33 Best Graeter's Ice Cream Flavors To Try in 2025

Graeter’s ice cream flavors offer everything you want and more — they’re rich, dreamy and often loaded with mix-ins that actually earn their place. With a time-honored production process that dates back to 1868, according to Wittenberg University, you'd expect nothing less than perfection in every scoop.

But what happens when it comes to picking the best Graeter’s flavor? That’s no simple task when they’re all so delicious. Whether you’re all about classic combinations or chasing the brand's next tempting seasonal drop, here are 33 standout Graeter's ice cream flavors worth every serving.

Grab a spoon and ask yourself: Are you in it for the chocolate chunks, the nostalgic vibes or the surprise mix-ins you didn’t see coming?

 Jump to Section

• The 33 Best Graeter's Flavors

The 33 Best Graeter's Flavors

1. Madagascar Vanilla Bean

If you're looking to experience a Graeter’s ice cream flavor that revamps a timeless classic, look no further than Madagascar Vanilla Bean. Made with real vanilla beans, this flavor is anything but plain, boasting an ultra-creamy texture and a subtly floral, custard-like depth.

Each spoonful reveals visible specks of vanilla, delivering a refreshing, luxurious depth that lingers. There are no mix-ins here; this one’s all about the base. So while chunk-chasers might find it too simple, it leaves plenty of room to play. Pair this Graeter’s ice cream flavor with brownies, spoon it over pie or enjoy it straight from the pint, unapologetically.

2. Black Cherry Chocolate Chip

There’s something about black cherry and chocolate that just screams decadence, and Black Cherry Chocolate Chip delivers on that promise. Each scoop represents a bold contrast, where juicy, tart black cherries meet generous chunks of bittersweet chocolate in a rich, luscious base. 

It’s one of those Graeter’s ice cream flavors that wins over both fruit fans and chocolate lovers while bringing plenty of mouthfeel to the table. Compared to something like the simplicity of a creamy vanilla flavor, this one’s anything but subtle — so if you’re chasing drama by the spoonful, go ahead and dig in.

3. Butter Pecan

While Butter Pecan can be a hit or miss for some taste buds, this Graeter’s ice cream flavor proves its worth as a timeless classic. Rich, buttery ice cream blends with perfectly toasted whole pecans to deliver a comforting, nutty sweetness that doesn’t try too hard, and certainly doesn’t need to.

Fans of Graeter’s ice cream flavors who crave a balance of creamy richness with a salty crunch will find their match here. This quiet legend in a pint isn’t flashy or wild, but that’s the beauty of it.

4. Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip

A Graeter’s ice cream flavor that needs no introduction (national recognition already in the bag), Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip is a true signature favorite. It combines luscious, tart black raspberry ice cream in a stunning shade of purple with the brand's famously large bittersweet chocolate chunks for an unforgettable combo.

This is another Graeter’s ice cream flavor for fruit lovers and chocolate fans, though those massive chips might catch you off guard if you’re expecting sprinkles. But honestly? That surprise is part of the fun.

5. Vienna Coffee

Smooth, rich and made with Sumatran and Colombian Arabica beans, Vienna Coffee is a love letter to coffee fans who crave more than just a caffeine fix. This isn’t your average coffee ice cream; it’s creamy, elegant and tastes like your favorite café drink perfectly frozen.

One of the more underrated Graeter’s ice cream flavors, this one speaks to grown-up palates that prefer a little depth over a sugar rush. It’s not ideal for folks who steer clear of caffeine, but for many, it’s the ultimate refined scoop.

6. Buckeye Blitz Chocolate Chip

One thing’s for sure, Buckeye Blitz Chocolate Chip doesn’t hold back in its celebration of peanut butter and chocolate, Ohio style. This Graeter’s ice cream flavor combines rich chocolate ice cream, chewy peanut butter cookie dough and signature dark chocolate chips for one seriously decadent bite.

If you grew up loving peanut butter cups or have a sweet tooth with a nostalgic streak, this Graeter’s ice cream flavor is the ideal choice for you. Fair warning: it’s a hefty scoop packed with texture, so it’s probably not the pick if you’re craving something simple. 

7. Cookies and Cream

A timeless classic done the Graeter’s way, Cookies and Cream is pure comfort in a cone, bowl or straight out of the container. This dreamy Graeter's ice cream flavor is loaded with crunchy Oreo cookies in generous, not-shy-at-all chunks.

Best of all, the cookies don’t get lost in the mix; in fact, you might even stumble upon a whole one hiding in your pint. Fans of classic Graeter’s ice cream flavors will love this one — it’s the kind of scoop that brings you back to basics in the best way.

