37 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis in 2024

Last Updated on April 26, 2024 | 0 Comments
Discover the best restaurants Indianapolis has to offer

Looking to explore the best restaurants that Indianapolis has to offer? Ready to take a culinary journey through the innovative flavors of this thriving city? Indianapolis, or Indy for short, is the proud host of many recognized restaurants—some steeped in fascinating history, others emerging fresh onto the scene in recent years. 

Each restaurant on this list has an intriguing story to tell and good food to accompany it. Located all across the city, from the bustling center to its lesser-known outskirts, there’s a restaurant on this list perfect for your next visit. 

 Jump to Section

Book a Gourmet Cooking Class Now
Kick-start your culinary confidence with help from a world-class chef. See what's cooking in your city today.
Book Now

The 37 Best Indianapolis Restaurants 

1. St. Elmo Steak House 

Kicking off the list is St. Elmo Steak House, known as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis to visit. Established in 1902, step inside this historical landmark for a delicious meal that you’ll remember for years to come. 

The Vibe

This classic steakhouse embodies its upscale reputation, providing guests with an atmosphere that feels both refined and sophisticated. 

What to Order

Begin your dining experiences with St. Elmo’s renowned shrimp cocktail served with their spicy signature sauce. For the main course, the filet mignon is always an excellent choice along with the prime rib steak which gets slow-roasted to perfection. 

St. Elmo Steak House | 127 S. Illinois St., Indianapolis, IN 46225 | $$$$ 

Shrimp cocktail served with spicy signature sauce and saltine crackers
via St. Elmo Steak House

2. Delicia 

Head to Delicia for a contemporary twist on Latin American cuisine that’s sure to impress. Discover why this is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for Latin food, with its captivating medley of traditional flavors from the Americas, Caribbean and Spain. 

The Vibe

Delicia exudes a hip, chic and lively ambiance, solidifying its reputation as one of the best restaurants Indianapolis has to offer when it comes to Latin fare. 

What to Order 

The queso fundido with chorizo is a hearty appetizer bursting with delicious flavors. For a satisfying main course, sampler the tender duck enchiladas with a pairing of rice. 

Delicia | 5215 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $$$ 

3. BRU Burger Bar 

As one of the top local burger restaurants in the city, BRU Burger Bar is not to be missed. This is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis to satisfy your cravings for a classic burger complemented by handcrafted sides and drinks to match. 

The Vibe

Expect a lively and inviting atmosphere, as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis should be. It’s a perfect setting for gathering with friends and family. 

What to Order

For first-timers, the signature burger is a must-try. Alternatively, opt for the turkey burger for a unique twist, featuring a sweet peach compote and curry-flavored mayo on a toasty oat bun. 

BRU Burger Bar | Multiple Locations | $$ 

The BRU burger is the signature dish from one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis
via BRU Burger

4. Livery 

Indulge in a classic Latin meal at Livery for a memorable night out in town. Known as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis when it comes to authentic Latin dishes, Livery offers a vibrant and fun dining experience. 

The Vibe

Experience a rustic and stylish ambiance, with an outdoor patio suited perfectly for summer evenings. 

What to Order

The steak empanadas are delicious and come with onion, pepper and a spicy guajillo crema. If you like to share, try the refreshing ceviche with shrimp, tomato, poblano pepper, and a blend of spices, served with a side of tortilla chips. 

Livery | 720 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$ 

5. Bluebeard

Named after a Kurt Vonnegut novel, Bluebeard pays homage to the heartfelt tale with its equally heartwarming food. It's no wonder this establishment is celebrated as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for modern yet artisanal American fare. 

The Vibe

Bluebeard combines a hip décor with a nautical flair. This is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis if you’re looking for a warm and welcoming atmosphere that’s rich with history. 

What to Order

The beet salad is the perfect starter, with a mix of fresh greens under a rich truffle vinaigrette. For a main course, the Faroe Island salmon is one of the most popular choices for diners.

