21 Best Bagels in NYC for 2022

Published on October 19, 2022 | 0 Comments
We've rounded up the best bagels in NYC.
Published on October 19, 2022 | 0 Comments

Whether you’re a local or a tourist, you’re probably on the hunt for the best bagels in NYC. Bagels are a staple food item in the Big Apple, whether they’re covered in creamy schmear or holding together a silky salmon sandwich. Being in the home of the handmade, kettle-boiled bagel, NYC locals will happily wait in line for these delicious breaded treats.

According to Today, there are over 200 bagel shops in NYC. With so many options, it can feel overwhelming to know where to start, so we’ve rounded up a list of the 21 best bagel places in NYC to satisfy your bagel cravings.

 

 Jump to Section

Book a Food Tour in NYC Now
Explore NYC's best bites, esteemed eateries and hidden gems with a top-rated local guide.
Book Now

Find the Best Bagels in NYC

Among several other iconic NYC foods, the Big Apple is known as the nation's capital for the most delicious bagels. One of the best things to do in NYC is to explore the city’s culinary cuisine through entertaining food tours in NYC. Whether you’re a tourist or a local looking for their new favorite bagel shop, expert tour guides will schedule your day to help you locate the best bagels and lox. 

21 Best Bagels in NYC

1. Ess-a-Bagel

With one of the best bagels in NYC, Ess-a-Bagel is a favorite among locals. These tender, chewy bagels provide the perfect amount of crunch in every bite. You can also order mini bagels 24 hours ahead of time.

The Vibe

The original location opened in 1976 as a family-run café in the Tri-State area. It boasts a homey deli atmosphere. In 1993, the family opened two more locations around the city with a similar café-deli vibe.

What to Order

With a variety of bagels, schmears and even salads on the menu, this local spot is a great place to hit up for breakfast or lunch. Many locals enjoy the fluffy everything, pumpernickel and cinnamon raisin bagels. Their bagel sandwiches are NYC favorites as well.

Ess-a-Bagel I Multiple Locations I $

Ess-a-Bagel serves some of the best bagels in NYC.
via Ess-a-Bagel

2. Absolute Bagels

Customers line up around the block to experience one of the best bagel shops in NYC. Locals love Absolute Bagels’ hand-rolled, housemade bagels topped with thick cream cheese. Customers rave about the friendly service run by a Thai family.

The Vibe

This joint is perfect for a quick bite or to grab a bagel on the go. The restaurant is currently cash-only with affordable options.

What to Order

Customers love the thick creamy schmears, from blueberry to sun-dried tomato. You can also top off your bagel with smoked fish or deli meat. 

Absolute Bagels I 2788 Broadway, New York, NY 10025 I $

3. BO’s Bagels

Hustle down to experience one of the best bagel places in NYC. Located in Harlem, BO’s Bagels actually started in the home kitchen of a culinary power couple. With a variety of bagels, schmears and spreads, customers are addicted to these bagels.

The Vibe

This sweet little shop is a great spot to grab breakfast. With natural light and beautiful artwork on the walls, Bo’s Bagels is a nice place to hang out while eating your bagel.

What to Order

Customers love the creative cream cheese flavors, such as tofu scallion, maple walnut and berry almond. Arrive early to beat the line for a fresh, hot bagel.

BO's Bagels I 235 W. 116th St., New York, NY 10026 I $

a bagel sandwich with tomato, onions, and chive cream cheese
via BO's Bagels

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in NYC
Kick-start your culinary confidence with help from a world-class chef. See what's cooking in NYC today.
Book Now

4. Riverdale Bagels

Enjoy over 20 years of chewy bagel perfection in one of the best bagel places in NYC. Every bagel at Riverdale Bagels is always boiled and never steamed to guarantee ultimate freshness.

The Vibe

Riverdale Bagels is a sweet deli shop with a variety of groceries and baked goods also available. Enjoy freshly spooned cream cheese and sliced meat on your bagel.

What to Order

Many customers love the breakfast and lunch bagel sandwiches. You can also experience unique cream cheese flavors, such as spicy bacon and garlic pepper. Fresh muffins and assorted baked goods are also a hit with customers.