8. Mint Chocolate Chip

Mint Chocolate Chip skips the neon green nonsense in favor of natural, real-deal flavor with peppermint oil as the minty backbone. Each scoop of this Graeter's ice cream flavor brings with it the icy-fresh kick you crave, along with pieces of rich bittersweet chocolate chips folded in. 

One of the cooler picks (literally), this one hits the spot, whether it’s your after-dinner treat or a straight-from-the-pint situation any time of day (no judgment here). And for anyone who’s mint-shy, this might just be the Graeter's ice cream flavor to change your mind. Why miss out on all that minty magic?

9. S’mores

If you’re craving campfire vibes without the smoke, S’mores is the Graeter’s ice cream flavor you'll want to get your hands on. Imagine gooey graham cracker-flavored ice cream studded with chunks of milk chocolate chips and marshmallows. Or better yet, skip the imagining and grab a pint.

A playful pick among Graeter’s ice cream flavors, S’mores nails the creamy-to-crunchy ratio with ease. Sure, some might wish it packed a little more punch to really channel backyard bonfire vibes with sparks flying and stories flowing. But even without the full campfire theatrics, it’s still a scoop-worthy pick that requires no bug spray and less effort than making actual s'mores.

10. Key Lime Pie

Take home a slice of Key West sunshine with classic Key Lime Pie reimagined into a Graeter’s ice cream flavor. This zesty and unapologetically refreshing Graeter's flavor is loaded with tangy key lime flair and speckled with crunchy graham cracker crust pieces that bring the pie to life.

Available from July to August, this is one of the best grocery store ice cream picks for beating the summer heat. That said, if you’re not into citrusy treats, the zingy punch of this Graeter's ice cream flavor might be more of a shock than a delightful surprise.

11. Elena's Blueberry Pie

Elena’s Blueberry Pie is comfort in a pint, offering a scoop that wraps you in memories of freshly baked pie. Each bite bursts with real blueberries, as if they’re fresh from Mother Nature’s backyard, and is dotted with buttery pie crust pieces.

But this special Graeter’s ice cream flavor is more than just a tasty pick. Available as a limited edition flavor, Elena’s Blueberry Pie honors the memory of Elena, a courageous young girl who lost her life to cancer. A portion of each pint sold supports cancer research foundations, turning every scoop into a small but meaningful act of love.

12. Peach

Few Graeter’s ice cream flavors embody summer in a bowl as effortlessly as Peach does. Made with real peach pieces, the taste is naturally sweet and gently floral, giving each bite that fresh-off-the-tree feeling. The creamy texture also balances the fruitiness beautifully.

There’s a quiet charm in every scoop, the kind that makes you slow down and savor, like a porch swing moment in dessert form. It’s a total win for fans of classic fruity desserts — just make sure to snag it while it’s in season during the month of June.

13. Caramel Macchiato

Another one for the caffeine fans, Caramel Macchiato is your favorite coffeehouse treat in frozen form. Grab a spoon and dig into bold espresso notes married with decadent milk chocolate caramel truffles and Heath bar pieces.

This popular dessert is sweet and full of depth, but rest assured, it's not overly sugary. However, if you’re not into coffee, this Graeter's ice cream flavor certainly won’t win you over. For everyone else, though, it’s like spooning up a caramel macchiato — no steam, just smooth comfort and plenty of mmm-worthy moments.

14. Coconut Chocolate Chip

If you didn’t already know, coconut and chocolate chips are a match made in dessert heaven, and in this case, Coconut Chocolate Chip is playing cupid. This Graeter’s ice cream flavor is the perfect sunny escape, with a lusciously creamy, coconut-infused base that doesn’t go overboard. Think tropical breeze without the sunburn. 

Dark chocolate chips add that signature richness, resulting in one of the best Graeter's flavors for coconut lovers. If you're craving a creamy scoop of paradise with a chocolatey crunch in every bite, this one’s like a sweet vacation in a pint.

15. Cotton Candy

No Graeter’s ice cream flavor lineup is complete without something for the kids, and that’s where Cotton Candy shines. This summer dessert leaves little eyes wide and excitement bubbling over. And if there aren’t any kids around, no worries, the nostalgic sweetness will still transport you back to carefree childhood days.

With its pastel blue hue and bits of pink candy speckled throughout, this Graeter’s ice cream flavor looks as fun as it tastes. It’s definitely sugary, something you might overlook amid all the whimsy, but for sugar lovers, it’s an absolute treat.

16. Chocolate Chip

A timeless classic, Chocolate Chip is the go-to Graeter’s ice cream flavor when you're feeling indecisive but still want to satisfy your cravings. The rich, silky base of dreamy Madagascar vanilla ice cream is perfectly complemented by indulgent pieces of gourmet chocolate chips that melt in your mouth.

