45 Best Crumbl Cookie Flavors in 2024
Are you ready to dive into the ever-expanding world of Crumbl Cookie flavors and discover which cookies you can't miss trying? Founded by two cousins with a single dream of creating the perfect chocolate chip cookie, Crumbl Cookies is a bakery business that grew from humble roots into the popular chain it is today.
Specializing in perfect gourmet cookies, it has an impressive offering of over 200 delicious Crumbl Cookie flavors. What makes the brand unique is the fact that its rotating menu features only six flavors at a time.
To help make sure you don’t miss the best flavors that Crumbl Cookies has to offer, we’ve gathered a list of the 45 most popular cookies. Whether you’ve just discovered Crumbl or you’ve been a long-time fan, we’ve got the ultimate guide to this family bakery chain’s extensive menu of delicious gourmet cookies.
Jump to Section
- How Does Crumbl Cookies Work?
- The 45 Best Crumbl Cookies Flavors
- What Are the Crumbl Cookie Flavors This Week?
- Learn How to Bake
How Does Crumbl Cookies Work?
Crumbl Cookies releases six new flavors every week. This means that while flavors will come back into the rotation, you can't get them all the time. Crumbl Cookies promotes the current cookies available on the Crumbl Cookies website and social media platforms. Simply check these channels to see what's on offer or be surprised by going directly to a Crumbl Cookies store. If you're in the U.S., you can also get Crumbl Cookies delivered.
The 45 Best Crumbl Cookies Flavors
1. Milk Chocolate Chip
At the franchise’s beginning, Milk Chocolate Chip was the first and only Crumbl Cookie flavor. This traditional flavor simply can’t be beat, with a lovely balance of chocolate chips and cookie dough. If this appears on the menu, make sure you order at least one!
2. Brownie Batter
Chocolate lovers will rejoice at the rich flavor and texture if Brownie Batter, all reminiscent of a brownie complete with chocolate chips on top. Crisp on the outside and as comfortingly gooey as a fresh-baked brownie on the inside, this cookie is sure to put you in a good mood!
3. Classic Pink Sugar
This beloved Crumbl Cookie flavor was a menu staple alongside Milk Chocolate Chip for years and for good reason! Classic Pink Sugar is a flawless sugar cookie with a delicate buttery softness to it, topped with an artful spread of pink frosting that adds harmonious notes of almond and vanilla.
4. Ultimate Peanut Butter
When it comes to one of the best Crumbl cookie flavors in existence, Ultimate Peanut Butter lives up to its name. It features a salty peanut butter filling and the cookie is also dipped in sugar and topped with peanut butter drizzle — it’s truly an ultimate peanut butter lover’s dream. Craving a similar alternative when Ultimate Peanut Butter isn’t on the menu? Try whipping up some gluten-free peanut butter cookies and drizzle them with peanut butter for a similar experience.
5. Cookie Dough
There’s something special about Cookie Dough at Crumbl. Order it and you'll get to bite into a sweet and rich brown sugar cookie, topped with an expertly whipped buttercream in a flavor that emanates the smoothness of ice cream. And of course, enjoy a generous amount of cookie dough chunks and chocolate chips across the top of the cookie.
6. Snickerdoodle Cupcake
For many, this next Crumbl Cookie flavor is a warm and comforting favorite. Snickerdoodle Cupcake is a twist on Crumbl’s original Snickerdoodle cookie. It features a vanilla sugar cookie base with a mesmerizing swirl of cream cheese frosting and cinnamon sugar on top to complete its upgrade to cupcake status.
7. Confetti Cake
If you love cookies but your favorite dessert is cake, Crumbl has still got you covered. Crumbl’s Confetti Cake wraps a cake batter-flavored sugar cookie up with a luscious swirl of cream cheese frosting and fun celebratory sprinkles to finish. This one often rolls back around during holidays and be sure to grab at least one when it is on the menu.
8. German Chocolate Cake
Continuing with the chocolate cake theme, German Chocolate Cake is our next Crumbl Cookie flavor pick. This is another very sweet chocolate cookie, with the added benefit of being filled with rich melted chocolate and topped with caramel-coconut frosting and milk chocolate drizzle. It’s perfect for equal fans of cakes and cookies.
