12 Potbelly Secret Menu Items Worth Trying in 2024

Published on June 20, 2024 | 0 Comments
Potbelly secret menu

The first sandwich enthusiast to discover the Potbelly secret menu definitely struck gold, but we’re here to give you that treasure for free. The secret menu is packed with delicious surprises that take your favorite sandwiches to new heights. Whether you're a regular customer or a newcomer eager to give this fast food gem a try, the items on the Potbelly secret menu are guaranteed to delight your taste buds.

Get ready to discover new flavors and satisfy your cravings in ways you never imagined. Whether you're craving a secret spin on a classic sub or a dessert treat with a twist, the Potbelly secret menu has something for everyone. Dive in and get ready to transform your next Potbelly visit into an unforgettable culinary adventure.

 Jump to Section

Book a Gourmet Cooking Class Now
Kick-start your culinary confidence with help from a world-class chef. See what's cooking in your city today.
Book Now

Does Potbelly Have a Secret Menu?

The answer is a resounding yes. But here's the fun part — the items on the Potbelly secret menu are not officially listed anywhere. Instead, they’re a bit of a hidden treasure crafted by passionate customers and creative employees. Think of it like insider knowledge shared among food enthusiasts. So, how does it work? Well, you won't find these items on the big board. Instead, you'll need to know what to ask for. 

The Potbelly secret menu choices are like hidden gems just waiting to be discovered. Chat with your server, share the secret name or ingredients and voilà! You're in for a tasty surprise off the regular menu's beaten path.

Person's hand holding two sandwich halves from Potbelly
via Potbelly

Potbelly Sandwich Secret Menu


Ever heard of TTLT? It's Potbelly's secret code for a mouthwatering creation — toasted turkey lettuce tomato. Picture sinking your teeth into warm, toasty bread hugging tender turkey, crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes — it's sandwich nirvana. But here's the catch: you won't find TTLT anywhere but on the Potbelly secret menu. To get your hands on this hidden delight, just whisper "TTLT" when at Potbelly and the sandwich wizards will whip it up for you. Starting with the classic turkey sandwich, they'll add fresh lettuce and tomato before toasting it to perfection. 

Person's hand holding a sandwich with meat, lettuce and tomato on from Potbelly
via Potbelly

2. Lucky 7

Ready to discover the Lucky 7 at Potbelly? It's like a secret sandwich society and you're invited. Picture this: Potbelly's classic Wreck sandwich, but jazzed up with not one, not two, but seven different types of meats and cheeses. It's a flavor explosion that'll make your taste buds do a happy dance. Now, how do you get your hands on this secret delight? Easy — just let the folks behind the counter know you're in on the secret and they'll whip up this culinary masterpiece for you. Trust us, once you've tried this number from the Potbelly secret menu, you'll wonder how you ever settled for plain old sandwiches.

Lucky 7 sandwich, with a variety of meats and cheeses, from the Potbelly secret menu
via Potbelly

3. Fireball

Experience the sizzle of the Fireball at Potbelly, where spiciness and succulence meet in the middle. Enjoy juicy meatballs, draped in tangy marinara sauce and embraced by melted pepper jack cheese, all topped with jalapeños and hot giardiniera for an extra kick. It's a flavor adventure waiting for you. How to indulge? Simply ask for the Fireball — a Potbelly secret menu sensation that'll set your taste buds ablaze. Don't miss out on this spicy twist. 

Meatball sandwich with cheese and peppers as part of the concept of the Potbelly secret menu
via Potbelly

Book an Online Cooking Class Today
Five-star chefs. Step-by-step coaching. Flexible menus. Come see what's cooking in a live online cooking class.
Book Now

4. The Barnyard

Craving something seriously meaty? Try The Barnyard, a Potbelly secret menu masterpiece. This mouthwatering sandwich is stacked high with turkey, roast beef, ham and salami, creating the ultimate feast for meat lovers. Just ask for a mix of these delicious meats and customize it with your favorite toppings, cheeses and sauces. The Barnyard from the Potbelly secret menu is your ticket to a hearty, flavor-packed meal that's guaranteed to satisfy your cravings. 

Sandwich with meats, cheese and a variety of other toppings from Potbelly
via Potbelly

5. The Elvis

The Elvis is a Potbelly secret menu gem you have to try. This unique sandwich combines creamy peanut butter, sliced bananas and crispy bacon for a sweet and savory treat that's out of this world. To order, start with a PB&J and ask for bananas and bacon to be added. Inspired by the King of Rock and Roll’s favorite flavors, this fun twist on a classic will make your taste buds sing. 

