancy, you’ve still got plenty of customization options!
How We Created This Biggby Coffee Secret Menu Guide
Creating this Biggby Coffee secret menu involved gathering customizations from our team members who have tried the coffee shop and conducting research to discover more fan favorite custom creations.
What's great about coffee chains like Biggby is that they already allow customers to customize their beverages with a range of add-ins. This means that there's no shortage of Biggby Coffee secret menu drinks promoted by customers across social media and forums like Reddit.
Some stores have even created in-store specialties that have then been shared via the brand's social media pages.
Having found all of the most unique and delicious Biggby secret menu drinks, we then uncovered exactly how to make them so that we can share instructions on how to get them with you to make custom ordering easy.
Should you ever wish for a change of pace in your morning coffee routine, the Biggby Coffee secret menu has you covered.
Substitutions, brand-new creations you’ve never heard of, it’s all here, and as long as you’re patient, clear and polite when ordering, you’ll walk out with a Biggby off-menu drink that may well be the envy of everyone else in line.
For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