9. Carrot Cake
This is a delicious Crumbl Cookie flavor that captures the nuances of carrot cake in a warm and convenient cookie. Every bite promises an even layer of spiced carrot cake cookie, Crumbl’s classic swirl of cream cheese frosting and a masterful line of crunchy pecans. It’s a work of art and a must-try when it appears back on the menu.
10. Dulce de Leche
Satisfy your dulce de leche craving with this cookie-style take. This Crumbl Cookie flavor features a well-spiced cinnamon base topped with sweet dulce de leche cream cheese and, of course, velvety warm dulce de leche. Not currently on the menu? Bake your own dulce de leche cookies in the meantime.
11. Maple Bacon
Skipped breakfast? Not to worry. This Crumbl Cookie flavor is a savory sweet medley of both breakfast and dessert. True to its name, Maple Bacon starts with a fluffy buttermilk base that’s topped with sweet maple frosting, a drizzle of maple syrup and some warm and salty bacon bits to finish.
12. Gingersnap
Get your ginger fix with this next Crumbl Cookie flavor, which combines the sweet and spice of a snappy gingerbread dough with the comfort of a thick, soft cookie. To finish, it’s dusted with sugar and white chocolate drizzle. For an alternative take, try this recipe for gluten-free ginger cookies.
13. Honey Cake ft. Teddy Grahams
This next flavor is perfect as a nostalgic treat. When it comes to Crumbl Cookies flavors ranked highest in terms of viral videos, Honey Cake ft. Teddy Grahams takes the cake as a TikTok hit. It’s made with a graham-flavored base, honey butter frosting, honey drizzle and of course, adorable Teddy Graham crackers.
14. Hawaiian Rainbow Cake
For a snack sure to inspire great joy, try Hawaiian Rainbow Cake as your next Crumbl Cookie flavor. It’s built on a cake-like cookie base with a perfect balance of butter and vanilla flavors before getting topped off with a thick zigzag of coconut cream cheese dyed beautifully in colors of the rainbow.
15. Blueberry Crumb Cake
If fruit flavors are your style, try this Crumbl Cookie flavor when it returns to the rotation. Blueberry Crumb Cake combines a tangy lemon graham cookie base with notes of sweet blueberries and a delicate lemon glaze on top.
16. Aggie Blue Mint
This Crumbl Cookie flavor pays homage to the bakery founders’ roots at Utah State University by sharing a name with the school’s mascot and featuring favors inspired by the campus creamery. Take a decadent bite into the Aggie Blue Mint cookie and you’ll get to savor a cream-flavored base with a gorgeous and refreshingly blue mint frosting.
17. Cookie Butter Ice Cream ft. Biscoff
Think regular Biscoff cookie butter, then multiply it. This classic and reliable flavor features a crunchy buttery Biscoff cookie filled with smooth cookie butter, topped with a fluffy spread and a delightful crumble. There's also a version of this cookie with the addition of white chocolate chips, which is just as indulgent and delicious.
18. Funfetti Milkshake
Take a visit back to simpler days with a sweet Funfetti Milkshake cookie. This sugar cookie is baked with colorful sprinkles, frosted with birthday cake-flavored buttercream and topped with whipped cream. Not in this week’s rotation? Indulge anyway by baking your own funfetti cookies.
19. S’mores
Take a trip back to your last campfire with this next Crumbl Cookie flavor which gets every morsel right. The S’mores cookie starts off strong with a chocolate chip and soft graham cracker base that gets topped off with perfectly toasted marshmallows, a chocolate drizzle and sweet graham cracker crumbs.
20. Midnight Mint
For fans of mint chocolate ice cream, this is the cookie to match. Midnight Mint is an exciting Crumbl Cookie flavor that sees a rich chocolate cookie baked with a filling of both mint green and semi-sweet chocolate chips. Fun fact: this is Crumbl’s first specialty cookie of its kind!
21. French Toast
This Crumbl Cookie flavor is a winner for anyone who likes their breakfast on the sweet side. Take a bite of French Toast and taste how it goes all out with a cinnamon egg wash, smooth buttercream, a sweet syrup drizzle and a dusting of powdered sugar to finish.
