23 Best Downtown Indianapolis Restaurants for 2024
When exploring central Indy, you’ll notice that there’s a host of Downtown Indianapolis restaurants lining the streets. With so many sensational options, it can be challenging to decide where to sit down to eat.
Whether you’re planning a fancy night out at an upscale restaurant, want a laid-back date night at a more casual spot or are searching for the best local cuisine, there’s a Downtown Indianapolis restaurant for you. To discover the best of the best on the Indianapolis dining scene, keep reading for a curated list of the 23 top restaurants in the downtown area.
Jump to Section
23 Best Restaurants in Downtown Indianapolis
1. FortyFive Degrees
Nestled along Mass Avenue, FortyFive Degrees adds a dash of style to your Downtown Indianapolis restaurant experience. This venue has become an iconic destination since its inception, offering an eclectic fusion of sushi, Asian-inspired dishes and inventive cocktails.
The Vibe
This Downtown Indianapolis sushi restaurant is upscale yet welcoming and relaxed. The greenery and light wood accents add a touch of tranquility while a blue light bar in the evening provides a dash of fun.
What to Order
For a burst of flavors, dive into the Playboy Roll, with spicy tuna and shrimp tempura, or the FortyFive Roll which features spicy crab, cream cheese, avocado and cucumber. You could get a selection of sushi to share amongst the table at this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant, while also adding a few main courses and some delicious cocktails to the mix.
FortyFive Degrees | 765 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$
2. St. Elmo Steak House
Embark on a journey through time and taste at St. Elmo Steak House, part of the Downtown Indianapolis restaurant scene since 1902. A local institution, St. Elmo's rich history and commitment to excellence have made it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
The Vibe
Tradition meets timeless elegance. The space boasts dark wood accents, classic leather seating and dimly lit chandeliers, creating an ambiance that returns to a bygone era.
What to Order
The world-renowned St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail is an iconic dish that has become synonymous with this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant, making it a must-try. Indulge in one of the exquisite dry-aged steaks for the main course, with the filet mignon and bone-in ribeye as favorites.
St. Elmo Steak House | 127 S. Illinois St., Indianapolis, IN 46225 | $$$$
3. The Eagle
Nestled in the heart of the downtown area, The Eagle welcomes patrons with open arms into a haven of Southern comfort. Originally a historic laundry facility, this charming Downtown Indianapolis restaurant is a labor of love by its founders, who transformed the space into a rustic retreat where the soulful flavors of the South take center stage.
The Vibe
This warm and welcoming Indianapolis restaurant blends rustic charm with modern comfort. The reclaimed wood, exposed brick and vintage touches create a cozy ambiance, inviting guests to relax and unwind.
What to Order
The famous Southern fried chicken is a masterpiece known for crispy perfection and juicy tenderness. Combine with classic sides like mac and cheese or flavorful bacon-infused Brussels sprouts for a meal full of comforting flavors. Be sure to explore the extensive cocktail menu at this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant as well, with options like bourbon punch and an apricot martini.
The Eagle | 310 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$
4. Prime 47
Prime 47 stands as a beacon of culinary sophistication on the Downtown Indianapolis restaurant scene. It’s popular with the city's elite, including Pacers players seeking an indulgent post-game meal.
The Vibe
Surround yourself in a setting of timeless elegance. This Downtown Indianapolis restaurant creates a fancy and intimate atmosphere with its white tablecloths, comfortable seating and soft lighting.
What to Order
The menu at this high-end Downtown Indianapolis restaurant offers a symphony of prime cuts and decadent accompaniments. Indulge in the creamy lobster bisque followed by velvety filet mignon and a bottle of high-end wine for a dining experience full of luxury.
Prime 47 | 47 S. Pennsylvania St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$$
5. Livery
Livery is an enchanting two-story establishment that beckons diners with its Latin-inspired menu. Its name pays homage to its historical roots as a former livery stable and has quickly become a Downtown Indianapolis restaurant hot spot.
The Vibe
An inviting atmosphere that effortlessly combines historical charm with modern Latin flair. The setting of this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant exudes warmth and character, featuring dark wood and exposed brick walls and horse décor items connecting the building’s past to the present. There’s also a rooftop dining area for when the weather is nice.
What to Order
The empanada platter is a must-order to start, featuring your choice of three empanadas, including those filled with corn, steak or chicken. The street corn, yuca fries and ceviche are also excellent starter choices. For your main, tuck into the paella and sample some of the best flavors you can find at a Downtown Indianapolis restaurant. The tacos are also excellent.
Livery | 720 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$
6. Shapiro’s Delicatessen
Steeped in history and flavor, Shapiro's Delicatessen has been an iconic presence on the Downtown Indianapolis restaurant scene since 1905. A family-owned establishment that spans generations, Shapiro's has perfected the art of classic deli delights.