Riverdale Bagels I 5650 Riverdale Ave., The Bronx, NY 10471 I $

5. Black Seed Bagels

This bagel hotspot has nine locations, including two more in development. With some of the best bagels in NYC, Black Seed Bagels boils its bagels and adds a touch of honey in the water for subtle sweetness. They’re then formed by hand and baked in a wood-burning oven for the ultimate chewiness and density.

The Vibe

Each shop is custom to its location in the city, but they’re all warm and welcoming. Whether you’re near the food halls in NYC in Rockefeller Center or in Brooklyn, there’s bound to be a Black Seed Bagels close by. 

What to Order

Many locals love the emphasis on poppy and sesame seeds incorporated into the bagels. The shop also offers housemade spreads and almond butter to top off your crispy bagel. They sell gluten-free bagels to enjoy as well.

Black Seed Bagels I Multiple Locations I $

Black Seed Bagels serves some of the best toppings for bagels in NYC.
via Black Seed Bagels

6. Murray’s Bagels

Every bagel is hand-rolled and made fresh each morning at Murray’s Bagels. Serving the Greenwich Village since 1996, the bustling lines and busy atmosphere make this one of the best bagel shops in NYC. 

The Vibe

Murray’s Bagels has a great reputation among the community for delicious bites and coffee, and the small shop is an excellent spot for a quick bite or even to catch a fun chat with the owner, Adam. 

What to Order

Customers love the exterior crunch and sweet inner chew of each bagel. Among favorites like poppy and sesame, customers are also impressed by the size of the sandwiches filled with fresh deli meat, fish salad or slices of chicken.

Murray’s Bagels I 500 Sixth Ave., New York, NY 10011 I $

Book a Five-Star Private Chef in NYC
Indulge in the finest fare the Big Apple has to offer. Book a five-star private chef experience starting at $59/person.
Book Now

7. Tompkins Square Bagels

Known for some of the best bagels in NYC, Tompkins Square Bagels currently has two locations for its customers to enjoy. This bagel hotspot is well known for offbeat and flavorful options, such as the chocolate chip cookie dough cream cheese.

The Vibe

The deli hosts a variety of colors with its unique cream cheese options. Both locations offer plenty of seating and friendly service to make this a nice place to hang out.

What to Order

Customers rave over traditional favorites like plain and poppyseed, but they also love the sandwiches. Whether you choose the French toast or chocolate chip bagel, the variety of cream cheese spreads won't leave you disappointed!

Tompkins Square Bagels I Multiple Locations I $

two bagel sandwiches cut open, one sweet, one savory
via Tompkins Square Bagels

8. Bagel Pub

This local chain has some of the best bagels in NYC. With six locations, Bagel Pub specializes in hand-rolled and kettle-boiled bagels, making them perfectly crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside.

The Vibe

Each location offers a classy café atmosphere with plenty of seating and chill music, making this a great place to hang out for a bit. Looking for a great place to stay warm? Grab a bagel, a cup of coffee and add this to your list of the best indoor activities in NYC.

What to Order

Bagel enthusiasts love the variety of flavorful cream cheeses, such as guacamole and even vegan tofu spreads. Customers also enjoy the lox and breakfast sandwiches as a great way to start their day.

Bagel Pub I Multiple Locations I $

9. Leo’s Bagels

Leo’s Bagels was founded by the same owner as Murray’s Bagels. This bagel shop also rolls, boils and bakes its bagels in small batches everyday to guarantee freshness and flavor.

The Vibe

This bustling bagel shop has a classy interior with a warm counter. Although there are currently no dine-in options, it’s perfect for a quick visit or breakfast on the go.

What to Order

In addition to being named after the owner’s uncle, Leo’s is also an acronym for a Lower-East side favorite: lox, eggs and onions. Order this with any flavor of their traditional, hand-rolled bagels and you're in for one of the best bagel sandwiches in NYC.

