Best Pizza in Brooklyn: 17 Best Pizza Places for 2024
There are few NYC foods more iconic than pizza, and even fewer titles more coveted than that of the best pizza in Brooklyn. Some may argue that it’s difficult to find a bad pizza, but true pizza connoisseurs know a perfect pie when they taste one, and the competition is deliciously brutal when it comes to narrowing down the best pizza in Brooklyn.
Whether you’ve lived in the neighborhood for generations or you’re visiting the Big Apple for the first time, Brooklyn is like a little slice of heaven for all pizza lovers. If you’re looking for things to do in NYC, you simply must plan to grab a slice of pizza before you go. Check out these incredible pizza places serving up some of the best pizza in Brooklyn!
Jump to Section
Find the Best Pizza in Brooklyn
One way to discover the best pizza in Brooklyn is with pizza tours in NYC. Food tours take you on a journey through the city’s most popular restaurants and hidden gems, so you can feel confident that you'll find the best pizza in Brooklyn. Learn about the history of pizza in New York, special recipes and tasty techniques when you book a food tour in NYC!
17 Best Pizza Places in Brooklyn
1. Chaos Pie at Di Fara
Di Fara is widely known as one of the most legendary of the best pizza spots in NYC. Regulars and tourists alike have happily waited in line for hours to get a slice of the best pizza in Brooklyn here.
The Vibe
Di Fara’s pizza shops are small, intimate and affordable like a typical neighborhood pizzeria, but bustling crowds signify the delicious secrets within their humble walls.
What to Order
Di Fara’s offers a standard pizza menu with customizable toppings, as well as some house specialties like the Chaos Pie. Created to celebrate Di Fara’s 50th anniversary, this pizza features toppings chosen by the owner’s family, including sausage, meatballs, wild onions, fresh garlic and cherry tomatoes.
Di Fara’s | Multiple Locations | $
2. Brunch Pizza at Roberta’s
Roberta’s is another restaurant frequently said to have the best pizza in Brooklyn. New Yorkers love stopping here for brunch, lunch and sunny celebrations. After enjoying indoor activities in NYC, it's lovely to relax on Roberta’s outdoor patio.
The Vibe
Roberta’s offers a cool, hipster atmosphere perfect for laid-back dining. An urban garden can be found on the back patio, where fresh produce is grown to create quality cuisine at one of the best pizza spots in NYC.
What to Order
The best boozy Sunday brunches come with a brunch pizza. Roberta’s offers a few specialty brunch pizzas, including the Brunch White and Greens Pizza, made with mozzarella, parmigiana, fresh greens and lemon. It’s one of the more unique options among the best pizzas in Brooklyn.
Roberta’s | 261 Moore St., Brooklyn, NY 11206 | $$
3. Margherita Pizza at Juliana’s
Pizza lovers in Brooklyn are familiar with the fascinating history behind beloved restaurants Juliana’s and Grimaldi’s. After selling Grimaldi’s, the owner came out of retirement to open Juliana’s in the same vacated space. Despite their intertwined history, both restaurants make a name for themselves with some of the best pizza in Brooklyn.
The Vibe
Juliana’s pizzeria is subtle and classically Italian, with tasteful red, checker-patterned décor. Juliana’s is one of the best pizza places in Brooklyn for a casual dinner, intimate party or date night in NYC.
What to Order
When dining at such an iconic pizzeria in New York, you should stick to the classics. The Margherita pizza at Juliana’s is to die for, with plump tomatoes, fresh basil and plenty of gooey mozzarella.
Juliana’s | 19 Old Fulton St., Brooklyn, NY | $$
4. Brooklyn Bridge Pizza at Grimaldi’s
Juliana’s infamous rival and nearby neighbor, Grimaldi’s, is another hot contender for the best pizza in Brooklyn. Grimaldi’s prides itself on providing the freshest sauces and pizza toppings in Brooklyn. Which restaurant is better? You’ll have to try both to decide for yourself.
The Vibe
Grimaldi’s proudly honors their Italian roots. Dine in to enjoy murals, art and cozy lighting in a casual Italian-inspired atmosphere.
What to Order
Grimaldi’s pizzas are fired in a coal oven, which makes for a delicate char and crispy crust while keeping the inner dough tender and soft. The Brooklyn Bridge Pizza is a perfect choice off the menu that showcases this baking method, topped with red peppers, ricotta cheese and Italian sausage.
Grimaldi’s | 1 Front St., Brooklyn, NY 11201 | $$
5. Grandma Pizza at Williamsburg Pizza
Serving the best pizza in Williamsburg, Brooklyn and beyond, Williamsburg Pizza is a mini-chain known for its low prices and quality ingredients. Williamsburg Pizza also offers a few vegan and vegetarian pizza options, and they’ve made strides as one of the first pizza restaurants in New York to deliver via drone.
The Vibe
Williamsburg Pizza is a great place to stop for a quick lunch or a slice of the best pizza in Brooklyn. The atmosphere is quaint, clean and cozy.
What to Order
Williamsburg Pizza carries all of your hot and cheesy favorites, as well as some unique toppings like vegan pepperoni and apple bacon. The traditional square-crust Grandma pizza is a local favorite, topped with basil, Parmigiano-Reggiano, fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce. It’s a must-try for those in search of the best pizza in Brooklyn.
Williamsburg Pizza | Multiple Locations | $
6. Funghi & Tartufo Pizza at Saraghina Restaurant
This wouldn’t be an honest list of the best pizza in Brooklyn if we didn’t include Saraghina. Located in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Saraghina Restaurant serves up traditional Italian fare including pasta and authentic wood-fired pizzas.
The Vibe
Saraghina is a classy yet rustic restaurant, bar and pizzeria, perfect for a casual date or birthday dinner in NYC. They offer takeout, but sitting on Saraghina’s patio is a one-of-a-kind pizza dining experience.
What to Order
Saraghina Restaurant offers many unique specialty pizzas, but the Funghi and Tartuffo pizza stands alone as one of the best pizzas in Brooklyn. Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, garlic and thyme set the stage for maitake, cremini and truffle mushrooms to shine. Don’t forget to browse Saraghina’s extensive cocktail menu as well!
Saraghina Restaurant | 350 Lewis Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11233 | $$
7. Build Your Own at Lucali
Lucali likes to keep things simple, relying on quality ingredients and wholesome firing techniques rather than fancy topping combinations. Come in to build your own pizza or calzone, and stay for the cozy atmosphere.
The Vibe
Lucali has a very rustic dining area that will make you feel like you’re enjoying freshly-baked pizza in the countryside. Soft lighting, wood furniture and antique décor set the mood for dining on some of the best pizza in Brooklyn.
What to Order
Lucali is a great place to indulge in the best version of your favorite pie. Build your own pizza with classic toppings like pepperoni, sweet pepper and mushrooms, then kick back and relax in the quaint dining room.
Lucali | 575 Henry St., Brooklyn, NY 11231 | $$
8. Pepperoni Pizza at F&F Pizzeria
Close friends Frank Falcinelli and Frank Castronovo founded F&F Pizzeria in a converted garage in 2019. Although F&F Pizzeria is a relatively new kid on the block, they’ve made a name for themselves by serving some of the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY.
The Vibe
F&F Pizzeria embraces a personable, modern atmosphere. Indoor standing tables are available if you want a quick bite of the best pizza in Brooklyn, and outdoor seating is available for a more relaxed meal.
What to Order
F&F Pizzeria sticks to the classics as they strive to make the best pizza in Brooklyn, but they are anything but boring. For example, their pepperoni pizza is topped with Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes, pepperoni, mozzarella, Pecorino Romano and Sicilian oregano. Vegan and vegetarian options. are also available.
F&F Pizzeria | 459 Court St., Brooklyn, NY 11231 | $$
9. Vegan Pizza at Paulie Gee’s
If you like to have plenty of options when ordering, head over to Paulie Gee’s. This spot has a notoriously long menu that includes excellent choices for vegans and vegetarians.
The Vibe
Paulie Gee’s has a warm, friendly atmosphere. Their open kitchen allows visitors to watch the fascinating pizza-making process and with ambient lighting from the oven.
What to Order
Plant-based diners can still enjoy a bite of the best pizza in Brooklyn at Paulie Gee’s. Paulie Gee’s offers 10 exclusively vegan pizzas, and many of their mainstay options can be made vegetarian upon request.
Paulie Gee’s | 60 Greenpoint Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11222 | $$
10. Kind Brother Pizza at Speedy Romeo
Looking for a break from typical food halls in NYC? Featured for many years on the Michelin Guide’s list, this pizza restaurant in Brooklyn is named after the co-owners champion racing horse, Speedy Romeo.
The Vibe
Compared to your typical run-of-the-mill neighborhood pizza joint, this establishment is rather classy and upscale. At Speedy Romeo, you can enjoy the best pizza in Brooklyn surrounded by art, aged brick and candlelight.
What to Order
Speedy Romeo offers more than just some of the best wood-fired pizza in Brooklyn; there are also incredible steaks, fish and burgers. The Kind Brother pizza made with béchamel sauce, smoked mozzarella, wild mushroom, egg and sage is a top-notch option.
Speedy Romeo | 376 Classon Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11238 | $$
11. Everything Pizza at Giuseppina’s
This beloved pizzeria in South Slope is actually run by the owners of Lucali. However, Giuseppina’s delivers a slightly more modern dining experience with a shorter wait time.
The Vibe
Giuseppina’s dark and simple décor is like many other pizzerias in Brooklyn, but a touch of class is added with candlelit tables and a robust selection of beer and wine. Giuseppina’s is perfect for a casual dinner or first date.
What to Order
Why settle for one topping when you can have everything on the best pizza in Brooklyn? Giuseppina’s popular Everything Pizza features their house tomato sauce, Buffalo sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, olives, onions, shallots, peppers, portobello mushroom, fresh basil and garlic.
Giuseppina’s | 691 Sixth Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11215 | $$
12. Sicilian Square Pizza at L&B Spumoni Gardens
L&B Spumoni Gardens has a legendary reputation as one of the best pizza spots in NYC serving some of the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY.
The Vibe
This famous pizza restaurant offers plenty of seating to accommodate its countless fans. L&B is casual and unpretentious, with outdoor picnic tables and vinyl tablecloths. Don’t let the unassuming décor mislead you; these are some top-notch slices. Even those looking for Dyker Heights pizza will travel to grab a bite from this renowned gem.
What to Order
One of L&B Spumoni Gardens’ most notorious dishes is their square Sicilian pizza. Deliciously soft, spongey dough is topped with hot cheese, then bathed in tangy tomato sauce to create square slices of perfection.
L&B Spumoni Gardens | 2725 86th St., Brooklyn, NY 11223 | $
13. Emily Pizza at Emily
Emily is a pizzeria founded by a young couple with a passion for delicious food. In just a few short years, Emily has become highly praised for serving up some of the best pizza in Brooklyn.
The Vibe
No matter where you’re from, Emily will feel like home. The kitchen is quaint but welcoming, the patrons and staff are friendly, and the pizza is always piping hot and fresh.
What to Order
The restaurants' namesake dish, the Emily pizza, holds its own as one of the best pizzas in Brooklyn. A white pizza topped with mozzarella, pistachios, honey and truffle sottocenere, this pie showcases a combination of flavors you’ll never forget.
Emily | 919 Fulton St., Brooklyn, NY 11238 | $$
14. Colony² Pizza at Emmy Squared
Craving a Detroit-style pizza in NYC? You can have the best of both worlds at Emmy Squared. An offshoot of the wildly successful Emily restaurant, Emmy Squared offers more of the best pizza in Brooklyn with a delicious Detroit-style twist.
The Vibe
Emmy Squared’s Brooklyn location is decorated in a modern, artistic style that embraces creative spirit. This restaurant is still as comfortable and relaxed as Emily, but with a more sleek side.
What to Order
Emmy Squared is a perfect spot for lunch with a small group of friends. They offer many similar dishes to those served at Emily, including the Colony², a red-sauce pizza with mozzarella, pickled chili, hot honey and pepperoni. Check out their list of witty cocktails, too!
Emmy Squared | 364 Grand St., Brooklyn, NY 11211 | $$
15. By the Slice at Best Pizza
If you’re going to call yourself the best pizza in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, you’d better have the slices to back it up. Best Pizza lives up to its name with generous, tasty slices served up the best way: on paper plates.
The Vibe
Best Pizza keeps things simple in their humble pizza shop. Customer-drawn paper plate art decorates the walls of Best Pizza on Havemeyer Street, and the luminescent signage makes this place feel like a hidden gem.
What to Order
You can try a variety of the best pizzas in Brooklyn when you order by the slice. Havemeyer's Best Pizza offers big slices of cheese, pepperoni, white, Grandma and veggie pizza. For whole pies, opt for cheese or white with customizable toppings including anchovy, kale, caramelized onion, bacon and more.
Best Pizza | 33 Havemeyer St., Brooklyn, NY 11211 | $
16. Fresh Mozzarella Pie at Joe’s Pizza
Craving a greasy bite before you head home from the bar? Open until 3 a.m. on weekdays and 5 a.m. on weekends, Joe’s Pizza is one of the best places to eat in NYC late at night.
The Vibe
Known for serving some of the best pizza in Brooklyn, Joe’s Pizza is a humble and friendly shop that welcomes customers at all hours of the day and night. Checker-tiled countertops and fun photo-clad walls will make you feel right at home as you treat yourself to a slice of midnight pie.
What to Order
Sometimes the best things in life are simple, and the same goes for the best pizza in Brooklyn. A fresh mozzarella pie from Joe’s Pizza is like the cherry on top of a perfect evening. Pair it with a classic Coke and you’re as good as gold.
Joe’s Pizza | 216 Bedford Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11249 | $
17. Zucchini Pizza at Dellarocco’s Brick Oven Pizza
Dellarocco’s Brick Oven Pizza is still a lesser-known pizza establishment, but it's quickly rising in the ranks for the best pizza in Brooklyn. Located in the lovely Brooklyn Heights neighborhood, Dellarocco’s offers a wide range of menu items with consistent quality.
The Vibe
Dellarocco’s serves the best pizza in Brooklyn in a clean and open dining area. The interior design of Dellarocco’s is simple yet beautiful, with a full wine bar and bright, airy windows.
What to Order
Dellarocco might serve the best pizza in Brooklyn, but some of their options stand out from the rest. The Zucchini Pizza is a delightful white pizza made with zucchini cream, smoked prosciutto and mozzarella. In addition to plenty of omnivore options, Dellarocco’s also offers a few vegan pies.
Dellarocco’s Brick Oven Pizza | 214 Hicks St., Brooklyn, NY 11201 | $$
Join 200,000+ Culinary Enthusiasts
With its rich Italian heritage and plethora of pizzerias, you’re sure to discover some of the world’s best pizza in Brooklyn. From modern and classy pizza restaurants to Mom-and-Pop lunch shops, it's clear that Brooklyn is where you'll find the best pizza spots in NYC. Grab a slice and savor each bite as you absorb all the bustle of the city.
For even more fun ways to explore NYC and beyond, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.