If you're craving something with more complexity, this might feel too straightforward. But it’s a flavor that never goes out of style, so you can trust you’re in good hands every time you indulge.

17. Dark Chocolate Brownie

Double the chocolate means double the indulgence, and if that’s your idea of a perfect evening, Dark Chocolate Brownie is calling your name. A full-on chocolate lover’s dream, this Graeter’s ice cream flavor doubles down on richness with a luxurious dark chocolate base and bountiful chunks of brownie throughout.

While it might be too intense for those who shy away from bittersweet cocoa, anyone craving something deeply decadent will find this pint hits every fudgy note.

18. Oregon Strawberry

If you're craving something fruity and refreshingly old-school, Oregon Strawberry from Graeter’s ice cream flavor lineup is where it's at. It embodies a sun-kissed strawberry feel, thanks to real berries sourced from Oregon’s Willamette Valley, and it doesn’t rely on artificial or overpowering sweetness. 

This flavor feels refreshingly honest and delicately rich with plenty of fresh summery goodness in every bite. It’s the kind of clean, strawberry dessert that’s reminiscent of childhood, whether you enjoy it in a cone, a bowl or straight from the pint.

19. Lemon Meringue Pie

Another heavy hitter among Graeter’s ice cream flavors, Lemon Meringue Pie knows how to make an entrance. It delivers a ridiculously creamy marshmallow-lemon base that’s not too tart, not too sweet and perfectly mimics that iconic toasted meringue topping. Bonus points go to the buttery pie crust bits and tangy lemon candy folded in, giving each bite a whole lot of texture.

There are few downsides to this mouthwatering Graeter’s ice cream flavor, except, perhaps, that it might just outshine an actual slice of lemon meringue pie. But honestly, when it tastes this good, who’s complaining? 

20. Peppermint Stick

If you love that refreshing, tingly mouthfeel that lingers long after your peppermint treat is gone, Peppermint Stick deserves a prime spot in your freezer. Available from late November to December, it’s one of the most invigorating Graeter’s ice cream flavors around, with peppermint oil adding an extra kick.

While it nails the minty magic, the chewy peppermint candy pieces can be clingy, often trying their best to wedge between your teeth. Nevertheless, for true peppermint fans, it’s a small price to pay for such a festive, cooling scoop.

21. Cinnamon

Sugar, spice and everything nice are exactly what you’ll find in a pint of Graeter’s Cinnamon ice cream. This cozy classic skips the flashy mix-ins and lets the warm spice do the talking, delivering just enough fall flavor to welcome the new season.

While some might find it plain on its own, that simplicity leaves room for pairing magic, from warm apple pie to buttery crumble. You can snag this spice-kissed Graeter’s ice cream flavor between October and November, and until then, your taste buds will just have to wait patiently.

22. Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

Craving both peanut butter and chocolate chips? Then, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip is your answer. This nutty Graeter’s ice cream flavor is salty-sweet perfection for anyone who swears peanut butter and chocolate belong together (they absolutely do). The peanut butter base is rich and creamy without being overpowering, while the milk chocolate chips add just the right amount of indulgence.

Fans of Graeter’s ice cream flavors with bold bites will be all over this one. The chocolate chips are generously sized and sometimes steal the spotlight, but honestly, that’s not the worst problem to have.

23. Eggnog

Whether you count down the days until eggnog season or cringe at the very thought of it, there’s no denying its impact. So, of course, Graeter’s gave it the frozen treatment. Nutmeg, rum and eggs come together in each scoop, wrapping you in a cozy, holiday hug. 

This is another seasonal Graeter’s ice cream flavor worth scooping while you can. Of course, if you’re anti-eggnog, this won’t make your Christmas list. But, love it or leave it, it’s the kind of flavor that leans all the way into what it is — a holiday favorite.

24. Orange and Cream

Don’t let the name scare you, orange and ice cream make a delicious duo, just give Orange and Cream a taste. This seasonal Graeter’s ice cream flavor is like a grown-up creamsicle with extra flair, blending orange purée with a creamy base for an irresistibly refreshing combo.

It’s light, playful and delivers exactly what it says on the package. The only downside? It’s a fleeting treat, available just one month a year. So, if this mellow, citrus-kissed Graeter's ice cream flavor wins you over, you’ll be counting down the days until next May.

25. Mocha Chocolate Chip

Latte lovers who dream in espresso and dark chocolate are in for a treat with Mocha Chocolate Chip. This smoky Graeter’s ice cream flavor invites anyone who treats mocha like a food group to experience a rich blend of roasted Arabica beans. A smooth, sweet cream base effortlessly mellows the flavor while bittersweet chocolate chips add a sprinkle of indulgence.