Leo’s Bagels I 3 Hanover Square, New York, NY 10004 I $

Leo's serves one of the best bagel sandwiches in NYC.
via Leo's Bagels

Book a Food Tour in NYC Now
Explore NYC's best bites, esteemed eateries and hidden gems with a top-rated local guide.
Book Now

10. Tal Bagels

Known for being one of the best bagels in NYC, Tal Bagels currently has six locations. With most bagel shops closing around mid-afternoon, this hotspot has one location on the Upper East Side open until 9 p.m., making it a great place for a casual date night in NYC.

The Vibe

This favorite NYC deli has a variety of fresh bagels, meats and schmears. With ample seating and a warm atmosphere, Tal Bagels offers a great place to hang out and enjoy a breakfast bagel or coffee.

What to Order

The lox, nova and smoked salmon are local favorites at this joint, and the generous spread on your bagel will make it easy for you to see why.

Tal Bagels I Multiple Locations I $

11. Russ & Daughters

As one of the oldest bagel shops in the country, Russ & Daughters boasts some of the best bagels in NYC. Since its opening in 1914, many customers had to wait in a long line to experience a delicious bagel here. Now, the shop has two more locations around the city.

The Vibe

This Jewish, family-owned shop boasts a quaint deli vibe. The shop has walk-in seating and offers a nice place to sit at the barista counter. Many customers stop by for brunch to enjoy the indoor seating.

What to Order

This bagel hotspot is well-known for its delicious lox and pickled herring. 

Russ & Daughters I Multiple Locations I $

a counter displaying bagels, toppings, and a traditional menu
via Russ & Daughters

12. Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company

Another local chain, Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company offers some of the best bagels in NYC. Despite its name, all locations are in Queens and Manhattan. Customers enjoy the wide variety of bagels and creamy schmears.

The Vibe

This bustling bagel shop provides ample seating at many of its locations. A colorful assortment of creative cream cheeses and delicious bagels create a nice atmosphere to cozy up and stay for a while.

What to Order

Customers love the kettle-boiled bagels as an appetizing way to start their day. With seasonal selections like gingerbread and sundried tomato, there’s always a new favorite to try at this bagel shop. Make sure to order freshly-roasted coffee or loose leaf tea to enjoy with your bagel.

Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company I Multiple Locations I $

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in NYC
Kick-start your culinary confidence with help from a world-class chef. See what's cooking in NYC today.
Book Now

13. Tasty Bagels

Tasty Bagels is iconic for some of the best bagels in NYC. Home of the Big Wheel Bagel, a giant bagel stuffed to the brim with meats and cheeses, this joint has proudly served Brooklyn since 1983.

The Vibe

This local deli is a great spot to grab a bagel on the go. Make sure to bring cash since it operates with a cash-only model.

What to Order

With plenty of cream cheese and rainbow-colored bagel options, there are tons to choose from when visiting this hotspot. Customers also love the addictive breakfast sandwiches.

Tasty Bagels I 1705 86th St., Brooklyn, NY 11214 I $

bagel sandwich with smoked salmon, onions, and tomato
via Tasty Bagels

14. Utopia Bagels

Travel out to Queens to enjoy one of the best bagels in NYC. Locals promise the freshly baked bagels and creative sandwich flavors are well worth the commute to Utopia Bagels.

The Vibe

Utopia Bagels hosts cartons filled to the brim with fresh, original bagels. Grab a chair for a quick breakfast or enjoy your bagel on the go.

What to Order

Whether ordering a regular bagel with lox or jalapeño cream cheese, customers agree you can’t go wrong at this spot. Explore unique sandwich options like the Tex-Mex Chicken or Smokey & the Bacon.

Utopia Bagels I 1909 Utopia Pkwy, Queens, NY 11357 I $

15. H&H Bagels

Although the original H&H Bagels shut down in 2011, this new hot spot also boasts some of the best bagels in NYC. With several locations in the city, H&H Bagels are available for pickup, delivery and can also be shipped nationwide.

The Vibe

This hip deli offers indoor seating and a calming ambiance. Grab a cup of coffee or pastry to enjoy with your bagel.

What to Order

These kettle-boiled bagels offer a wide variety of options that customers love. Traditional staples include pumpernickel and cinnamon raisin.