22. Monster ft. M&M's Candies
The name may sound daunting but don’t worry, Crumbl’s Monster lives up to its name in the best of ways. This concoction is laden with peanut butter chips, M&M's, semi-sweet chocolate chunks and oats. Welcome to the cookie made for those who love a little bit of everything.
23. Key Lime Pie
If you’ve been wanting a taste of summer, Key Lime Pie is the Crumbl Cookie flavor for you. It’s tart, sweet and best served chilled. This pretty graham cookie comes with graham crumbs, fluffy whipped cream, a fresh lime slice and a satisfying key lime pie filling as its center.
24. Strawberry Cheesecake
For a sweet and fruity treat, try the melt-in-your-mouth Strawberry Cheesecake Crumbl Cookie flavor. You’ll get to enjoy the balance of a chilled graham cracker cookie with a topping of heavenly vanilla cream cheese frosting and sweet strawberry jam.
25. Pumpkin Pie
For more of an autumnal vibe, try Crumbl's Pumpkin Pie. It features an expertly baked pie crust cookie with a decadent pumpkin pie filling and finishes up beautifully with fresh whipped cream.
26. Raspberry Danish
A newer addition to the family of Crumbl Cookie flavors, this cookie transforms the best of a flaky raspberry Danish into its worthy cookie counterpart. Each bite starts with a classic butter cookie base filled with smooth cream cheese before getting topped with raspberry jam and a sweet vanilla glaze.
27. Peach Pie
To continue with the pie theme, this next Crumbl Cookie flavor captures your favorite fruity pie in an easier handheld format. Bite into a buttery pie crust cookie with a dollop of creamy buttercream and sweet and tangy peach pie filling on top.
28. Sea Salt Toffee
Take a visit to the seaside with this Crumbl Cookie flavor. Best served warm, sea salt toffee is a cozy twist on Crumbl’s Classic Milk Chocolate Chip. Along with chocolate chips, this version adds decadent butterscotch toffee pieces into the mix to create the perfect sweet and salty cookie.
29. Caramel Popcorn
Transport yourself back to your last town fair or carnival with this next comforting flavor, which perfectly encapsulates the sweet and savory popcorn treat. Each bite of Caramel Popcorn brings you a heavenly butter cookie base underneath a thick swirl of caramel frosting, warm caramel drizzle and well-placed pieces of deliciously crunchy caramel corn.
30. Eggnog
Back in 2022, this delicious Crumbl Cookie flavor was first released during the holiday season. Made for eggnog lovers, this chilled eggnog sugar cookie is topped with creamy eggnog frosting and nutmeg to finish. It almost always returns around the holidays, but if you don’t want to wait, try baking your own eggnog cookies from scratch.
31. Dark Dream
This next Crumbl Cookie flavor is a take on the double chocolate chip cookie, aptly named Dark Dream for the near-mystical experience it offers to chocolate lovers everywhere. This chocolate cookie is packed with semi-sweet chocolate chips throughout and on top. It’s best served warm for a complete melt-in-your-mouth experience.
32. Texas Sheet Cake
Chocolate lovers, rejoice once more. This next Crumbl Cookie flavor turns the traits of a rich Texas sheet cake into its cookie counterpart. Picture a warm cake-like chocolate cookie with fudge glaze on top, along with a dash of toasted pecans to add that perfect nutty crunch in every bite.
33. Orange Milkshake
This citrus-inspired Crumbl Cookie flavor will remind you of retro diners and sunny days. Meant to be served chilled, this buttery sugar cookie features bright orange bits and a fluffy creamy orange buttercream frosting that’s reminiscent of the milkshake it’s named after. A fresh orange slice tops off this refreshing summertime treat.
34. Mango Frozen Yogurt
Take a trip to the tropics with Mango Frozen Yogurt as your next of the best Crumbl Cookie flavors to look out for. This chilled mango cookie is topped with a swirl of tangy mango yogurt and vanilla frosting, plus a sweet and chewy piece of dried mango.
35. Churro
Based on a beloved crunchy sweet treat, Churro is a Crumbl Cookie flavor that hits the nail on the head. Take a slow bite into an expertly spiced soft cinnamon cookie with a crispy churro-like outer layer, topped with cinnamon-flavored buttercream and a light dusting of cinnamon sugar to finish.
