Best Pizza in NYC: 31 Top Pizza Places in 2024
Are you on a mission to find the very best pizza in NYC? With all the incredible options, finding the best pizza in NYC can feel like an intimidating venture.
New York City has no shortage of legendary slice shops and up-and-coming hotspots, so navigating the world of NYC pizza can be hard without any direction.
Luckily, this rundown is the perfect place to start. Whether you’re an NYC local on the prowl for a new go-to pie or are visiting the Big Apple on the ultimate pizza pilgrimage, this list is sure to help make sure you hit all the best pizza spots in New York.
If you want to optimize your NYC pizza experience, read on and get ready to taste the finest of NYC one mouth-watering slice at a time.
Jump to Section
Find the Best Pizza in NYC
If you want a hands-on experience that will truly envelop you in the world of the best pizza in NYC, embark on one of the many food tours in NYC. Led by a local culinary expert, these NYC food tours will introduce you to can’t-miss hidden gems around the city, while also teaching you about local history.
For pizza enthusiasts that want an immersive experience that’s equal parts educational and delicious, cooking classes in NYC are the perfect activity. Led by an experienced chef, you’ll learn the secrets and techniques that go into creating NYC’s most iconic food.
The Best Pizza in New York City: 31 Top Pizzerias
1. L&B Spumoni Gardens
Specializing in their signature Sicilian-style square pizza, L&B Spumoni Gardens has been serving up some of the best pizza in NYC since 1939. This spot is a quintessential Brooklyn pizzeria and no list of the most delicious NYC foods would be complete without it.
Whether you prefer a crispy corner slice or a cheesy cut from the center, enjoying a slice at L&B Spumoni Gardens is a can’t-miss experience for pizza enthusiasts.
The Vibe
A fun and relaxed old-school pizzeria, with cafeteria-style seating outside.
What to Order
Keep it classic and go with a Sicilian pie, which has long been considered one of the best pizzas in NYC.
L&B Spumoni Gardens | Multiple Locations | $
2. Una Pizza Napoletana
If you’re looking for some of the best Neapolitan-style pizzas in NYC, take a trip down to Una Pizza Napoletana in the Lower East Side for some delectable pies that are nothing short of legendary.
Una Pizza Napoletana has been through multiple redesigns and locations but one thing has remained unchanged: Chef Anthony Mangieri makes some of the best pizza in NYC and you won’t want to miss out on his memorable, mouthwatering pies.
The Vibe
Una Pizza Napoletana is only open three days a week, so expect to have to wait a bit for a table if you’re not able to book a reservation.
What to Order
You can’t go wrong with a classic marinara pie. The Margherita pie is also thought to be one of the best pizzas in NYC.
Una Pizza Napoletana | 175 Orchard St., New York, NY 10002 | $$
3. Paulie Gee’s
The epitome of a New York City slice shop, Paulie Gee’s is a Brooklyn institution that’s famous for their flavorful and unique slices. Paulie Gee’s compliments their legendary wood-fired pizza with an approachable ambiance that perfectly sets the scene for one of the best pizza experiences in NYC.
The Vibe
A cool and rustic atmosphere that draws hungry crowds of tourists and locals.
What to Order
Keep things simple with the cheese slice or go with the Hellboy, which is a pepperoni pie topped with a hefty drizzle of hot honey.
Paulie Gee’s | 110 Franklin St., Brooklyn, NY 11222 | $
4. Mama’s Too!
Once the Upper West Side’s best-kept secret, Mama’s Too recently expanded its empire to a new downtown location, introducing a new flock of lucky locals to some of the very best pizza in NYC.
Featuring an inventive menu of eclectic square pies and slices, Mama’s Too drew crowds of influencers and bloggers to its new location to see what all the hype was about. As it turned out, the hype was very real, as Mama’s Too quickly joined the ranks of one of the best pizza spots in NYC.
The Vibe
This bustling pizza spot gets crowded during peak hours and the uptown location has no indoor seating but they do have some tables outside. The West Village location is bigger with more indoor seating.
What to Order
Don’t miss out on the house pie or the poached pear pie, which is topped with aged mozzarella and gorgonzola cheese. If you need a break from pizza, their signature sandwiches are constantly going viral online.
Mama’s Too! | Multiple Locations | $
5. John’s of Bleecker Street
Serving up some of the best pizza in NYC since 1929, John’s of Bleecker Street is synonymous with the New York City pizza scene. This sit-down pizzeria churns out thin-crust, coal-oven-fired pies — no slices — to a packed dining room of locals and in-the-know tourists. A neighborhood staple of Greenwich Village, dining at John’s undoubtedly offers some of the best pizza in NYC.