The Vibe
An inviting atmosphere with a part deli, part diner-style aesthetic, plus charming checkered tile floors and friendly staff. The eatery is busy and bustling during peak hours, transforming into a more relaxed setting during quieter times. While not the most classic version of this type of restaurant, Shapiro’s definitely earns a place on the list of the best diners in Indianapolis.
What to Order
While renowned for its shaved corned beef sandwiches on rye, Shapiro's also offers an extensive menu beyond deli classics. Hearty entrées, soups, salads and delectable desserts can additionally be found at this laid-back Downtown Indianapolis restaurant.
Shapiro’s Delicatessen | 808 S. Meridian St., Indianapolis, IN 46225 | $$
7. Bluebeard
Located in the vibrant Fletcher Place neighborhood, Bluebeard is an Indy food hot spot with a rich history. The name is inspired by the novel “Bluebeard" by Kurt Vonnegut, a legendary Indianapolis author.
The Vibe
Bluebeard occupies a renovated warehouse, showcasing the industrial past while embracing modern aesthetics. Featuring exposed brick walls, rustic wooden accents and natural light, it’s a rare warm and cozy gem amongst the more modern Downtown Indianapolis restaurants.
What to Order
Guests at this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant can expect an ever-evolving menu showcasing seasonal and locally sourced ingredients. Standout dishes include house-made pasta, steaks and decadent seafood dishes, such as diver scallops and Pacific halibut with tomato beurre blanc.
Bluebeard | 653 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203 | $$$
8. Salt on Mass
Salt on Mass is a premier seafood restaurant in Downtown Indianapolis. It’s a must-try for those seeking the freshest catches.
The Vibe
This warm and inviting spot has lots of natural light and a part-steakhouse, part-bar vibe.
What to Order
For a seafood feast, start with fresh white fish sushi or lump crab cakes before moving on to main courses like pan-seared diver scallops or yellowfin tuna. The lobster mac and cheese and surf and turf are also decadent choices at this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant.
Salt on Mass | 505 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$
9. Yaso Jamaican Grill
Travel to Jamaica without leaving Indianapolis at Yaso Jamaican Grill. Founded by a husband-and-wife duo, the owners bring a slice of their Jamaican roots to the Downtown Indianapolis restaurant scene. The authenticity and commitment to traditional flavors found here have quickly made it a local favorite.
The Vibe
The atmosphere at this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant mirrors Jamaica’s laid-back spirit, with lots of color and a warm, welcoming feel.
What to Order
Choose a combo meal, that comes with your choice of meat like jerk chicken or oxtail, plus sides of rice and peas, plantains and cabbage. The snapper dishes, macaroni and cheese and Jamaican patties are additional must-tries.
Yaso Jamaican Grill | 1501 Prospect St., Indianapolis, IN 46203 | $$
10. Spoke and Steeple
Downtown Indianapolis restaurant Spoke and Steeple is popular for serving regional dishes along with a variety of international cuisine, offering something for everyone. It’s also open from 6.30 a.m. through midnight, making this one of the best places for breakfast in Indianapolis as well as lunch and dinner.
The Vibe
A modern and upscale spin on an old-fashioned bar with dark wood and comfy booth seating. Large glass windows illuminate the space, adding extra brightness to this chic Downtown Indianapolis restaurant.
What to Order
Start with the bruschetta or smoked salmon roulades. For your main course, the chicken pot pie is a comforting dish that everyone will love.
Spoke and Steele | 123 S. Illinois St., Indianapolis, IN 46225 | $$
11. Weber Grill Restaurant
A popular Downtown Indianapolis restaurant for classic barbecue, Weber Grill Restaurant has over 50 years of grilling experience, with the menu featuring a selection of tempting dishes for meat lovers.
The Vibe
Traditional steakhouse style with unique backyard barbecue décor items, creating a relaxing space that is great for casual dining.
What to Order
To start, enjoy appetizers like soft pretzels with beer cheese dip and skillet cornbread with molasses butter. Next, go for the Beer Can Chicken or barbecue baby back ribs, which can be accompanied by sides like mac and cheese or garlic mashed potatoes for the ultimate in barbecue at this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant. The burgers are also some of the best in the city!
Weber Grill Restaurant | 10 N. Illinois St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$$
12. Union 50
With an extensive bar drink and snack menu, Union 50 is a must-visit gastropub serving New American cuisine, plus local beers and inventive cocktails. It’s definitely worth a visit while exploring the Downtown Indianapolis restaurant scene!
The Vibe
This Downtown Indianapolis restaurant boasts an industrial vibe, making it both warm and rustic yet bright and modern. It also offers the perfect atmosphere for all types of meals, from family get-togethers and catch-ups with friends to date nights and even birthday dinners in Indianapolis.