Peanut butter, banana and bacon on two slices of bread
via Canva

6. Sicilian

Craving something bold and savory? Discover the Sicilian, another meaty hidden gem on the Potbelly secret menu. This mouthwatering creation is packed with salami, pepperoni, capicola, provolone cheese and a zesty mix of hot peppers. Ready to order? Simply ask for an Italian sandwich and customize it with extra pepperoni and capicola. Toast it with provolone and top it off with hot peppers for an unforgettable kick. Elevate your sandwich game and experience the deliciousness of the Sicilian right now.

Person's hand picking up half of a meaty and cheesy sandwich from Potbelly
via Potbelly

7. The Clubby

After reading about The Clubby, you'll want to get your hands on one as soon as humanly possible. It's a Potbelly secret menu gem that's all about layers of turkey, ham and roast beef, stacked with provolone cheese, lettuce and tomato, then drizzled with honey mustard for that perfect sweet and savory blend. How do you get your hands on this deliciousness? Just tell your server you're craving The Clubby. Or, if you prefer, order a standard club sandwich and jazz it up with roast beef and honey mustard. It's one of the Potbelly secret menu's most popular flavor-packed adventures.

The Clubby sandwich from the Potbelly secret menu
via Potbelly

8. Black and Bleu

Introducing one of Potbelly's best-kept secrets: the Black and Bleu. Tantalize your taste buds with this flavor-packed sandwich sensation. Sink your teeth into succulent roast beef, paired perfectly with crumbled blue cheese, tangy hot peppers and a kick of zesty hot sauce, all sandwiched between Potbelly's freshly baked bread. How to treat yourself to one of these? Just waltz into your nearest Potbelly joint and ask for the Black and Bleu to unlock this hidden Potbelly secret menu gem. Feeling even more adventurous? Amp up the flavor with add-ons like crispy bacon or creamy avocado. 

Close-up of the inside of a sandwich cut in half from Potbelly
via Potbelly

Gourmet Cooking Classes Near You
Take your culinary skills to new levels with guidance from five-star chefs.
Book Now

Other Potbelly Secret Menu Items

9. A Wreck Salad

Imagine all the mouthwatering flavors of the iconic Wreck sandwich, now served in a crisp, refreshing salad bowl. Dive into juicy roast beef, tender turkey, savory ham, melted Swiss cheese and a burst of fresh veggies, all kissed with zesty Italian dressing. How do you get your hands on this culinary masterpiece from the Potbelly secret menu? Just ask for the Wreck salad, loaded with all your favorite Wreck ingredients, and set yourself on a flavor adventure like no other.

Two salads with a variety of different ingredients, from Potbelly
via Potbelly

10. Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Shake

Looking for a deliciously indulgent treat? You’ve got to try the chocolate peanut butter banana shake from the Potbelly secret menu. This dreamy shake combines the rich taste of chocolate, the creamy goodness of peanut butter and the fresh sweetness of banana. It’s like dessert in a cup! To order, simply ask for a chocolate shake and request the addition of peanut butter and banana. Remember, it’s not on the regular menu, so be sure to mention the special ingredients to get the Potbelly secret menu edition.

Hands of two people each holding a shake from Potbelly
via Potbelly

11. Cookie Collision

Cookie Collision is one of the best-kept secrets on the Potbelly secret menu — a delicious treat that’s perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth. Imagine biting into creamy vanilla ice cream nestled between two warm, gooey chocolate chip cookies. To get this amazing dessert, simply ask for two freshly baked cookies and a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Your server will craft this delightful combo just for you. It’s like a mini ice cream sandwich that’s pure bliss with every bite.

Person's hands breaking apart a chocolate chip cookie
via Potbelly

12. Ice Cream Sandwich

Craving a different sweet treat with a twist to the ones above? Say hello to another Potbelly secret menu treasure in the form of the ice cream sandwich. With two scrumptious cookies hugging a scoop of creamy ice cream in between, it's a match made in dessert heaven. To try this delectable delight, just ask your friendly Potbelly server for an ice cream sandwich. Then, get creative by picking your favorite cookie flavors from the regular menu and watch as they transform into a mouthwatering masterpiece right before your eyes.

Ice cream sandwich with chocolate chip cookies and vanilla ice cream
via Canva

As you wrap up your meal at Potbelly, there's a hidden world waiting to be uncovered — the Potbelly secret menu. You'll be back sooner than expected after discovering this treasure trove of culinary delights. From the savory TTLT to the indulgent chocolate peanut butter banana shake, each item is a delightful surprise that takes your taste buds on a journey. So, the next time you're at Potbelly, don't just stick to the regular menu. Be daring and give the secret offerings a try.

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.