The Vibe
A bustling, old-school pizzeria with plenty of tables and plenty of lines. This place serves pies only, so if you want a quick slice you’re better off somewhere else.
What to Order
Top one of John’s famous pizzas with the toppings of your choice, like sausage, pepperoni or fresh basil.
John’s of Bleecker Street | 278 Bleecker St., New York, NY | 10014
6. L’Industrie Pizza
The wildly popular L'Industrie Pizza unquestionably makes some of the best pizza in NYC, showcasing an imaginative menu of flavorful slices and pies. What started as a Williamsburg hotspot has made its way to Downtown Manhattan and pizza-lovers all over the city are constantly flocking to either location for a taste of some of the very best pizza in NYC.
The Vibe
A popular slice shop with fast-moving lines. Slices are only available in-store but you can order whole pies to enjoy at home.
What to Order
You won’t want to miss out on the burrata pie and the L’Industrie Pie, topped with prosciutto and burrata, is also one of the best pizzas in NYC.
L’Industrie Pizza | Multiple Locations | $$
7. Lucali
Simply put, Lucali makes some of the best pizza in Brooklyn, which means that Lucali makes some of the greatest pizza in the world. That claim isn’t an understatement, as countless critics and television programs have highlighted Mark Iacono’s legendary Carroll Gardens pizzeria as a global masterpiece. Perfectly simple and flawlessly fresh, Lucali sets the standard for NYC pizza.
The Vibe
Lucali is a homey and down-to-earth pizzeria with extensive wait times. They start taking names for the waitlist at 4 P.M., so make sure to get there early.
What to Order
Lucali makes some of the best pizza in NYC, so don’t overthink this one. Go with a signature pie and add a couple toppings if you wish.
Lucali | 575 Henry St., Brooklyn, NY 11231 | $$
8. Ops
For some of the best pizza in New York, head over to Bushwick and pay a visit to Ops, whose sourdough crusts have served as a delicious base for some of the very best pizza in NYC. Featuring an assortment of craft cocktails and small plates, Ops is more than just a simple neighborhood pizzeria but it’s no secret that the pizza is the undisputed star of the show.
The Vibe
This cozy and casual Brooklyn restaurant features exposed brick walls, creating a cool and comforting ambiance.
What to Order
The simple marinara pie is one of the best pizzas in NYC but if you’re feeling adventurous go with the Juno pie, which is topped with broccoli rabe, potatoes and cheese.
Ops | 346 Himrod St., Brooklyn, NY 11237 | $$
9. Di Fara
Legendary pizza Chef Dom DeMarco, who stood behind the counter at Di Fara making pizza by hand since he opened his shop in 1965, sadly passed away in 2022. Thankfully, his family has taken over the reins of the tiny Brooklyn shop that makes some of the best pizza in NYC. This no-frills pizzeria takes flavor seriously and their signature thin-crust slices are as beloved by foodies across the city as they are by neighborhood locals.
The Vibe
An old-school pizza shop with plenty of charm. There’s very limited seating inside, so prepare to take your slices to go.
What to Order
The regular pie is one of the best pizzas in NYC. It’s topped with fresh basil, olive oil and multiple types of cheese.
Di Fara | Multiple Locations | $
10. Scarr’s Pizza
Scarr’s Pizza is a cult-favorite Lower East Side pizzeria that slings out some of the best thin-crust pizza in NYC. Scarr’s grinds their own flour for their signature crust, creating a shockingly flavorful crust that creates layers of satisfying bites for diners making their way through a Scarr’s slice. The retro vibes at Scarr’s are balanced by the innovative and modern menu, forming a delicious dichotomy that’s perfectly New York.
The Vibe
For those wanting to skip the long lines, be sure to make a reservation at this trendy and hip pizza shop with attractive retro décor.
What to Order
Order the regular slice with pepperoni and enjoy one of the best pizzas in NYC.
Scarr’s Pizza | 35 Orchard St., New York, NY 10002 | $
11. Cuts & Slices
Specializing in an imaginative assortment of unique toppings, Cuts & Slices is taking the five boroughs by storm with their Brooklyn and Queens locations. Cuts & Slices make some of the best New York-style pizza in NYC but they elevate the norm with their creative flavors like the chopped cheese pizza and the Internet-famous oxtail slice. It may not be your grandfather’s neighborhood pizzeria but Cuts & Slices is responsible for some of the best pizza in NYC.
The Vibe
A chill and stylish grab-and-go slice shop with a viral following, so don’t be surprised if there’s a line.
