29 Best Italian Restaurants in Naperville, IL for 2024
Are you ready to discover the best Italian restaurants in Naperville? The city's vibrant Italian dining scene offers a diverse range of options to suit every taste. From classic trattorias to modern pizzerias, there's something for everyone to enjoy.
Whether you're a seasoned Italian food lover or simply curious about exploring the cuisine, Naperville's Italian restaurants have plenty to offer. Join us as we explore 29 of the best Italian restaurants in Naperville, each one showcasing the creativity and deliciousness of Italian cuisine. Get ready to discover new favorites and embark on a culinary journey that will transport you to the heart of Italy.
Jump to Section
The 29 Best Naperville Italian Restaurants
1. Davanti Enoteca
Named after its wine shop origins, Davanti Enoteca is a charming Italian eatery nestled in Naperville. It's renowned among Italian restaurants in Naperville for its extensive wine collection and masterful pasta dishes.
The Vibe
Davanti Enoteca has a mix of rustic and modern elements, creating a cozy, yet sophisticated atmosphere. Soft lighting provides the perfect setting for a leisurely meal.
What to Order
This Italian restaurant in Naperville is famous for its truffle egg toast, mouth-watering ricotta honeycomb or the decadent short rib lasagna.
Davanti Enoteca | 47 E. Chicago Ave., Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
2. VAI's Italian Inspired Restaurant Kitchen + Bar
Known for its modern Italian cuisine, VAI's Italian Inspired Restaurant Kitchen + Bar stands out among Italian restaurants in Naperville. This restaurant blends traditional flavors with innovative twists to popular dishes such as wood-fired pizza and Italian sharing plates.
The Vibe
This restaurant in Naperville offers a chic yet relaxed atmosphere with contemporary décor and warm lighting. It's an ideal spot for a lively dinner or a laid-back evening out.
What to Order
The seafood linguine and truffle mushroom risotto are popular choices that make it one of the unmissable Italian restaurants in Naperville to visit.
VAI's Italian Inspired Restaurant Kitchen + Bar | 916 Illinois Route 59, Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
3. GIA MIA
Nestled in the heart of downtown, GIA MIA is one of the best Italian restaurants Naperville has to offer, known for its traditional Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizzas. It combines traditional recipes with modern twists.
The Vibe
GIA MIA's industrial-chic interior and warm lighting make it perfect for both casual and upscale dining experiences.
What to Order
Try the prosciutto and arugula pizza, arguably one of the best pies on Naperville's Italian restaurant scene.
GIA MIA | 110 S. Washington St., Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
4. Avanzare Italian Restaurant
A favorite among Italian restaurants in Naperville, Avanzare has charmed locals with its authentic Italian cuisine and warm hospitality since its opening. The restaurant offers a cozy setting that feels like a slice of Italy in the heart of Naperville.
The Vibe
The ambiance at Avanzare is intimate and inviting, with white linen tablecloths and dark wood décor that create a relaxed, yet elegant dining experience. It's perfect for a romantic evening.
What to Order
At this standout among Italian restaurants in Naperville, try the house-made gnocchi, celebrated for its light and fluffy texture or the savory osso buco — succulent braised veal shanks topped with a gremolata — a dish that has become a local favorite.
Avanzare Italian Restaurant | 667 W. Roosevelt Road, #4223, Lombard, IL 60148 | $$
5. Giordano’s
One of the standout Italian restaurants in Naperville is Giordano's, famous for its deep-dish pizza that traces its roots back to 1974 in Chicago. This family-owned establishment brings authentic Italian-American flavors to Naperville, attracting both locals and visitors.
The Vibe
Giordano's blends classic Italian décor with a modern twist. It’s perfect for both casual family dinners and special occasions, offering a warm, welcoming space.
What to Order
At Giordano's, you can’t miss the signature stuffed deep-dish pizza and savory lasagna, a must-try in this Italian restaurant in Naperville.
Giordano’s | 119 S. Main St., Naperville, IL 60540 | $$-$$$
6. Made in Italy Trattoria
A charming spot in Naperville, Made in Italy Trattoria has been delighting guests with authentic Neapolitan fare since it opened. The owner, a passionate chef from Naples, brings traditional recipes and flavors to one of the most genuine Italian restaurants in Naperville.