36. Frozen Hot Chocolate
If you like your hot chocolate frozen and in cookie form, this one’s for you. This Crumbl Cookie flavor is a harmonious mix of different textures that make up a perfect chocolate drink. It begins with a decadent chocolate cookie that’s then topped with fluffy hot cocoa-flavored mousse and adorable mini marshmallows.
37. Chocolate Covered Strawberry
This is definitely a favorite Crumbl Cookie flavor for fans of chocolate and fruit combinations and especially lovers of chocolate-covered strawberries. It’s an expertly balanced treat in the form of a chocolate cookie frosted with a fruity strawberry cream cheese and a smooth chocolate drizzle on top.
38. Almond Joy
Inspired by the nostalgic candy bar of the same name, Almond Joy combines classic flavors to create one of the greatest Crumbl Cookie flavors out there. Each bite brings a chewy chocolate base topped with shredded coconut and almond slices. Can't wait for this one to come back on the menu? Try your hand at making Almond Joy cookies at home.
39. Cornbread
Cornbread is among the top when it comes to Crumbl cookies flavors ranked favorably and consistently requested by fans. This is definitely a unique choice compared to the more traditional flavors offered. Try this cornbread cookie that’s glazed with honey butter, topped with honey buttercream and drizzled with sweet honey.
40. Rocky Road
Best served warm, Rocky Road is sure to bring back memories. Take yourself back to firefly-lit summer nights with a bite of chocolate cookie that encases a fluffy marshmallow filling and has chocolate chips and almonds sprinkled on top. This cookie is sure to warm your soul every time.
41. Cinnamon Roll
There’s nothing like a warm, fresh cinnamon bun straight out of the oven, but this Crumbl Cookie flavor definitely holds its own. This soft and chewy cookie is topped with cinnamon brown sugar and a cinnamon roll-like swirl of cream cheese frosting to create a medley of classic flavors.
42. Peanut Butter ft. Snickers
Satisfy your hunger once and for all with this Snickers-filled treat. When it comes to Crumbl Cookie flavors, this is definitely a favorite for many. Served warm, this cookie starts with a classic Crumbl peanut butter base, with a layer of airy caramel buttercream and crunchy pieces of Snickers candy bar throughout.
43. Lemon Poppy Seed
A popular choice for lovers of lemon desserts, this Crumbl Cookie flavor transforms the classic muffin flavor into an artfully made cookie. When it returns, take a bite into this perfectly baked lemon poppy seed cookie with a fresh lemon filling center and a distinct, delicate almond glaze on top.
44. Red Velvet Cupcake
This Crumbl Cookie flavor hits every note of a perfect red velvet cupcake. Bite into a vibrant red, perfectly buttery base that balances out with a healthy dose of smooth cream cheese frosting topped with gorgeous crimson crumbs. For a bake-at-home alternative, try out these delicious red velvet crinkle cookies.
45. Mystery Cookie
Finally, we have the coveted Mystery Cookie. This is an exciting chance to try a surprise flavor from Crumbl’s extensive menu. Once a month, each store features a different mystery cookie. Discover the featured Mystery Cookie flavor for your local store through the Crumbl Cookies app.
What Are the Crumbl Cookie Flavors This Week?
As mentioned, Crumbl Cookies releases six flavors every week. To find out which Crumbl Cookies are available this week, visit the Crumbl Cookies website, which features the weekly cookie flavors, plus each cookie's primary ingredients and an image of the treat. The weekly flavors are often released on Crumbl's social media platforms as well.
Learn How to Bake
While there’s nothing like the excitement of trying out new Crumbl Cookie flavors as they’re released, sometimes you just crave your favorite flavors. When this happens, taking some cooking classes offers a great way to pick up new baking skills. Experiment with your own gourmet recipes by checking out one of many baking-based cooking classes near you. Want to stay home and learn to bake? Try a few online cooking classes to up your baking game from the comfort of home.
Join 200,000+ Culinary Enthusiasts
With so many delicious and expertly crafted Crumbl Cookie flavors in existence and many more to come, it’s easy to see how Crumbl has gained its loyal customers. After all, there’s nothing like sharing a perfect gourmet cookie.
If you’ve been wondering which flavors you have to try when released, this list of the top 45 cookie flavors at Crumbl Cookies should have helped you discover which treats have to be tried when they pop back up on the menu.
For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.