What to Order
Their jerk barbecue salmon slices are considered some of the best pizza in NYC. You’ll also want to experience the chicken & waffle slice.
Cuts & Slices | Multiple Locations | $
12. Patsy’s Pizzeria
Wonderfully old-school and undoubtedly unique, Patsy’s Pizzeria is an East Harlem staple that’s undisputedly one of the best pizza places in New York. Patsy’s uses a coal-fired oven, which gives their signature crust a unique, delicious char, which combined with their fresh ingredients and tangy sauce creates one of the best pizza slices in NYC. Simply put, a slice of Patsy’s pizza is a slice of NYC history.
The Vibe
An old-school, classic pizzeria that feels like the quintessential neighborhood spot.
What to Order
Keep things nice and simple with the timeless plain slice.
Patsy’s Pizzeria | 2287 First Ave., New York, NY 10035 | $
13. Roberta’s
Roberta’s makes some of the best pizza in NYC by focusing on fresh, local ingredients and traditional techniques. This cult-favorite pizzeria started in Brooklyn but it's since expanded to multiple locations across the country. Roberta’s has a deep influence on the world of pizza but make no mistake — their New York roots run deep and they run delicious.
The Vibe
A modern and funky ambiance with a hip clientele.
What to Order
The Grateful Red is a groovy pie packed with flavor. You also can’t go wrong with the classic margherita, one of the best pizzas pies in NYC.
Roberta’s | Multiple Locations | $$
14. Joe’s Pizza
One of the city’s most beloved slice shops, Joe’s Pizza in Greenwich Village has been serving up some of the best pizza in Manhattan since 1975. The epitome of an authentic New York street slice, Joe’s Pizza is a staple for lunchtime diners and late night revelers who want a timeless experience of eating some of the best pizza in NYC amongst a crowd of hungry strangers.
The Vibe
Joe's is a traditional counter-service slice shop that’s a popular late night spot on the weekends.
What to Order
The plain slice is one of the best pizza slices in NYC and the fresh mozzarella slice is a crowd favorite as well.
Joe’s Pizza | 7 Carmine St., New York, NY 10014 | $
15. Rubirosa
Rubirosa might be known for having some of the best pizza in NYC but their Nolita operation has grown into one of the top full-fledged Italian restaurants in the city. That being said, most of the diners at this super popular eatery are coming for the pizza — a perfectly crispy pie packed with deep layers of flavor. Rubirosa pies look just as good as they taste but it’s unlikely you’ll have enough patience to take a picture.
The Vibe
A bustling restaurant that draws long wait times, if you can’t manage to snag a reservation, make sure to put your name down early.
What to Order
The visually striking Tie Dye pizzas, which feature vodka sauce, tomato sauce, pesto and fresh mozzarella, are some of the best pizza pies in NYC.
Rubirosa | 235 Mulberry St., New York, NY 10012 | $$
16. Prince Street Pizza
Lovers of pepperoni should immediately make their way to Prince Street Pizza, a Downtown NYC pizzeria that makes some of the finest pepperoni slices in New York. Prince Street does a lot of things well but it’s their square pepperoni slice that’s been making waves amongst pizza enthusiasts across the globe. The delectable cups of pepperoni get flooded with flavor, creating a series of unforgettable bites.
The Vibe
This neighborhood favorite serves up some of the best pizza in NYC in a no-frills, easygoing setting.
What to Order
If you’re a fan of pepperoni, get a square of Spicy Spring. If you don’t eat meat, the Prince Perfection pie is a winning choice.
Prince Street Pizza | 27 Prince St., New York, NY 10012 | $$
17. Fumo
Known for their elevated takes on pizza and other Italian comfort food staples, Fumo is a restaurant that proudly serves some of the best pizza in NYC in an intimate and modern setting.
Pizza shouldn’t be the only thing you order at Fumo but you won’t want to miss out on it. If you like your pizza with a side of baked clams and fresh focaccia, Fumo is the spot for you.
The Vibe
A contemporary restaurant with dimmed lights and top-notch service.
What to Order
Sip a glass of wine while enjoying a margherita pizza. The Buffalo chicken pizza is also one of the most beloved pizza pies in NYC.
Fumo | Multiple Locations | $$
18. Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern
Step aside Manhattan and Brooklyn, because some of the best pizza in NYC is located in the heart of Staten Island. Denino’s is a landmark pizzeria and tavern that churns out legendary thin-crust pies in a no-frills environment that’s packed with devoted locals. Sit down, order a beer and some fresh calamari and wait patiently for one of the best pizzas in NYC. Could it possibly get any better than that?