The Vibe
With its warm and rustic décor, this Italian restaurant offers a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Ideal for a casual meal or a relaxed dinner with friends.
What to Order
Try the rich Bolognese or the creamy fettuccine Alfredo. These amazing dishes make it a favorite among Italian restaurants in Naperville, giving you a slice of Naples life without the need to travel.
Made in Italy Trattoria | 476 Forest Ave., Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 | $$
7. Angeli's
A local favorite among Italian restaurants in Naperville, this cozy spot has been serving authentic Italian fare since 1996. Owned by a dedicated family, Angeli's is known for its fresh ingredients and traditional recipes that bring a genuine taste of Italy to the community.
The Vibe
Angeli's exudes a warm, inviting ambiance with rustic décor and dim lighting. It's perfect for a laid-back, casual dining experience where guests can feel right at home.
What to Order
At Angeli's, the chicken vesuvio is a must-try, showcasing a classic that many Italian restaurants in Naperville feel must be mastered. Also, consider the handmade gnocchi and the rich and creamy tiramisu to finish.
Angeli's | 1478 E. Chicago Ave., Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
8. Maggiano's Little Italy
Located in the heart of Naperville, Maggiano's Little Italy offers an authentic Italian dining experience with a modern flare. As one of the most popular Italian restaurants in Naperville, it is known for its generous portions and family-style dining, perfect for gatherings.
The Vibe
Maggiano's Little Italy in Naperville exudes a warm, classic Italian vibe with dark wood décor and elegant mirrors, perfect for gatherings and celebrations.
What to Order
When dining at one of the best Italian restaurants in Naperville, try the famous Rigatoni "D" or the lobster carbonara for a rich, flavorful treat.
Maggiano's Little Italy | 1847 Freedom Drive, Naperville, IL 60563 | $$
9. Che Figata
Located in the vibrant center of Naperville, Che Figata presents a delightful fusion of traditional and modern Italian cuisine. This is a gem among Italian restaurants in Naperville and is celebrated for its fresh, locally sourced ingredients and inviting atmosphere.
The Vibe
Che Figata exudes a contemporary atmosphere with neutral tones and modern lighting, perfect for a casual meal or a special night out.
What to Order
The wood-fired pizzas and house-made pasta at this Italian restaurant in Naperville are highly recommended by locals.
Che Figata | 2155 City Gate Lane, Naperville, IL 60563 | $$
10. Uncle Pete's Pizza
With its charming roots tracing back to a beloved family recipe, this spot has become a staple among Italian restaurants in Naperville. Uncle Pete's Pizza is known for its warm, welcoming atmosphere, family values and generous portions.
The Vibe
Relaxed and family-friendly, with cozy seating and a casual ambiance. Perfect for a laid-back meal with loved ones or a casual catch-up.
What to Order
The pizza here is the star, especially the classic pepperoni and the meat-free veggie supreme. Uncle Pete's Pizza offers a true taste of comfort among Italian restaurants in Naperville.
Uncle Pete's Pizza | 815 N. Washington St., Naperville, IL 60563 | $$
11. Fontinas Italian Kitchen
Known for its warm ambiance, Fontinas Italian Kitchen was founded by a passionate Italian chef with a vision to bring authentic flavors to Italian restaurants in Naperville.
The Vibe
The atmosphere is inviting and laid-back, with rustic décor and dim lighting creating a homey feel. Perfect for both a casual meal and a special night out, Fontinas embodies a relaxed vibe.
What to Order
At this top choice among the Italian restaurants in Naperville, the signature lasagna and hand-tossed pizzas are standout favorites.
Fontinas Italian Kitchen | 1767 W. Ogden Ave., Ste. 131, Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
12. Billy Bricks
In the heart of Naperville, Billy Bricks brings a touch of Italy with its authentic wood-fired pizzas. Owned by a passionate pizza maker, its name pays homage to the traditional brick-oven method. Lovers of Italian restaurants in Naperville flock to this spot for a slice of history.
The Vibe
The ambiance is casual and welcoming, with a mix of rustic and modern décor. The open kitchen adds a touch of energy and excitement to the space, making it perfect for watching expert chefs hard at work.