H&H Bagels I Multiple Locations I $

H & H Bagels serves some of the best bagels in NYC.
via H & H Bagels

16. Zucker’s Bagels

With several locations across the city, Zucker’s Bagels is also known for having the best bagels in NYC. Another entrepreneurial venture from the same owner of Murray’s and Leo’s bagels, this shop is worth a visit as well.

The Vibe

Grab a bagel and enjoy this cozy atmosphere. Depending on your location, stay for breakfast or a late afternoon snack to unwind and relax.

What to Order

Smoked fish is an essential favorite at this shop. Order this on your sandwich or savory egg salad and you’re in for a treat.

Zucker’s Bagels I Multiple Locations I $

17. Bagel Oasis

Enjoy this 24/7 shop for one of the best bagels in NYC. Stop by Bagel Oasis for an early breakfast or a midnight snack to satisfy your bagel cravings.

The Vibe

This small shop is perfect for a grab-and-go, but there is seating if you want to stay to enjoy your bagel. 

What to Order

Savor original favorite bagels like egg-onion or blueberry for a delicious treat. Grab a sandwich served with hashbrowns for an incredible breakfast to start your day.

Bagel Oasis I 183-12 Horace Harding Expy, Queens, NY 11365 I $

a Bagel Oasis shop with bagels on display
via Bagel Oasis

Book a Five-Star Private Chef in NYC
Indulge in the finest fare the Big Apple has to offer. Book a five-star private chef experience starting at $59/person.
Book Now

18. Finn’s Bagels

Enjoy fast and friendly service along with one of the best bagels in NYC. Finn’s Bagels offer freshly baked bagels that keep their loyal customer base coming back for more.

The Vibe

Enjoy this airy, light space while you savor your bagel. Grab a coffee and stay for a while to enjoy the warm, friendly atmosphere.

What to Order

Customers rave about the variety of cream cheeses — including vegan options. One of the local favorites is bacon scallion cream cheese on an everything bagel.

Finn’s Bagels I 477 10th Ave., New York, NY 10018 I $

19. Bagel Supreme

With seven locations and counting, Bagel Supreme impresses locals and tourists alike with some of the best bagels in NYC. Enjoy bagels, waffles and French toast for a hearty breakfast.

The Vibe

With a warm, friendly atmosphere, this local chain offers dining options to enjoy your breakfast in house.

What to Order

Customers recommend the French toast bagel showered in powdered sugar, or the Oreo bagel.

Bagel Supreme I Multiple Locations I $

an egg, cheese, and bacon bagel sandwich
via Bagel Supreme

20. Hudson Bagel

With some of the best bagels in NYC, Hudson Bagel is also known for having fast, friendly service. Pull up a chair to enjoy large, chewy bagels with a generous serving of schmear. 

The Vibe

This cozy deli shop offers several options for inside seating. Customers recommend stopping by for a quick bite if you’re in the area.

What to Order

Enjoy a sunflower seed bagel with lox or chipotle cream cheese.

Hudson Bagel I 691 Ninth Ave., New York, NY 10036 I $

21. Zabars

This unique market is iconic for some of the best bagels in NYC. Founded by a Ukrainian immigrant in 1934, Zabars offers everything from bagels to delicious sweet treats.

The Vibe

This custom food hall bustles with excitement and variety. Perfect for a grab-and-go meal for a busy workday.

What to Order

Well known for its smoked fish, customers highly recommend indulging in this meat on your bagel. Locals also love the bagels crafted from malt barley flour.

Zabar’s I 2245 Broadway, New York, NY 10024 I $

Zabars has served some of NYC's best bagels since the 1930s.
via Zabars

There’s no doubt NYC has earned its reputation for having some of the best bagels in the world. With countless options for unique bagels, schmears and breakfast sandwiches, exploring these NYC bagel hotspots will help you find your next favorite places to eat in NYC.

For even more fun ways to explore NYC and beyond, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.

About Cozymeal

Discover the best in culinary experiences and products on Cozymeal: From in-person cooking classes to virtual cooking & mixology classes to private chef experiences and top-rated cookware — from world-class chefs, mixologists & more.

View All Experiences & Cookware on Cozymeal

FOOD FOR THOUGHT?

Join the conversation.

0 Comments
0 Comments
Please Log In to leave a comment