What to Order
There are lots of classics like chicken wings, steaks and salads, but if you want something a little different, opt for the kimchi meatloaf or Toast + Jam, featuring sushi-grade ahi jam and wild gulf shrimp toast with wasabi tobiko and marinated cucumber. The chilaquile poutine is another interesting choice, merging Mexican and Canadian cuisines.
Union 50 | 620 N. East St., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$
13. Yard House
A Downtown Indianapolis restaurant destination for anyone looking for tasty dishes in a relaxed space, Yard House is an American-style bistro that features dishes from across the globe and a vast selection of craft beers. Founded in 1996, Yard House now has over 80 locations across the USA.
The Vibe
Modern meets industrial for the interior of this all-American casual dining space. This Downtown Indianapolis restaurant is open for happy hour, lunch, dinner and late-night dining, so stop by whenever you’re in the mood!
What to Order
Top dishes include the Nashville hot chicken sandwich and the Korean ribeye. Any of the burgers will also be a hit. There are additionally gluten-free, low-calorie, vegan and vegetarian options, including veggie burgers and Gardein chicken dishes. Don’t leave without having a delicious dessert and a craft beer or two.
Yard House | 15 W. Maryland St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$
14. The Library Restaurant & Pub
Nestled within an elegant building, The Library Restaurant & Pub is the perfect place for lunch or dinner on a rainy day, thanks to the warm atmosphere and comfort food dishes. Once the weather heats up, head outside to dine on the charming patio.
The Vibe
This Downtown Indianapolis restaurant honors the building’s heritage with vintage-style furnishings and décor items, plus wood accents and tranquil blue walls.
What to Order
The prime rib is one of the most popular dishes at this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant. It also comes with sides like garlic smashed potatoes, sautéed green beans and seasonal vegetables. The stuffed shrimp and onion soup are also popular if you want an appetizer to go with your main meal.
The Library Restaurant & Pub | 2610 S. Lynhurst Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46241 | $$
15. Vida
This iconic restaurant in Downtown Indianapolis emerges from the visionary efforts of restaurateur Mike Cunningham. Transcending its origins as a shaky old building in the Lockerbie neighborhood, Vida has been meticulously transformed into an AAA Four Diamond restaurant.
The Vibe
This top-tier Downtown Indianapolis restaurant is uniquely adorned with a live wall of growing herbs and greens. It offers a sensory experience that extends beyond exquisite flavors.
What to Order
Vida's tasting menus invite diners for a multi-course masterpiece of chef-chosen dishes, with a selection of courses and price points available. While dishes will vary, you may get to try delights like Maine scallops with a citrus-chile beurre blanc and A5 wagyu beef with black truffle sauce. For an even more lavish experience, opt for the wine pairing with your meal, and ensure you finish with a dessert.
Vida | 601 E. New York St., Indianapolis, IN, 46202 | $$$$
16. Tinker Street
With a nod to the original name of the street it is located on, Tinker Street offers a wide variety of dishes and boasts a large selection of vegetarian and vegan options.
The Vibe
A self-proclaimed “cozy, urban cottage,” this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant is a great place to unwind with delicious food and drinks. In the summer, there’s an outdoor patio and large doors that open out from the interior, creating an indoor-outdoor dining area.
What to Order
Treat yourself to oysters and confit marbled potatoes with caviar and black garlic purée before going for a flavorful main like tandoori marinated shrimp with cilantro rice. The vegan bao bun and Korean fried mushrooms are also recommended at this fusion Downtown Indianapolis restaurant.
Tinker Street | 402 E. 16th St., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$
17. Bru Burger Bar
A claim to fame for having locally sourced ingredients in a made-from-scratch menu, Bru Burger Bar stands out as a top Downtown Indianapolis restaurant for those who want high-quality food in a more laid-back space.
The Vibe
Rustic and chic, combining a traditional bar and exposed brick walls with modern décor pieces and lighting. This Downtown Indianapolis restaurant is just as good for a date night meal as it is for a few beers and appetizers with friends.
What to Order
Given the name of this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant, it’s not surprising that the burgers are the best thing to order here. Options range from classic beef burgers to bison, lamb and plant-based options. The toppings and seasonings are also interesting, including things like whipped goat cheese, a peppercorn-bourbon glaze and curry mayonnaise. Gluten-free burger buns can also be provided, meaning there’s an option for almost everyone!
Bru Burger Bar | 410 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$
18. Leviathan Bakehouse
A rising star in pastry-making in the city, Leviathan Bakehouse was founded with a passion for redefining the art of baking. This bakery has swiftly become known for its artisanal bread and delectable pastries that you can pick up in the heart of the Downtown Indianapolis restaurant district.
The Vibe
A welcoming atmosphere and a cozy interior, adorned with rustic-chic ornamentation and bright yellow accents, invite patrons to unwind in a peaceful setting.