What to Order
Known for its delectable wood-fired pizzas, the Margherita and the prosciutto arugula are standout choices. The fresh ingredients and savory flavors make these dishes a must-try at this well-loved Italian restaurant in Naperville.
Billy Bricks | 1763 Freedom Drive, Naperville, IL 60563 | $$
13. Fiamme
Situated in the bustling downtown area, Fiamme is a notable choice among Italian restaurants in Naperville. Renowned for its wood-fired pizzas and inviting atmosphere, this family-owned spot brings the essence of Naples to Illinois.
The Vibe
Fiamme offers a cozy, intimate setting with warm lighting and rustic décor, making it perfect for a romantic night out or a casual dinner with friends.
What to Order
Don’t miss the classic Margherita pizza, made with fresh mozzarella and the best San Marzano tomatoes. The house-made gnocchi and tiramisu are also must-tries for a true Italian experience.
Fiamme | 19 N. Washington St, Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
14. Traverso's
A beloved Italian restaurant in Naperville, Traverso's has been serving up authentic Italian cuisine for years. This restaurant is a local favorite for those seeking a taste of Italy in Illinois.
The Vibe
Traverso's has a classic Italian trattoria vibe, with warm lighting. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, with plenty of round tables, making it a great spot for both intimate dinners and gatherings with friends.
What to Order
Some of Traverso's must-try dishes include its homemade pasta, classic Italian entrées like chicken Parmesan and veal marsala. Don’t forget to order one of the mouthwatering desserts, such as Mama T's light and fluffy version which has been voted number 1 in Chicagoland by the renowned Chicago Magazine.
Traverso's | 2523 Plainfield-Naperville Road, Naperville, IL 60564 | $$-$$$
15. Buca di Beppo
A staple among Italian restaurants in Naperville, Buca di Beppo offers a unique dining experience with its vibrant atmosphere and generous portions. This popular eatery has been delighting guests for years with its classic Italian dishes and warm hospitality.
The Vibe
The vibe at Buca di Beppo is lively and festive. The décor features vintage Italian photographs and memorabilia, creating a nostalgic taste of a bygone era.
What to Order
At Buca di Beppo, the chicken parmigiana and spaghetti marinara are crowd favorites. The tiramisu is a must-try for dessert, an essential dish for any Italian restaurant in Naperville.
Buca di Beppo | 90 Yorktown Road, Lombard, IL 60148 | $$
16. Rosemary and Jeans Public House
Tucked in the heart of the city, Rosemary and Jeans Public House is one of the best Italian restaurants in downtown Naperville. Guests are treated to a blend of authentic Italian flavors and a cozy, welcoming atmosphere.
The Vibe
The ambiance is warm and inviting, with rustic wooden accents and gentle lighting, creating a casual yet elegant setting perfect for both date nights and family gatherings.
What to Order
Try the wood-fired margherita pizza, creamy risotto or fresh, handmade pasta dishes, each bursting with authentic flavors — you can taste the love and care that’s gone into each plate of food here.
Rosemary and Jeans Public House | 116 S. Main St., Lombard, IL 60148 | $$-$$$
17. La Sorella di Francesca
Located in the heart of Naperville, La Sorella di Francesca offers a true taste of Italy with its Tuscan-inspired menu. As one of the top Italian restaurants in Downtown Naperville, it has been delighting guests for over 20 years with its warm hospitality and authentic dishes.
The Vibe
The ambiance here is elegant yet inviting, with a blend of rustic wooden beams and gentle lighting. It’s perfect for both a romantic dinner and a lively group gathering.
What to Order
Don’t miss signature dishes like the rigatoni alla Norcina or the classic veal Milanese, both favorites among fans of Italian restaurants in Naperville.
La Sorella di Francesca | 18 W. Jefferson Ave., Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
18. Za Za's
Known for its authentic Italian flavors, Za Za's has been a staple among Italian restaurants in Naperville since it opened its doors in the heart of Downtown. This delightful eatery blends traditional recipes with old-fashioned charm.
The Vibe
Za Za's offers a cozy, intimate setting with warm lighting, white linen tablecloths and traditional décor, creating an inviting atmosphere ideal for both casual dining and special occasions.
What to Order
Customers rave about the classic osso buco and the house-made gnocchi, which melts in your mouth. Don't miss the mussels if you’re a seafood lover!