Bold without veering into grimace-inducing bitterness, this pint lands squarely in the “grown-up treat” category among Graeter’s ice cream flavors. Luckily, it’s still playful enough to keep you reaching for just one more spoonful. 

26. Midnight Snack

Midnight Snack is what happens when every snack craving you've ever had gets tossed into one glorious scoop. Think chewy peanut butter cups, crunchy pretzels and fudgy brownie bits swirling through a creamy malt ice cream base.

Each serving is chaotic in the best way possible, with salty, sweet, crunchy and gooey elements hitting a different note in every bite, and somehow, it works. One of the more indulgent Graeter’s ice cream flavors, it’s for snack lovers who can’t pick just one craving to satisfy.

27. Banana Chocolate Chip

A throwback to banana splits and homemade desserts, Banana Chocolate Chip is one of those comfort-driven Graeter’s ice cream flavors that might stir up debate. Banana can be a polarizing pick, often accused of stealing the show, but here, it’s mellow and naturally sweet, allowing the milk chocolate chips to shine.

It’s a surprisingly balanced scoop for anyone who grew up with banana-flavored everything (and didn’t mind). Whether you’re a longtime banana fan or just banana-curious, this light-hearted Graeter's flavor proves the combo still deserves a spot in the spotlight. And if you still need convincing, it happens to take first prize in Bob Graeter's daughter's books.

28. Brown Butter Bourbon Pecan

Say Brown Butter Bourbon Pecan three times fast, and a pint might just magically appear in front of you. This indulgent Graeter’s ice cream flavor is a little something for the adults, offering an unapologetic boozy, buttery escape.

With velvety bourbon notes and sweet glazed pecans folded into rich brown butter ice cream, it sounds like a dream, and for many, it is. That said, it does its job a little too well, so if you prefer your scoops a little more subtle on the liqueur front, it might be a bit overpowering.

29. Birthday Cake

Anytime is a good time for cake, and Birthday Cake ice cream gives you the perfect excuse to dig in. Easily one of the most playful Graeter’s ice cream flavors, this one brings a dreamy cake batter base to life. Soft chunks of real cake and rainbow sprinkles add a touch of whimsy to every scoop.

It’s sweet, nostalgic and unapologetically fun. It's the ideal treat for kids, the young at heart and anyone who believes that every day should include at least one scoop of excitement. This is one party you don’t have to RSVP for — grab a pint and enjoy! 

30. Mint Cookies and Cream

Blending cool, minty cream with pieces of Oreo cookies, Mint Cookies and Cream gives cookie lovers and mint fans something (delicious) to talk about. It’s a true crowd-pleaser that will make your tastebuds sing without being too overpowering.

This seasonal Graeter’s ice cream flavor is a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it favorite, and it just might outshine your usual cookies and cream. If it feels like a betrayal of your regular pint, so be it; it’s the kind of delicious disloyalty you won’t regret.

31. Pumpkin

This time, it's pumpkin, spice and everything nice that come together to bring cozy fall feels with every ultra-creamy scoop. This comforting Graeter’s ice cream flavor tastes just like a dreamy slice of pumpkin pie that grandma used to make, just a tad colder. Made with real pumpkin and kissed with cinnamon and nutmeg, it captures everything pumpkin spice fans crave.

There are no surprises in this pint: what you see is what you get, and that’s a whole lot of plain. Still, it’s smooth, spiced and unapologetically seasonal, patiently waiting in the freezer aisle from September to October.

32. Original Salted Caramel

An OG in the lineup, Original Salted Caramel stays true to Regina Graeter’s original recipe, and it shows. This Graeter’s ice cream flavor nails the perfect balance between sweet and salty, with velvety cream, brown sugar and a subtle kiss of sea salt.

It’s elegant, versatile and satisfying, without being over-the-top. So, if you’re avoiding bold or chunky mix-ins, this one stays delightfully simple with pure caramel goodness throughout.

33. Chocolate Coconut Almond Chocolate Chip

By the time you’ve finished saying Chocolate Coconut Almond Chocolate Chip, you’ll already be scraping the bottom of the pint. As far as Graeter’s ice cream flavors go, this one doesn’t hold back, starting with a lush chocolate base that sets the tone.

Beyond that, crunchy almonds add bite, dark chocolate chips await discovery and delicate coconut shavings weave in a breezy island vibe. It’s a full-flavored escape you’ll want to revisit.

No matter what you’re craving, Graeter’s ice cream flavors deliver scoop after scoop of indulgence. From year-round staples to limited-edition gems, there’s something for every kind of sweet tooth (even eggnog fans).

And just when you think you’ve found your go-to, another one comes along to challenge the crown. Who knows, your next favorite flavor might be waiting for you to discover it in the freezer aisle.

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal