17 Best Culver's Custard Flavors To Try in 2025

When it comes to sweet treats, Culver’s custard flavors are truly in a league of their own. With rich, layered textures and perfectly blended mix-ins, Culver’s has mastered the art of doing frozen custard right. Whether you're a die-hard chocolate fan, a fruit-forward dessert lover or someone who can't say no to a peanut butter swirl, there’s a Culver’s frozen custard flavor just waiting to win you over.

But with so many incredible choices, where do you even begin to pick a favorite? Don’t worry, we’ve rounded up 17 of the best Culver’s custard flavors you won't hesitate to dive into spoon-first.

Jump to Section

• The 17 Best Culver's Frozen Custard Flavors

The 17 Best Culver's Frozen Custard Flavors

1. Caramel Fudge Cookie Dough

"Caramel Fudge Cookie Dough" may be a mouthful to say, but it’s even more of a treat to eat. This popular Culver’s custard flavor is a glorious union of gooey salted caramel swirls, hot fudge ribbons and chewy chunks of cookie dough.

It’s a dream team dessert combo made for anyone who believes more is more when it comes to indulgence. It is on the sweeter side, so if you don't have much of a sweet tooth, it might be a bit much. But for fans of Culver’s custard flavors who love a little (or a lot) of decadence, it’s a winner.

2. Turtle

Far from its slow-moving namesake, Turtle is a decadent pick for those who don't mind a quick sugar rush. Each scoop of this Culver’s custard flavor blends creamy vanilla frozen custard with ribbons of nostalgic salted caramel, crunchy roasted pecans and rich chocolate. It hits all the sweet spots with a marriage of smooth, salty, nutty and sugary in every bite.

If you usually lean toward lighter desserts, this one might feel a little extra (it’s not shy about the sugar). But if you're all about rich, nostalgic flavors that have stood the test of time, Turtle is a fan-favorite for good reason.

3. Raspberry Cheesecake

Raspberry Cheesecake strikes the perfect balance between tangy fruit and heavenly vanilla custard. Swirled with real raspberries and dotted with chunks of velvety cheesecake waiting to be discovered, this flavor is a fruity dream with a luxurious twist.

It leans toward the sophisticated side of Culver’s custard flavors, with the raspberry adding a refreshing zing and the cheesecake bringing its rich, satisfying texture. The only downside? It might be a bit too rich — but that’s part of its charm.

4. Mint Explosion

Whether you think mint desserts taste like toothpaste or you’re drooling just at the thought of it, this Culver’s custard flavor is a refreshing take on a classic treat. Each scoop features creamy mint frozen custard packed with Oreo cookie chunks, crunchy chocolate bits and irresistible Andes candy bits.

A mint lover’s dream, this Culver’s custard flavor delivers a refreshing kick just sharp enough to wake up your taste buds. If you’re not on team mint, this one might taste a little strong, but for fans of bold, fresh flavors, Mint Explosion is easily one of Culver’s standout scoops.

5. Devil's Food Cake

What happens when chocolate decides to go all out? You get the ridiculously indulgent Devil’s Food Cake that truly embodies decadence. This bold pick from the Culver’s custard flavors lineup starts with a dreamy dark chocolate base. It then dives straight into even richer territory with chunks of moist devil’s food cake and plenty of novelty chocolate for good measure.

It’s not light, but that’s kind of the point, so if chocolate isn’t your jam, you may feel overwhelmed. But if you’re chasing that full-bodied, velvety, cocoa-loaded experience, this custard doesn’t hold back, and that’s exactly why it’s such a hit.

6. Butter Pecan

What’s a dessert lineup without a nod to good old Butter Pecan? This popular dessert is pure comfort in a sweet treat, the kind of classic that keeps Culver’s custard flavors feeling timeless. It nails this feeling with a buttery-smooth base and a generous helping of perfectly roasted pecans. The balance is just right — sweet and nutty with a warm, toasty finish that lingers in the best way.

This flavor is tailor-made for old souls and anyone who appreciates a scoop (or two) of nostalgia. It’s not flashy, but that’s the charm, and few Culver’s custard flavors deliver so much flavor with minimal ingredients. 

7. Really Reese's

If you really want something to talk about, Really Reese’s is the flavor to try. A peanut butter lover’s dream, it features rich, moist chocolate custard loaded with generous chunks of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. Every bite hits that crave-worthy sweet-salty balance with creamy, chocolatey depth and just the right amount of peanut butter punch. 

The obvious con with this sweet treat? It’s a no-go for anyone with nut allergies. But for everyone else, it’s one of those Culver’s frozen custard flavors that delivers exactly what you want when that chocolate-peanut butter craving hits. 

8. Georgia Peach

Savor everything summer has to offer, one scoop at a time, with Georgia Peach. Complete with peach frozen custard and juicy peach pieces, this Culver’s custard flavor brings a fresh, fruity charm that’s sweet but not overpowering.

It’s a dream for anyone who loves light, refreshing flavors that are mellow yet memorable. That said, if you’re usually team chocolate or caramel, this one might come off a bit too subtle. Still, this flavor stands out when you’re craving a summer dessert that's sweet, sunny and a little bit Southern.