Za Za's | 441 E. Ogden Ave., Clarendon Hills, IL 60514 | $$-$$$
19. Portillo's & Barnelli's
Known for its unique blend of Italian and American cuisine, Portillo's & Barnelli's stands out among Italian restaurants in Naperville for its rich history and loyal following. The restaurant features a menu that showcases traditional Italian dishes as well as American favorites.
The Vibe
Portillo's & Barnelli's vibe is vibrant and bustling, with colorful, retro décor and a lively crowd. It’s a casual spot where diners can enjoy a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere.
What to Order
Popular dishes at this Italian restaurant in Naperville include the hearty Italian beef sandwich and the comforting baked mostaccioli: pasta tossed in a rich Italian meat sauce and topped with ricotta, Parmesan and mozzarella.
Portillo's & Barnelli's | 1992 W. Jefferson Ave., Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
20. Buona
A beloved spot among Italian restaurants in Naperville, Buona is known for its rich history of serving up delicious Italian beef dishes. Founded by a local family, this eatery blends traditional recipes with modern American fare, such as burgers.
The Vibe
A relaxed and casual vibe, featuring a mix of modern and rustic décor. The spacious dining area and comfortable seating create a welcoming atmosphere perfect for any occasion.
What to Order
When it comes to Italian restaurants in Naperville, this eatery hits the spot for meat lovers: try the Buona beef sandwich — slow-roasted Italian spiced beef layered on fresh Italian bread.
Buona | 1588 Naperville Wheaton Road, Naperville, IL 60563 | $$
21. Olive Garden
Another popular Italian restaurant in Naperville, Olive Garden delivers a true taste of Italy. Known for its warm hospitality and inviting atmosphere, the restaurant has been serving up classic Italian dishes for years.
The Vibe
A cozy, family-friendly spot with décor inspired by the Italian countryside, featuring warm colors and rustic accents. It's perfect for a casual night out or a laid-back lunch.
What to Order
A must-try among Italian restaurants in Naperville, the fettuccine Alfredo and chicken parmigiana are fan favorites.
Olive Garden | 620 S. Route 59, Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
22. Clara’s
In a charming spot, Clara’s stands out among Italian restaurants in Naperville for its authentic family recipes. Founded by a passionate chef whose family has been serving Italian cuisine for generations, Clara’s offers a taste of tradition.
The Vibe
Warm and inviting, with exposed brick walls and dark wood accents creating a cozy, intimate setting. It’s perfect for both casual dining and special occasions.
What to Order
The homemade lasagna and creamy risotto are wonderful dishes, bringing hearty flavors and fresh ingredients to the table.
Clara’s | 6550 IL-53, Woodridge, IL 60517 | $$
23. Taurasi
A cherished spot among Italian restaurants in Naperville, this restaurant specializes in Southern Italian cuisine. Established by a passionate chef with roots in Naples, Taurasi brings a touch of Italy to the heart of Naperville.
The Vibe
The ambiance here is inviting and sophisticated, with warm lighting and elegant décor creating a cozy yet upscale atmosphere. Perfect for both casual and special occasions.
What to Order
The hand-made ravioli is not to be missed, and seafood lovers will love the version filled with crab and lobster. You could also try the scallops for a treat. When the time comes for something sweet, the lemon cake is tough to beat.
Taurasi | 14 N. Cass Ave., Westmont, IL 60559 | $$$
24. Calogero's
A charming gem among Italian restaurants in Naperville, Calogero’s has been serving delectable Italian fare since 2005. Its warm, inviting atmosphere and family-owned legacy make it a beloved local favorite for hearty Italian dishes.
The Vibe
Cozy and welcoming, the colorful mural, exposed brick walls and open kitchen create an exciting ambiance. It’s perfect for casual family dinners and special occasions.
What to Order
Try the simple but delicious aglio e olio — garlic, chile and parsley mixed with Sicilian olive oil and sea salt over pasta and topped with Parmesan. The homemade cannoli is perfect for a sweet finish that reflects the best of this Italian restaurant in Naperville.
Calogero's | 931 W. 75th St., Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
25. Sogno
Another favorite on the scene of Italian restaurants in Naperville, this family-owned spot called Sogno is renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine and welcoming atmosphere. Known for its traditional recipes and warm hospitality, it has been a local hotspot for years.