The Vibe
Denino’s is a casual, no-nonsense bar and restaurant that’s popular with both locals and tourists.
What to Order
Order a pizza with your favorite toppings, like fresh garlic, meatballs and mushrooms.
Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern | 542 Port Richmond Ave., Staten Island, NY 10302 | $$
19. Bleecker Street Pizza
The West Village has no shortage of legendary pizza spots but Bleecker Street Pizza has maintained their position at the front of the pack. This authentic slice shop makes some of the best thin-crust pizza in NYC and with plenty of seating inside, it’s the perfect place to grab lunch with friends from out of town who are seeking NYC pizza perfection.
The Vibe
A classic counterservice pizzeria with a lot of indoor seating.
What to Order
The regular slice is one of the best pizza slices in NYC but if you’re particularly hungry the chicken bacon ranch pizza slice is a popular option.
Bleecker Street Pizza | 69 Seventh Ave., New York, NY 10014 | $
20. Emmy Squared
Serving anything but classic New York-style pizza in the Big Apple can be considered blasphemous but Emmy Squared came in hot with their Detroit-style square pizza and never looked back.
Now, with nearly 30 locations, Emmy Squared has come a long way since their Williamsburg beginnings but no matter how far they grow, this classic spot will always be home to some of the best pizza in NYC.
The Vibe
A fun and casual place, with beers on tap. Perfect for a quick and easy weeknight date.
What to Order
This spot makes some of the best pizza in NYC but their burger is also considered one of the top in the city.
Emmy Squared | Multiple Locations | $$
21. Rocco’s of Roc Beach
Considered by many critics to be the best pizza spot in Queens, Rocco’s of Roc Beach treats locals to delicious coal-brick-oven pizzas in a fun and festive atmosphere. Everything on the menu is made from scratch, so all the food at Rocco’s — including the pizza, of course — is worth the trip over to Rockaway Beach. This might be the best pizza spot in NYC that you’ve never been to but it’s definitely time to change that.
The Vibe
A family-oriented Italian restaurant near the beach with friendly service and a fun ambiance.
What to Order
Don’t skip the margherita pie or the spicy meatball pie.
Rocco’s of Roc Beach | 115-10 Rockaway Beach Blvd., Rockaway, NY 11694 | $$
22. Louie and Ernie’s Pizza
The essential neighborhood spot, Louie and Ernie’s thin-crust pies and slices have been feeding hungry Bronx locals for nearly 65 years. Perfectly bare bones and unpretentious, Louie and Ernie’s is everything people love about the best pizza spots in NYC. It’s easy, homey and most importantly, delicious.
The Vibe
A casual neighborhood pizza joint that’s a favorite amongst locals.
What to Order
The white slice is one of the best pizza slices in NYC and the calzones are also delicious if you want to change things up.
Louie and Ernie’s Pizza | 1300 Crosby Ave., Bronx, NY 10461 | $
23. Luigi’s Pizza
Luigi’s Pizza in Brooklyn is quite simply one of the best pizza places in New York. Located near the Green-Wood Cemetery, Luigi’s has been serving picture-perfect New York slices for over 50 years and they’ve perfected the art of thin-crust pizza. A classic establishment that makes some of the best pizza in NYC, Luigi’s is a must-visit for pizza fans making their way through Brooklyn.
The Vibe
Luigi’s Pizza has an old-school ambiance with a charming neighborhood feel.
What to Order
The fresh mozzarella slice is considered to be one of the best pizza slices in NYC.
Luigi’s Pizza | 686 Fifth Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11215 | $
24. Lee’s Tavern
Hop on the ferry, because the classic bar pie at Staten Island’s Lee’s Tavern is one of the best pizzas in NYC. Lee’s Tavern is a community staple they’re dishing out perfectly poured pints and delicious pizzas to their loyal customer base every day and night, creating a friendly atmosphere that’s perfect for a pizza-packed gathering.
The Vibe
A neighborhood bar that’s crowded with locals and a select few of ferry-riding pizza enthusiasts from Manhattan.
What to Order
Locals swear by the white clam pie; listen to the locals.
Lee’s Tavern | 60 Hancock St., Staten Island, NY 10305 | $
25. Totonno’s
Serving some of the best pizza in NYC for over 90 years, it’s safe to say that the experts over at Totonno’s know what they’re doing. This legendary Coney Island pizzeria has been featured on countless media platforms, including the hit Netflix series “Somebody Feed Phil,” and given the longevity of the historical space and the deliciousness of the pizza, it’s no surprise that Totonno’s continues to maintain their standing as one of the best pizza spots in NYC.
The Vibe
A quaint and cozy neighborhood pizzeria that’s the definition of old-school.