Bluebeard | 653 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203 | $$$ 

Salmon served with crispy confit potato, lemon and horseradish
via Bluebeard

6. Milktooth 

For brunch enthusiasts, MilkTooth is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis offering elevated diner fare. Opened by award-winning chef Jonathan Brooks back in 2014, this acclaimed establishment has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike with its creative menu. 

The Vibe

Milktooth boasts a bright and rustic mood, with open-concept communal seating, gleaming wooden tables and a cheery outdoor patio perfect for warm days. 

What to Order

The famous savory Dutch baby pancakes are a local favorite, served with sausage, fresh salsa and cheese. For a unique twist, the sweet potato latkes expertly infuse Asian flavors into a classic dish.  Don’t miss out on the decadent tres leches for dessert. 

Milktooth | 534 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203 | $$ 

Book a Gourmet Cooking Class Now
Kick-start your culinary confidence with help from a world-class chef. See what's cooking in your city today.
Book Now

7. Vida 

Vida is a classy restaurant that boasts AAA’s Four Diamond Award for good reason. The chef’s tasting menu of delicious worldly cuisine helps make it one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for celebrating special occasions with your loved ones. 

The Vibe

Exuding sleek modernity, this is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis if you’re searching for a sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere. 

What to Order

The scallops are always fresh and come with Brussels sprouts, fingerling potatoes and an intricate gochujang-maple brown butter. For a perfect finale, try their signature ricotta doughnuts served with bourbon maple glaze, candied bacon, maple cream, brown butter crumble and sea salt caramel ice cream.

Vida | 601 E. New York St., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$$$ 

Ricotta doughnuts take center stage on one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis
via Vida

8. Mesh 

Step into a fine and memorable dining experience at Mesh, one of the best restaurants that Indianapolis has to offer. Enjoy impeccable service and inventive, inspiring dishes that always aim to push the bar further. 

The Vibe

Mesh’s atmosphere is quite intimate and romantic. The wooden floors, warm lighting and cozy seats undoubtedly make this one of the best places to eat in Indianapolis. 

What to Order

Start with a smooth and creamy lobster bisque. For entrées, the Amish chicken is a popular choice that comes with a unique bleu cheese mashed potatoes, prosciutto and an intricate sherry cream sauce. 

Mesh | 725 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$ 

9. Ramen Ray 

Experience Ramen Ray, one of the first and best restaurants in Indianapolis to serve authentic Hokkaido-style Sapporo ramen. Enjoy a complete casual dining experience that feels like a home away from home, but be prepared for bustling crowds, especially on weekends. 

The Vibe

Cozy and inviting, Ramen Ray is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for casual dining and catching up with friends or family over ramen.

What to Order

Savor the Sapporo-style spicy miso ramen, served with a spicy miso broth, sliced ground pork stir-fry, house-braised chashu and a perfectly soft-boiled egg. For those with milder tastes, the shoyu is a great choice. 

Ramen Ray | 5628 E. 71st St., Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $$ 

Spicy miso ramen served with broth, sliced ground pork stir-fry, chashu and a soft-boiled egg
via Ramen Ray

10. Caplinger’s Fresh Catch 

Seafood lovers can rejoice at the extensive menu that Caplinger’s Fresh Catch offers. True to its name, this is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis offering fresh, delicious and premier seafood dishes cooked to order. 

The Vibe

To mirror its no-frills nautical nature, this restaurant keeps things simple with counter-style ordering and a casual atmosphere. Great for a relaxed evening of trying out new seafood dishes. 

What to Order

Indulge in the lobster roll sandwich, featuring seasoned lobster claw and knuckle meat on a freshly baked roll. Opt for the smoked tuna salad sandwich if you are looking for a more customizable array of toppings to suit your preferences.

Caplinger’s Fresh Catch | Multiple Locations | $$ 

11. Oakley’s Bistro 

Oakley’s Bistro is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for French-inspired new American fare. Located inside a strip mall,  this hidden gem serves up beautifully plated dishes that are sure to inspire and entice you to return. 

The Vibe

Classy yet comfortable, this is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis to visit for an upscale dining experience with your partner or close friends. 

What to Order

The shrimp corndogs are a local favorite, served with a side of bistro honey mustard. Elsewise, savor the popular meatloaf, accompanied by balanced sides of chile jam and whipped potato purée. 

Oakley’s Bistro | 1464 W. 86th St., Indianapolis, IN 46260 | $$$ 

Shrimp corndogs are a local favorite from one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis
via Oakley’s Bistro

12. Iozzo’s Garden of Italy 

Take a stroll through the Italian vineyards with a visit to Iozzo’s Garden of Italy, one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis serving authentic Italian cuisine. With a storied history dating back to the 1930s, this restaurant closed for a decade before experiencing a triumphant reopening in 2009. 

The Vibe

An authentic and welcoming energy, with exposed brick walls and spacious seating. Iozzo’s Garden of Italy is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis that encourages long conversations over plates of endless pasta, wine and more. 

What to Order

The piccata is rich and comes as your choice of fresh chicken, veal, salmon or scallops. For pasta lovers, the five-layer lasagna bolognese and pasta carbonara are great options.  

Iozzo’s Garden of Italy | 946 S. Meridian St., Indianapolis, IN 46225 | $$  

Book a Gourmet Cooking Class Now
Kick-start your culinary confidence with help from a world-class chef. See what's cooking in your city today.
Book Now

13. Tlaolli 

Tlaolli stands out as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for classic Mexican fare. Serving up both meat and meatless options, this restaurant prides itself on being vegetarian and vegan-friendly. 

The Vibe

As one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis, Tlaolli exudes a trendy and cheerful mood. The interior boasts colorful walls adorned with splashes of pink and green, complemented by bright yellow chairs to match. 

What to Order

The signature torta is a must-try, a well-rounded baguette sandwich with black bean purée, avocado, cotija cheese and more fresh ingredients. For mild spice lovers, the pork carnitas tacos are a great choice. For a bolder flavor experience, don’t sleep on the Quesadilla Flameada. 

Tlaolli | 2830 E. Washington St., Indianapolis, IN 46201 | $$ 

Carnitas tacos served with cilantro and onions
via Canva

14. Leviathan Bakehouse 

Leviathan Bakehouse specializes in baked goods and savory breakfast fare, earning its place as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis when it comes to breakfast foods, especially croissants. 

The Vibe

One of the best restaurants in Indianapolis where history meets the modern-day lifestyle. Located in the city’s Chatham Arch neighborhood, this bakehouse offers spacious seating underneath natural light and delicious smells of fresh bread in the oven. 

What to Order

Go for the classic breakfast sandwich to get a Leviathan croissant complete with local ham, Gruyère Swiss cheese, savory soft shallot baked eggs and a vibrant green salsa. For drinks, try the refreshingly unique honey pistachio latte. 

Leviathan Bakehouse | 1101 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$ 

15. Tinker Street 

Tinker Street is a 21+ restaurant that serves up contemporary American cuisine with fresh local ingredients and modern twists. A rotating seasonal menu keeps things exciting and lively, as expected at one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis. 

The Vibe

Intimate, warm and always friendly. Whether you choose to settle into a cozy booth for the evening or venture out onto the outdoor patio, this is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis to add to your list of birthday ideas in Indianapolis

What to Order

The menu changes constantly, but for a classic dish, consider trying the Sirloin. The Korean fried mushrooms are also a current highlight on the menu. 

Tinker Street | 402 E. 16th St., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$$ 

Classic sirloin is always a good choice in one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis
via Tinker Street

16. Pier 48 

If you’re looking for one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for seafood, look no further. Pier 48 is a fish house and oyster bar that serves up fresh Atlantic lobster flown in directly from the east coast of Maine. 

The Vibe 

Pier 48 embodies a relaxed, spacious and welcoming atmosphere, reflecting its status as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis. Guests can enjoy comfy seating surrounded by white and blue tiled walls to match the seaside theme. 

What to Order

Start with the crispy crab beignets served with a side of fragrant garlic herb cream cheese. Another crowd-pleaser is the fresh lobster roll available in both hot and cold variations.

Pier 48 | 130 S. Pennsylvania St., Ste. B, Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$$ 

17. Ale Emporium 

Step into Ale Emporium, one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis when it comes to pub food, ensuring a memorable experience for pub-lovers. There’s plenty of beer, wings and even a trademarked sauce to go around. 

The Vibe

Ale Emporium encompasses the classic bustling atmosphere of a sports pub, making it one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis. With spacious seating and large TV screens, you can easily keep track of the game while enjoying your meal. 

What to Order

Try the wings with the Hermanaki® sauce for a satisfying treat. You also can’t go wrong with any of the other three award-winning Herman sauces. 

Ale Emporium | Multiple Locations | $$ 

Chicken wings served with signature sauce on ceramic plate
via Canva

18. Bazbeaux

If you’re on the hunt for one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis serving fresh pizza pies, Bazbeaux is your answer. Named after a French court jester turned chef, Bazbeaux now boasts two locations in the city and three across Indiana. 

The Vibe

Warm, casual and comfortable—Bazbeaux is among the top Indianapolis restaurants that create a friendly, whimsical atmosphere for their guests. 

What to Order

Go for the quattro formaggio, especially if you enjoy a classic combination of bacon and mushrooms. The house special and bayou chicken pizzas are also savory crowd-pleasers. 

Bazbeaux | Multiple Locations | $$ 

19. BODHI 

BODHI stands out as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis servingauthentic Thai cuisine in a cozy gastropub setting. Inspired by the Sanskrit-Thai word “enlightenment,” it’s clear that this family restaurant hits all the marks with its inspiring and creative menu. 

The Vibe

Industrial-chic and full of refreshing greenery make this one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for impressing a date or catching up with friends. 

What to Order

Try the Thai noodle soup for fresh flavors and a kick of spice. For spice enthusiasts, the panang curry is another great dish served with vegetables on top of a bed of jasmine rice. 

BODHI | 922 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$ 

Thai noodle soup is savory dish at one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis
via BODHI

20. Lincoln Square Pancake House 

If you’re looking for one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis when it comes to retro diners, take a visit to Lincoln Square Pancake House. Established in 1989, this chain has multiple locations across the city today for breakfast lovers to enjoy. 

The Vibe 

Old-fashioned in the best way possible, with cozy booth seating and muted walls that bring you back to the good old days of casual breakfast dining. 

What to Order

This is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis serving pancakes, so make sure to try the house pancakes topped with butter and powdered sugar. Try the vegetable skillet topped with eggs for a nutritious and savory start to the day.

Lincoln Square Pancake House | Multiple Locations | $$ 

Book a Gourmet Cooking Class Now
Kick-start your culinary confidence with help from a world-class chef. See what's cooking in your city today.
Book Now

21. Our Table American Bistro 

Our Table American Bistro is a hidden gem among the best restaurants near Indianapolis. Just a half-hour drive away from the city center, it offers a welcoming dining experience led by the expertise of Chef Joe and his wife, Ginger. 

The Vibe

Quaint and lively, with the wooden booths, a fireplace and an outdoor patio, making it a top contender for one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis. 

What to Order

Start with the richly seasoned Cajun truffle frites as your appetizer. For mains, try the shrimp bucatini ‘Diablo.’ Finish with the apple pie, which comes drizzled with caramel sauce. 

Our Table American Bistro | 5080 IN-135, Ste. A, Bargersville, IN 46106 | $$$ 

Slice of appple pie drizzled with caramel sauce
via Canva

22. 10th Street Diner 

When it comes to delicious vegan food crafted with the freshest ingredients, 10th Street Diner is highlighted as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis. Their signature rotating menu means that there’s always a new creation to try. 

The Vibe

Industrial-chic and friendly, with exposed brick walls, wooden furniture and a smattering of plants to soften the overall décor. 

What to Order 

While the menu changes regularly, the burgers are always a good choice. Try the classic 10th Street burger with all the vegetarian toppings you desire. The latest brunch options are also great, especially the huevos rancheros if available.  

10th Street Diner | 3301 E. 10th St., Indianapolis, IN 46201 | $$ 

23. Love Handle

Up next is Love Handle, one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis renowned for its fun and creative breakfast and lunch fare. It’s also a popular spot for locals.  

The Vibe

Love Handle’s colorful appearance sets it apart as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis, offering an eclectic and quirky atmosphere. While you wait, you can admire the walls of unique vintage items. 

What to Order

Although the menu changes weekly, try the latest breakfast sandwich for a well-balanced combination of freshly prepared artisanal ingredients. As for the lunch menu, make sure to try the tender beef brisket if it’s available. 

Love Handle | 877 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$ 

Catfish breakfast sandwich served with sausage gravy on a biscuit
via Love Handle

24. Cleo’s Bodega & Café

When rounding up a list of the best restaurants in Indianapolis, Cleo’s Bodega & Café is a must-add. A community-centric establishment operated by Flanner House, this unassuming café doubles as a bodega, both of which offer freshly made local goods. 

The Vibe

Casual and community-centered, with an outdoor patio for the warmer seasons. Cleo’s also acts as a venue for talented live music performances, making it one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis to immerse yourself in local culture while enjoying delicious food and great entertainment. 

What to Order

The Halle Berry smoothie is always a refreshing choice. For a savory treat, try their Good Morning, Trapper sandwich: a croissant sandwich with eggs, cheese and a brush of Chef Oya’s Trap Buttah on top. 

Cleo’s Bodega & Café | 2432 Doctor Mlk Jr. St., Flanner House, Indianapolis, IN 46208 | $ 

25. Petite Chou Bistro and Champagne Bar 

Embark on a journey to Paris without leaving the country at Petite Chou Bistro and Champagne Bar, one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for casual French cuisine. Led by successful restaurateur Martha Hoover, this restaurant has gained high recognition for its innovative menu. 

The Vibe

Easygoing yet romantic, with sweet mood lighting above the outdoor patio and an extensive wine list. Enjoying a meal with your loved one here is a great addition to your list of  upcoming date ideas in Indianapolis 

What to Order

For brunch, try the hearty croque madame or, for a sweeter option, the fresh berry crêpes. For a midday menu, savor the Mussels Meuniere with shallots, garlic confit & roasted fennel cream

Petite Chou Bistro and Champagne Bar | 823 Westfield Blvd., Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $$ 

Mussels are a specialty dish in one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis
via Petite Chou Bistro and Champagne Bar

26. Chef Oya’s The Trap 

Chef Oya’s The Trap ranks among the best restaurants in Indianapolis for seafood enthusiasts. Led by Chef Oya Woodruff, the unique walk-up style restaurant serves boil-style trays in signature trap buttah sauces that leave customers planning their next visit. 

The Vibe

 Capturing a great sense of excitement, The Trap stands out as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis with its highly recognized dishes, social justice roots, and takeout-only setup.

What to Order

Make sure to try the loaded crab legs for a fresh and flavorful experience. The loaded shrimp, lobster tails and trap chowder are also satisfying options. 

Chef Oya’s The Trap | 3355 N. Keystone Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46218 | $$ 

Book a Gourmet Cooking Class Now
Kick-start your culinary confidence with help from a world-class chef. See what's cooking in your city today.
Book Now

27. The Eagle Mass Ave 

Step into The Eagle Mass Ave to experience one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis when it comes to award-winning Southern fried chicken. This national chain restaurant proudly stands on Mass Avenue and serves signature free-range chicken, brined and dredged in-house.

The Vibe

Lively and cheerful, with comfy booths and tables lined by walls of exposed brick and a watchful bald eagle mural. 

What to Order

The chicken legs are a local favorite. You can also share a whole chicken with the family or an eager group of friends. For sides, try the sweet potato crock complete with toasted mini marshmallows. 

The Eagle Mass Ave | 310 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$ 

Fried chicken legs are a legendary dish at one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis
via The Eagle Mass Ave

28. La Parada 

La Parada is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for authentic Mexican fare, particularly on a cool summer evening. With an extensive menu that offers something for everyone, it’s easy to tell why this restaurant is a favorite among locals. 

The Vibe

Casual and fun, with vibrant artwork on the walls and incorporated into the booths and chairs, La Parada stands out as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis to relax after a long week. 

What to Order

Bite into the well-portioned chimichanga to experience an intricate, expertly balanced combination of spices, rice, meat and refried beans. 

La Parada | 1642 E. New York St., Ste. A, Indianapolis, IN 46201 | $$ 

29. Café Patachou

With six locations across the city, it’s clear that Café Patachou is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis, cherished by locals and visitors alike as a beloved cornerstone. Founded by Martha Hoover, this vegetarian-friendly brunch spot prides itself on using locally and organically sourced ingredients, elevating every dish to a culinary delight. 

The Vibe

Radiating a bright and airy ambiance, Café Patachou creates an inviting atmosphere that beckons diners to savor their experience to the fullest, making it one of the best places to eat in Indianapolis. 

What to Order

Try the thick sourdough or whole wheat bread cinnamon toast for a sweet treat. For a vegan option, the Phat Rabbit is a great choice, stacked with avocado, spinach, tomato, red onion, beets, carrots, and two healthy schmears of cashew ricotta & vegan spinach-jalapeño pesto.

Café Patachou | Multiple Locations | $$ 

Vegan sandwich served avocado, spinach, tomato and carrots
via Café Patachou

30. The Fountain Room 

As one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis when it comes to fine dining in a distinguished atmosphere, The Fountain Room pulls out all the stops to create an impressive, memorable experience. This restaurant is a long-awaited return to the iconic era of supper clubs. 

The Vibe

Elegant and enjoyable, The Fountain Room exudes class with candlelit tables set amidst a stunning dining room featuring velvet benches, ornate chandeliers and nostalgic décor. 

What to Order

The wagyu meatloaf is a melt-in-your-mouth dish that comes with herb brown gravy, fluffy whipped potatoes and tender broccolini. For dessert, try the grasshopper pie named after its crème de menthe flavoring. 

The Fountain Room | 830 Massachusetts Ave., Ste. 1480, Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$$ 

31. Vicino 

Experience the allure of Italian cuisine at Vicino, one of the newest and best restaurants in Indianapolis. The innovative menu offers a mix of traditional dishes and creative reimaginings. 

The Vibe

By day, Vicino exudes a bright and airy atmosphere that transforms into a lively mood-lit one when night falls. As one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis, Vicino’s fun and romantic setting makes it perfect for date nights. 

What to Order

Start with an order of beautifully plated crostini bruschetta. Don't miss the star of the menu, the carbonara featuring bucatini pasta with a smooth cream sauce and rich black truffle oil. 

Vicino | 350 Massachusetts Ave., Ste. 150, Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$$ 

Crostini bruschetta is a great appetizer from one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis
via Vicino

32. Magoo’s California Pizza 

Magoo’s California Pizza is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for those looking to grab a slice of halal pizza. Originally from California, Magoo’s diverse menu offers flavors to satisfy every palate. 

The Vibe

The casual atmosphere of this no-frill pizza joint easily makes it one of the best places to eat in Indianapolis. Perfect for a lunchtime treat or a relaxing evening dinner with friends after a long work day. 

What to Order

The chicken tikka or the supreme pizzas are both trustworthy choices, especially with Magoo’s signature kabob sauce.

Magoo’s California Pizza | Multiple Locations | $$

33. Black Leaf Vegan 

Black Leaf Vegan is among the best restaurants in Indianapolis for vegan fare served in a sleek and modern setting. The restaurant also doubles as a versatile space for private parties and a caterer for events. 

The Vibe

Black Leaf Vegan stands out as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis as it captures casual and easygoing energy. Adorned with wooden slat walls, chic lighting and spacious seats, it offers a welcoming mood for diners. 

What to Order

Try the famous original Black Leaf burger complete with a plant-based patty and spiced teriyaki sauce. For an even more memorable experience, try the vegan loaded nachos.

Black Leaf Vegan | 335 W. 9th St., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$ 

Vegan lodaded nachos served with teriyaki sauce
via Black Leaf Vegan

34. Ripple Bagel & Deli 

Transport yourself to the past as you step through the colorful doors of Ripple Bagel & Deli, one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for deli meats and bagel sandwiches. After all, there’s nothing better than starting your day with a delicious made-to-order bagel. 

The Vibe

Friendly service and whimsical retro décor create a welcoming atmosphere that makes this one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for artfully crafted bagels. 

What to Order

First-time visitors should go for the aptly named Morning Mess, an amalgamation of crispy bacon, eggs and three kinds of melted cheese on a toasted everything bagel. 

Ripple Bagel & Deli | 850 Broad Ripple Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $ 

35. Half Liter BBQ & Beer Hall 

Step into the boisterous atmosphere of Half Liter BBQ & Beer Hall, one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for Texas-style barbeque and locally brewed beer. During warmer months, you can dine outside in a 250-seat beer garden complete with firepits. 

The Vibe

Half Liter is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis offering a fun and lively setting. Here you can also enjoy a tailored experience by opting for the family-friendly floor or the 21+ floor. 

What to Order

The Biergarten pretzel is a salty classic. For a hearty main course, try the Carolina pork sandwich which features signature pulled pork, smoked turkey and swiss cheese on a hoagie bun. 

Half Liter BBQ & Beer Hall | 5301 Winthrop Ave., Ste. 2, Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $$ 

The Biergarten pretzel is a great snack from one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis
via Canva

36. La Margarita 

La Margarita is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis when it comes to Mexican bar-style establishments. Right in Fountain Square, it serves as the perfect stop to end a day of exploring the different attractions within the neighborhood. 

The Vibe

Modern art adorns the walls of this chic restaurant. Combined with some rustic embellishments, La Margarita’s unique interior achieves the ideal mix of both the nostalgic past and the timely present. 

What to Order

Try the carne asada, a dish of grilled and sliced steak topped with caramelized onions and refreshing cilantro. The burrito Azteca is also a reliable choice. 

La Margarita | 1043 Virginia Ave., Ste. 1A, Indianapolis, IN 46203 | $$ 

37. Root & Bone

If you’re looking to take a trip down South without leaving the city, Root & Bone has got you covered. This is one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis for fresh farm-to-table Southern fare, served in a cozy exposed-brick setting. 

The Vibe

Root & Bone captures that signature Southern charm with intimate lighting above a relaxed atmosphere, making it one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis. Great for a fun night out with friends or your partner. 

What to Order

In addition to the latest seasonal offerings, make sure to try the artfully crafted drunken deviled eggs to start. Don't miss the signature fried chicken, a popular choice among patrons. 

Root & Bone | 4601 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46205 | $$  

Fried chicken served with slices of lemon and cilantro
via Root & Bone

Try Cooking Indianapolis Foods 

The food scene in Indianapolis is vibrant, with something for everyone and hidden gems everywhere. Along with the city’s diverse culture, the best restaurants in Indianapolis are always evolving. 

With so many signature restaurants, it’s easy to become inspired about trying your hand at creating similar Indianapolis-famous foods with your own unique twists. Learn the secrets to cooking the foods that make this city famous with cooking classes in Indianapolis that unveil the essence of its renowned cuisine. 

When it comes to the best restaurants in Indianapolis, there’s no shortage of options to choose from. This abundance is a testament to the great values of this city. Each restaurant on this list works to create community and connection with every dish served. The heart behind each innovative establishment is truly an inspiring feat to behold. 

For even more ways to explore Indianapolis and beyond, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.