The Vibe
Sogno provides an intimate dining experience, featuring rustic décor. Exposed wood beams and the abundance of natural light are perfect for a romantic dinner or a quiet family meal.
What to Order
Try out the classic Margherita pizza, homemade gnocchi with truffle cream or delicate spaghetti with clams. Each dish at this restaurant highlights the memorable flavors that make Italian restaurants in Naperville so special.
Sogno | 100 N. Hale St., Wheaton, IL 60187 | $$-$$$
26. Little Pops NY Pizzeria
A top choice among Italian restaurants in Naperville, Little Pops NY Pizzeria has been serving authentic New York-style pizza since 2005. The restaurant was founded by a former New York chef, bringing a taste of the Big Apple’s rich Italian heritage to Naperville.
The Vibe
Casual and lively, with a retro diner feel and bright, cheery décor. It’s a great spot for a relaxed meal, whether you’re dressing up or keeping it casual.
What to Order
At Little Pops NY Pizzeria, the famous thin-crust pizza is a must-try, especially the pepperoni and sausage pies.
Little Pops NY Pizzeria | 1819 Wehrli Road, Naperville, IL 60565 | $$
27. Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano
With a rich history of serving traditional Italian fare, Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano has been an established eatery among Italian restaurants in Naperville for years. Its dedication to authentic flavors and warm hospitality sets it apart.
The Vibe
With a welcoming and cozy atmosphere, the elegant décor and ambient lighting create a relaxed dining experience, perfect for both casual outings and special occasions.
What to Order
Don’t miss out on Biaggi's delicate butternut squash ravioli or the savory chicken marsala (cooked in marsala wine), both among the most celebrated dishes at this Italian restaurant in Naperville.
Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano | 2752 Showplace Drive, Naperville, IL 60564 | $$
28. Lou Malnati's Pizzeria
A cornerstone of Naperville's Italian restaurant scene, Lou Malnati's Pizzeria offers deep-dish pizza that’s beloved across the city. Founded in 1971, it’s renowned for its buttery pizza crusts and rich, flavorful ingredients, making it a local favorite.
The Vibe
The restaurant has a casual atmosphere, with vintage signage and a mix of pendant lighting and ceiling fans. The décor is classic, perfect for a laid-back dining experience.
What to Order
When dining at Italian restaurants in Naperville like Lou Malnati's, the deep-dish pizza and the Malnati Chicago Classic are must-tries.
Lou Malnati's Pizzeria | 131 West Jefferson Ave., Naperville, IL 60540 | $$
29. Harry Caray's Italian Steakhouse
Known for its rich history and connection to the legendary sportscaster Harry Caray, this dining spot offers a unique blend of Italian cuisine and steakhouse favorites. This one’s a gem among Italian restaurants in Downtown Naperville.
The Vibe
The atmosphere here is a mix of vintage sports nostalgia and classic elegance. With low lighting and wood accents, if you're looking for warm and cozy restaurants that are perfect for a low-key dining experience, you're in the right place.
What to Order
Fans of Italian restaurants in Naperville love the chicken vesuvio and the adventurous rigatoni alla vodka. And, of course, the steaks are juicy and cooked to perfection — however you like yours done.
Harry Caray's Italian Steakhouse | 70 Yorktown Shopping Center, Lombard, IL 60148 | $$
Try Cooking Naperville Foods
Are you tired of ordering takeout from Naperville's Italian restaurants? Why not learn to make those delicious dishes for yourself? If this sounds like your idea of culinary heaven, cooking classes in Naperville could be your magical gateway to uncovering the secrets of Naperville's dining scene.
Cooking classes provide hands-on experience with experienced chefs from Italian restaurants in Naperville, teaching you essential skills. You’ll master techniques like pasta making and pizza dough preparation while discovering the rich flavors and textures of Italian cuisine.
Join 200,000+ Culinary Enthusiasts
Whether you're in the mood for a hearty pasta dish, a gourmet pizza or a quick, satisfying snack, Italian restaurants in Naperville have something for everyone. These 29 spots showcase the creativity and passion that define Naperville's Italian culinary landscape. So, next time you're in town, make sure you explore these fantastic restaurants.
For even more ways to explore Naperville and beyond, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.