What to Order
For the full Totonno’s experience, go with a red pie and a white pie.
Totonno’s | 1524 Neptune Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11224 | $$
26. Best Pizza
For some of the best pizza in NYC served in a hip and retro space, head over to the aptly named Best Pizza in Brooklyn. The aesthetic is based on the classic pizzerias from the 80s and 90s and the simple, minimalist menu of flavorful toppings makes a trip to Best Pizza equal parts nostalgic and simple.
The Vibe
Best Pizza gives off cool retro vibes based on the no-frills neighborhood slice shops from the 80s and 90s.
What to Order
Top a cheese or white pie with your favorite toppings and dig in!
Best Pizza | Multiple Locations | $$
27. Speedy Romeo
For some of the most inventive pies and slices in New York, take a trip to Speedy Romeo in Brooklyn. This imaginative pizza spot features toppings like pastrami, figs and sauerkraut, creating a pizza experience that defies tradition and embraces a flavorful future. If you need a changeup from the classic slice shop, Speedy Romeo is home to some of the best pizza in NYC.
The Vibe
A cool neighborhood spot located in a refurbished auto parts shop, featuring self-described “kitschy” décor and plenty of modern character.
What to Order
The Paul’s Boutique pie is one of the most unique pizza pies in NYC. It features an everything bagel crust topped with pastrami, sauerkraut and thousand island dressing.
Speedy Romeo | 376 Classon Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11238 | $$
28. NY Pizza Suprema
Just outside of the hustle and bustle of Penn Station is NY Pizza Suprema, a popular slice shop that makes one of the best pizzas in NYC. Whether you’re taking the train from Long Island or New Jersey or catching a game or concert at Madison Square Garden, a trip to NY Pizza Suprema is an essential part of any midtown excursion.
The Vibe
A traditional slice shop that draws considerable midtown crowds, especially when there’s an event at MSG.
What to Order
Go with a classic margherita slice or take a bold turn with the hot honey slice.
NY Pizza Suprema | 413 Eighth Ave., New York, NY 10001 | $
29. Motorino
One of the best places for pizza in NYC, Motorino is a Neapolitan-style pizzeria and restaurant with multiple locations throughout the city. From the dark, elegant vibes to the wonderfully crispy pies, Motorino offers the quintessential NYC dining experience, making it a perfect spot for a date night or casual lunch.
The Vibe
Motorino is cozy and chic, with rustic and stylish décor. It’s a sit-down restaurant but you can order their pizzas to-go.
What to Order
The margherita pizza is one of the best pizzas in NYC and the Brussels sprout pie is a solid choice if you want your fix of veggies.
Motorino | Multiple Locations | $$
30. Andrew Bellucci’s Pizzeria
Hitting all of the best pizza spots across the five boroughs is on every foodie’s bucket list of things to do in NYC and no conversation about the best pizza in NYC would be complete without including Andrew Belucci’s Pizzeria in Queens. This Astoria gem is a haven for pizza enthusiasts, serving up classic NY-style pies in a pleasing, easygoing environment.
The Vibe
A bright and airy space with a friendly, neighborhood atmosphere.
What to Order
The fresh-shucked clam pie is beloved by locals and anything with the house’s signature vodka is sure to be one of the best pizza experiences in NYC.
Andrew Bellucci’s Pizzeria | 37-08 30th Ave., Astoria, NY 11103 | $$
31. Pugsley’s Pizza
A popular hangout for students at Fordham University, Pugsley’s Pizza is an easygoing restaurant that makes some of the best thin-crust pizzas in NYC. This Bronx institution has been serving the community since 1984 and they’ve established themselves as a perfect place to enjoy a pint of beer while chowing down on a flawless New York-style pie.
The Vibe
Popular with Fordham University students and locals alike, Pugsley’s is the quintessential neighborhood hangout.
What to Order
Feeling hungry? Treat yourself to the penne vodka pizza, which tastes just as glorious as it sounds.
Pugsley’s Pizza | 590 E. 191st St., Bronx, NY 10458
Join 200,000+ Culinary Enthusiasts
It’s hard to go wrong when it comes to finding the best pizza place in NYC but with all the legendary spots, a little guidance never hurts. Hopefully, this list can help you seek out your new favorite spot or lead you to revisit a favorite from your younger days.
The world of NYC pizza is constantly expanding, with new slice shops popping up that honor the pies of the past while writing the tasty tales of the future. That balance of tradition and innovation is one of the best qualities of pizza in NYC and it’s what helps New York maintain its standing as the pinnacle of pizza.
For even more fun ways to explore NYC and beyond, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.