9. Caramel Cashew

Caramel Cashew is a salty-sweet masterpiece loved by fans of sugary, nutty combos. Lush, creamy vanilla custard sets the stage for buttery ribbons of golden caramel and a liberal helping of lightly salted cashews. The contrast between smooth and crunchy, rich and nutty, makes every bite feel like a little celebration. 

This Culver’s custard flavor pulls double duty — satisfying your sweet tooth and salty snack cravings in one smooth, rich-textured scoop. If you’re chasing that nostalgic sundae-shop vibe with a grown-up twist, this one’s guaranteed to hit the spot.

10. Double Strawberry

What’s better than a dessert with one strawberry element? Something with two! And Culver’s Double Strawberry delivers exactly that. This heavenly Culver’s custard flavor is a berry lover’s dream, blending fruity strawberry custard and real strawberry pieces for a double dose of fruity bliss.

What's more, thanks to strawberries being high in antioxidants, according to EHL Insights, this flavor has added health benefits. This strawberry dessert hits all the right notes, from juicy and tangy to just sweet enough to keep you going back for another spoonful. 

11. Cappuccino Cookie Crumble

What happens when your favorite afternoon pick-me-up meets your go-to dessert? You get Cappuccino Cookie Crumble, where rich espresso frozen custard marries with bits of novelty chocolate and chewy sugar cookie chunks. It’s one of those Culver’s custard flavors that makes your coffee break feel like it got a delicious upgrade.

The only con is the caffeine kick, so if you’re actively avoiding it, this isn’t the Culver’s custard flavor for you. But if you’re a caffeine enthusiast or a cookie-lover at heart, this flavor will absolutely combine your favorite coffee shop moments with those from your most beloved dessert spots.

12. Chocolate Covered Strawberry

Treat yourself to a Valentine’s Day scoop any time of the year with Chocolate Covered Strawberry. Sweet, creamy and just a touch decadent, this flavor features real strawberry pieces folded into creamy vanilla custard, before being completed with beloved novelty chocolate. 

The contrast between the tart berries and velvety custard excites your taste buds with every bite. Romantic, nostalgic and downright delicious, it’s one of those Culver’s custard flavors that turns any day into something special.

13. Caramel Turtle

One of the most popular Culver’s custard flavors, Caramel Turtle is what happens when a candy-shop classic gets the frozen dessert treatment. Caramel-flavored frozen custard lays the base for toasted pecans and scrumptious chocolate. The mix is a dream for those who appreciate a variety of textures — smooth and creamy with pockets of gooey caramel and that satisfying pecan crunch that keeps each bite interesting.

This Culver’s custard flavor will appeal to anyone who loves their dessert with a little bite and a whole lot of nostalgic charm. Basically, it’s turtle candy reimagined as a frozen masterpiece.

14. Andes Mint Avalanche

Mint lovers are in good hands with Andes Mint Avalanche, earning a well-deserved spot on this list of top Culver’s custard flavors. You can look forward to cool mint custard swirled with crushed Andes Chocolate Mints and ribbons of delicious (non-minty) chocolate. 

If mint isn’t your thing, this one might overwhelm, as it’s definitely not subtle. But if you’re chasing cool, refreshing indulgence, each spoonful of this Culver’s custard flavor is reminiscent of your favorite after-dinner mint turned into a frozen treat that doesn’t hold back.

15. Oreo Cookie Overload

Oreo Cookie Overload lives up to its name, with rich, velvety chocolate custard piled high with crumbled Oreo cookies and a generous drizzle of chocolate syrup. Every bite is a texture party, blending crunchy, gooey and chocolatey goodness — exactly what you'd expect from a flavor that proudly promises an overload.

This is a true crowd-pleaser among Culver’s custard flavors, especially if you’re a cookies and cream fan who doesn’t believe in holding back. It’s decadent and a little heavy on the sweet side, but a treat from time to time never hurt anyone. 

16. Snickers Swirl

As if Culver’s custard flavors couldn’t get any better, Snickers Swirl takes things up a notch with serious candy bar energy. Creamy chocolate and vanilla custard form the base with chewy, satisfying chunks of Snickers woven into every bite.

If you’re all about satisfying textures and salty-sweet bliss, this Culver's custard flavor will make you feel like you’re in dessert heaven. As you may have guessed, it's a go-to when you want your sweet tooth gloriously spoiled.

17. Dark Chocolate PB Crunch

Dark Chocolate PB Crunch stands out for effortlessly reaching that perfect “can’t-stop-eating-it” level of deliciousness. Each spoonful of this Culver's custard flavor features decadent dark chocolate custard layered with ribbons of creamy peanut butter and chewy Butterfinger pieces. Even if you’re a die-hard milk chocolate fan, the rich, bold flavor of the dark chocolate paired with that sweet-salty peanut butter is pure dessert magic.

No matter what you’re craving, there’s a Culver’s custard flavor ready to steal your heart (and probably your last spoonful). It doesn’t matter if you stick to classics or love chasing down those flavor-of-the-day specials, Culver’s knows how to keep things deliciously exciting. So, next time you’re near a Culver’s, treat yourself, because life’s a little sweeter with a cup (or cone) of its legendary frozen custard in hand.

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.