What to Order
The breakfast sandwich, with a vegetarian option available, is a great choice for starting your day. If you prefer sweet, opt for a buttery croissant or sweet Danish pastry.
Leviathan Bakehouse | 1101 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$$
19. Tony’s of Indianapolis
Known as one of the best fine dining establishments on the Downtown Indianapolis restaurant scene, Tony’s of Indianapolis combines modern dishes with a classic American-style steakhouse vibe.
The Vibe
This restaurant in Indianapolis offers the perfect ambiance for a fancy evening out. Exquisite design with minimalist flare and classic steakhouse elements, plus an impressive wine display, make this a memorable place to dine.
What to Order
Steak lovers should try the New York striploin or filet mignon paired with creamed spinach or grilled asparagus. If you want something lighter, try a pasta dish, with vegetarian, fish and meat options available. This Downtown Indianapolis restaurant also has an exceptional wine list, enabling you to find the perfect complement to your meal.
Tony’s of Indianapolis | 110 W. Washington St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$$$
20. Yats
Enjoy a flavor-packed journey at Yats, a Downtown Indianapolis restaurant inspired by vibrant Creole and Cajun traditions and classic New Orleans dishes.
The Vibe
Casual and inviting, with colorful walls and furniture reflecting the lively spirit of the Big Easy. There are lots of NOLA-themed décor pieces as well, such as Mardi Gras beads and masks. The energetic atmosphere at this popular Downtown Indianapolis restaurant creates a welcoming space where patrons can feel at home with Southern comfort food.
What to Order
Indulge in Yats' signature dishes like the étouffée or jambalaya, each bursting with bold flavors and a comforting warmth that transports diners to the heart of Louisiana.
Yats | Multiple Locations | $
21. Conner’s Kitchen + Bar
Located inside the Indianapolis Marriott, Conner’s Kitchen + Bar is a lively spot that’s great for dinner and drinks any night of the week. This Downtown Indianapolis restaurant is also open for breakfast and lunch and is perfect for a work meeting or midday meal with friends.
The Vibe
Upscale yet warm and welcoming with leather booth seating, mood lighting and exposed brick walls, plus contemporary fire pits in the outdoor seating area. If you’re stopping in for drinks and bar snacks, feel free to sit at the stylish bar.
What to Order
For dinner, start with the spicy guacamole before going for comforting fried chicken with hot honey drizzle and accompaniments of mashed potatoes, coleslaw and gravy. The Greenhouse Gemelli is also an excellent choice, with the option to add chicken, shrimp or salmon.
Conner’s Kitchen + Bar | 350 W. Maryland St., Indianapolis, IN 46225 | $$
22. Nada
Featuring gourmet Mexican dishes paired with famous house margaritas and other cocktails, Nada is an excellent place for a fun and delicious night out.
The Vibe
This bright and vibrant Downtown Indianapolis restaurant features colorful interiors paired with natural wood for a tranquil yet upbeat dining experience.
What to Order
The tacos, including pork al pastor and Baja fish tacos, are a must-try. The Nada Mac and Cheese, with jalapeño, roasted poblano and garlic breadcrumbs is also delicious, offering a twist on the classic dish. Be sure to try a few cocktails with your meal, with options including pineapple mojitos and spicy margaritas.
Nada | 11 W. Maryland St. Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$
23. Root & Bone
Nestled in the heart of SoBro, Root & Bone is a gem curated by Janine Booth and Jeff McInnis, bringing their culinary prowess to the vibrant streets of Indianapolis.
The Vibe
The ambiance dances between Southern charm and modern sophistication. The décor exudes warmth with rustic touches, creating an inviting space for casual gatherings and special occasions.
What to Order
The fried chicken steals the show at this Downtown Indianapolis restaurant. Brined in sweet tea and fried to perfection, it showcases the soulfulness of Southern cuisine. The fish dishes are also highly recommended. Complement your meal with signature biscuits that will transport you to the heart of comfort food.
Root & Bone | 4601 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46205 | $$
Try Cooking Indianapolis Foods
While going out to eat at the best restaurants in Downtown Indianapolis can’t be missed, cooking at home is also a fun activity that allows you to recreate the flavors that make the city famous. Whether you’re a seasoned cook who wants to elevate your skills are are completely new to preparing your own meals, enrolling in cooking classes in Indianapolis is a great idea if you want to give your home cooking a boost.
Join 200,000+ Culinary Enthusiasts
The Downtown Indianapolis restaurant scene is packed with culinary gems, from upscale eateries to more laid-back spots and everything in between. If you’ve been struggling to decide where to make reservations in Indy, this list of the 23 best restaurants should have given you a good idea of where to start your dining adventure!
For even more ways to explore Indianapolis and beyond, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.