27 Best Places to Host a Birthday Dinner in NYC

Published on December 1, 2021 | 0 Comments
birthday dinner in nyc
Published on December 1, 2021 | 0 Comments

Let’s be real: Everyone wants to have a fun, glamorous birthday dinner in NYC at least once in their life. What’s a better way to celebrate yourself than in one of the greatest cities in the world?

There is no shortage of cool places to eat for a birthday dinner in NYC, so it’s easy to plan an iconic night fit for stellar Instagram photos and even better food. 

Whether you’re looking for a nice restaurant in New York for an intimate night with your significant other or a party-like fun birthday restaurant in NYC, the options are almost endless. We’ve got a coveted list of all the best birthday restaurants in NYC from the classics to hidden gems no one else will tell you about. 

1. Michelin-Quality Experience at Home

Throw on some mood music, invite your closest friends and host an intimate dinner party with a private chef right in your own home. With tons of renowned private chefs in NYC, you can choose from elegant options like sophisticated seafood, a comforting New American feast or a fun Mexican fiesta. Your private chef does all of the work for you, from grocery shopping to kitchen cleanup. For an exquisitely gourmet birthday dinner in NYC, find a private chef near you and enjoy a deliciously unique experience for your special day.

via Cozymeal

2. NYC's Hidden Hotspots

Calling all foodies! Guided food tours in NYC are a fun twist on a birthday dinner that eliminates the stress of indecision and allows you to try hidden gems all over the neighborhood. Expert local guides will treat you to some of the coolest places to eat in NYC for a day of diverse, authentic dining. Finding food tours near you is an easy, completely unique way to treat yourself to an immersive birthday dinner in NYC. Schedule one in your own neighborhood, or head to a spot you haven’t yet explored, like Williamsburg, Hell’s Kitchen or the Lower East Side. 

3. The Boil

This is one of those places that people wait to get into for hours. No worries, though, they take reservations! The Boil is known for its over-the-top, mouthwatering Cajun-style seafood. If you’re looking to try something different for your birthday dinner in NYC, why not go somewhere where you can order a big, steaming bag of fresh Cajun king crab legs? Don your bib and dig in!

loster and crab legs at the boil nyc
via The Boil

4. Pastis

For a high-end birthday dinner in NYC that’s kind of like a trip to Paris, Pastis is the place to be. Order from a variety of fresh, aesthetically pleasing French dishes and delectable desserts. Cheers to Champagne and caviar!

5. The Polo Bar

After a year and a half stuck inside, it’s safe to say that you deserve a bougie, blowout birthday. If you’re looking for one of the most extravagant places to have a birthday dinner in NYC, it doesn’t get much more impressive than the Polo Bar. Gather your close friends and even some distant acquaintances, because the Polo Bar allows you to invite up to 20 guests for an exclusive private event, complete with customized menus and music.

the ralph lauren polo bar is a great place for a birthday dinner in nyc
via Ralph Lauren Polo Bar

6. Pana II Garden

If Chrissy Teigen could have her birthday dinner in NYC here, so can you. This colorful spot in the East Village is studded with streamers, twinkle lights and fun vibes. Enjoy Indian cuisines and don’t forget the Champagne, because Pana II Garden is BYOB!

7. While We Were Young

Make your dinner reservations during golden hour, and your birthday photos will be glowing. This airy, bright pink spot has floor-to-ceiling windows, drinks that look too pretty to consume and a million birthday photo-ops!

cocktails at while we were young in nyc
via While We Were Young

8. Jacob’s Pickles

For a more cozy birthday dinner in NYC, Jacob’s Pickles is a fan-favorite restaurant for groups in NYC. Their tagline is “Beer. Biscuits. Pickles,” and that’s pretty much all you need to know. This spot is rustic and great for a unique sort of comfort food, including fresh buttermilk biscuits and mac and cheese, root beer on tap, bacon beer and homemade jars of pickles that you can take home with you as birthday souvenirs.

9. Lil’ Frankie's 

Lil’ Frankie's is a staple of the East Village, another celeb-favorite and it’s one of the greatest restaurants for groups in NYC. Celebrate your birthday with heaping plates of their famous spaghetti and pass around authentic Naples pizzas.

lil frankie's is a great place to host a birthday dinner in nyc
via Lil' Frankie's

10. Corner Social

If you want to have a casual but fun birthday dinner in NYC, this Harlem hotspot is where you should be. There is almost always a DJ on the weekends, which attracts a crowd of down-to-earth people who just want to have fun. Treat yourself to delectable Mediterranean-inspired bites and strong, mouthwatering cocktails. Corner Social is certainly the kind of place to bring friends to, and if you don’t, you’re likely to make some during your stay!

11. Flour Shop

A birthday dinner in NYC should be whatever you want it to be. Dessert for dinner? Sure, it’s your birthday! For the most colorful of birthdays, head over to the Flour Shop, where you’ll find rainbow-colored pastries, cakes, macaroons and more. 

rainbow cakes and flour shop in nyc
via Flour Shop

12. The UES

The UES is the perfect example of a fun birthday restaurant in NYC because it’s a hidden gem, it has an awesome menu and it’ll make you feel like a VIP. When you walk in, you’ll be standing in what looks like a regular old ice cream shop. What you don’t know, however, is that a secret codeword (the “storage room”) will bring you to a speakeasy-esque bar fit for an iconic birthday dinner in NYC — it even has a dress code! You’ll enjoy cocktails that taste as unique as they look, including a bright pink "BIRTHDAY SUNDAE" topped with a fiery sparkler, of course.

13. The Blue Box Café

Instead of receiving a Tiffany-blue box as a gift, spend your birthday inside of one. Tiffany’s Blue Box Café is an Instagram-worthy café that’s perfect for birthday dinners in NYC, complete with afternoon tea, perfect pastries and elegant brunch dishes. 

tiffany's blue box cafe is an elegant place for a birthday dinner in nyc
via Tiffany's Blue Box Café

14. Gitano Garden of Love

Wish you could go anywhere but NYC for your birthday dinner? At Gitano Garden of Love, your birthday dinner in NYC will feel more like a birthday getaway to Tulum. At a sprawling outdoor patio, under the shade of leafy palm trees, you can chill between big canvas pillows and sip on a frozen mezcal margarita, just like you deserve to.

15. Claro

For warm, summer birthdays in NYC, make reservations at the backyard patio at Claro. Sit underneath the greenery and enjoy all of the authentic Mexican cuisine and cocktails — go for the frozen strawberry mezcal margarita!

eggs over pulled pork at claro in nyc
via Claro

16. Bernie’s

Slide on into a big, comfy booth and order all of your favorite comfort dinner foods, like mozzarella sticks, bacon cheeseburgers and chicken Parm. If you're spending your birthday dinner in NYC at Bernie’s, the night can only be completed with a big, classic ice-cream sundae. 

17. The Tyger

For a birthday dinner in NYC with a drool-worthy menu, The Tyger’s Asian-fusion dishes will surely not disappoint. Make reservations to sit at their heated outdoor patio or inside their bright, airy, industrial-chic dining area.

the tyger is a great place to host a birthday dinner in nyc
via The Tyger

18. Grand Banks

This sunny, waterfront oyster bar comes with stunning views and all the seafood you can eat. Have your birthday dinner in NYC here during the sunset, and you'll feel like you're on an island getaway.

19. Loulou

Known for its vibrant floral storefront, Loulou is a hip French bistro with food and drinks that look like pure art. You might even get to meet the famous Loulou, the restaurant owner’s adorable pooch. 

steak on a cutting board at loulou nyc
via Loulou

20. Xiang Hot Pot

Calling all hungry party-goers! At Xiang Hot Pot, enjoy an all-you-can-eat hot pot birthday dinner in NYC perfect for a crowd. Did we mention it’s on a rooftop patio?

21. Wild Ink

Everything about this upscale bar is eye-catching, including the Asian-American-inspired cuisine. For a restaurant for groups in NYC, Wild Ink is popular not only because of its elegance, but because a lazy Susan is conveniently placed in the middle of larger tables!

wild ink is a fun place for a birthday dinner in nyc
via Wild Ink

22. Wu’s Wonton King

Another great group dinner spot, complete with lazy Susans on the table for an optimal sharing experience. Celebrate your birthday with some of NYC’s best, authentic wontons and Cantonese cuisine. Pack your favorite bottle of red, because Wu’s Wonton King is BYOB.

23. Telly’s Taverna

For a birthday dinner in NYC that feels like a vacation, Telly’s Taverna is the place to be. Step inside of this bright white Greek oasis, order some insanely good fresh fish and you’ll be transported straight to the Mediterranean. It’s the next best thing to a birthday celebration in Mykonos.

whole roasted fish at telly's taverna
via Telly's Taverna

24. Fish Cheeks

Gather your loved ones for a family-style Thai birthday dinner in NYC. Fish Cheeks served huge platters of all your favorite Thai cuisine, and the atmosphere is sunny, colorful and birthday-perfect.

25. Insa

There are so many cool things about this Korean BBQ spot in Brooklyn. Don’t worry about your NYC birthday dinner being undercooked, because you get to cook it yourself on grills built into your table. The best part? Insa is also home to a swanky cocktail karaoke bar! Bring your friends for a night to remember.

insa is a fun place to host a birthday dinner in nyc
via Insa

26. Forlini’s

This long-standing classic spot serves exactly what you want for an indulgent birthday dinner in NYC: heaping platefuls of authentic Italian food. It’s family-style, but we won’t tell if you have the entire chicken Parm to yourself — it’s your birthday, after all.

27. City Vineyard

If you’re a major social butterfly and can’t find a spot to host all of your friends for your birthday dinner in NYC, City Vineyard’s massive rooftop will do just fine. Toss back bottles of wine and watch the sunset over the Hudson River. Best birthday ever!

buffalo cauliflower and mac and cheese at city vineyard
via City Vineyard

Do It Big for Your Birthday Dinner in NYC

When doing a birthday dinner in NYC, go big or go home. That is, don’t pick a boring place when there are so many unique restaurants in New York. On your search for birthday dinner restaurants in NYC, you’re bound to come across tons of fun options, so be sure to save your discarded choices for a date night in NYC or another special occasion.

For even more fun ways to celebrate a birthday dinner in NYC, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.

About Cozymeal

Discover the best in culinary experiences and products on Cozymeal: From in-person cooking classes to virtual cooking & mixology classes to private chef experiences and top-rated cookware — from world-class chefs, mixologists & more.

View All Experiences & Cookware on Cozymeal