Can You Freeze Fudge?
If you’ve whipped up a big batch of fudge or have a large quantity of store-bought fudge on hand, you may question: “Can you freeze fudge?” Conveniently, you can freeze fudge to enjoy at a later date, including homemade fudge and fudge with toppings.
To help you discover exactly how to freeze this sweet treat, this in-depth guide covers which types of fudge you can freeze. It also offers top tips on how can you freeze homemade fudge and storebought fudge with best results.
Jump to Section
Can Fudge Be Frozen?
The resounding answer to the question: “Can I freeze fudge?” is yes, you definitely can. You can freeze fudge safely for up to two to three months without any worries. Fudge is an easy treat to freeze due to its high sugar and fat content and low water content. The process of freezing halts the growth of microbes and bacteria and considerably extends the shelf life of these candies.
The quality of the ingredients used to make the fudge will also determine how much its taste and texture alter after freezing. For example, fudge made with full-fat ingredients freezes better than batches made with low-fat cream, milk or condensed milk. This is due to the latter's high water content, which may lead to soggy, extra-moist fudge after thawing.
If you plan to freeze store-bought fudge, it pays to choose the higher-end varieties to retain a creamy and rich taste and consistency. Even fudges with toppings or mix-ins, such as the nuts or dried fruit added to festive Christmas fudge or marshmallows stirred into rocky road fudge, can be frozen and defrosted with good results.
Can You Freeze Homemade Fudge?
If you find yourself with too much homemade fudge (always a welcome problem) and wonder: “Can you freeze fudge after you make it?”, let us assure you that you can freeze fudge instead of eating it all up at once or letting it go bad. When you opt to freeze fudge made at home, you preserve its smooth texture and rich taste.
If you plan to freeze fudge that you have made, always stick to the best quality milk, butter, chocolate and other ingredients when making it. This is because higher-quality, high-fat ingredients freeze and thaw best.
Can You Freeze Fudge With Condensed Milk?
As condensed milk is the primary ingredient in many fudge recipes, you may wonder: “Can you freeze fudge if it’s made with condensed milk?” Conveniently, you can freeze a condensed milk-based fudge. The high fat content in this ingredient makes it a great candidate for freezing and you’ll see minimal changes to the texture of the fudge once frozen.
Like with freezing any kind of fudge, ensure you wrap and store condensed milk fudge well. Ideally, wrap it in cling film and then store it in a sealed freezer-safe box or bag before freezing to avoid freezer burn.
Can You Freeze Peanut Butter Fudge?
Another common type of fudge to consider freezing is peanut butter fudge. As with all other varieties, fudge mixed with peanut butter will freeze safely for up to three months. Additionally, the high-fat content and low water content in peanut butter will contribute to maintaining the original texture when frozen and thawed.
Should You Freeze Fudge?
Now we’ve answered the question: “Can you freeze fudge?”, you may want to know if you should or if it’s optimal to avoid freezing. Freezing fudge is an excellent way to extend its lifespan past what could be achieved when stored at room temperature or in the refrigerator.
As a rule, you should leave fudge at room temperature only briefly. Even when stored in the fridge, fudge can start to go bad within a month. Assuming you take care to pack fudge correctly for freezing (wrapped and stored in a well-sealed airtight container), storing it in the freezer is highly recommended if you have too much to eat when fresh.
How Do You Freeze Fudge?
By now, you know the answer to: “Can you freeze fudge?” is a positive one, but how do you freeze fudge for best results? To start, cutting the fudge into pieces, if not already portioned, is a good idea. While you can freeze a slab of fudge if needed, portioning it makes defrosting easier. If you are planning to thaw and use the whole block of fudge in one go, then freezing it in one piece should be fine.
Once you've decided whether to portion it or not, follow these steps to freeze fudge with best results:
- Wrap the fudge: Whether you portion it or keep the block as one, the first step is wrapping the fudge well in cling film. If possible, wrap it in two layers, ensuring no air can get in. Do a final wrap-around with foil.
- Place in freezer-safe containers: Move the wrapped fudge into Ziploc bags or an airtight, freezer-safe container. You may also want to separate each layer of fudge with parchment if wrapping pieces together. Ensure the bags or containers are fully sealed shut.
- Mark with a date of freezing: Add a date of freezing to the containers that you store the fudge in for freezing. This allows you to stay on top of whether the fudge is still safe to consume or if it has been in the freezer too long.
- Move the fudge to the freezer: Lastly, pop the fudge in the freezer. Refrain from storing anything on top of Ziploc bags of fudge and ensure the fudge is laid flat on an even surface. Avoid placing fudge in the freezer's doors as well. This area is susceptible to the most temperature variations and can cause your fudge to spoil. Instead, store flat at the back of the freezer for optimal results.
When freezing fudge that has just been made, you'll also want to ensure it is fully set before moving to the freezer. Leaving it to set for 24 hours before freezing is recommended.
How To Freeze Fudge With Toppings
If your fudge recipe calls for toppings, such as nuts, marshmallows, candies or coconut chips, it would be best to mix these into the fudge rather than just sprinkling them on top. Different fudge toppings react differently in the freezer. If you plan to freeze store-bought fudge, choose flavors without too many extra toppings or garnishes like chocolate drizzles.
Whether you’re making a mix-in-filled fantasy fudge or just want to add a few nuts or some dried fruit, freezing fudge with toppings can be successful. Stirring the toppings into the fudge instead of sprinkling them on top is a good idea if already planning to freeze the fudge when you make it.
If you really want to keep toppings on the fudge instead of mixing them in, press the toppings firmly into the fudge instead of sprinkling them over it. Toasting nuts before mixing them in is also an excellent hack for retaining their crunch in frozen fudge.
How Long Can You Freeze Fudge?
If all the necessary precautions have been taken and your fudge has been wrapped and stored correctly, you can expect to have delicious fudge on hand for up to three months. Unless the frozen fudge has been thawed incorrectly, its taste and texture should remain the same whether you eat it a week or three months after freezing.
How To Thaw Frozen Fudge
If you plan to eat only a portion of the frozen fudge, simply place the chosen pieces in a plastic bag in the refrigerator to thaw. Depending on how thick the fudge is, the thawing process can take two to four hours. Remove the foil and clingfilm once the fudge pieces are softened, and enjoy.
You can thaw fudge at room temperature if needed by simply placing it on a counter. However, this can result in uneven thawing, with some sections of the fudge becoming overly soft by the time the whole piece has defrosted. No matter how quickly you need the fudge, do not thaw your frozen fudge in a microwave. This will only result in a molten, soggy mess.
Join 200,000+ Culinary Enthusiasts
If you have any doubts about whether you can freeze fudge, this article should have put your worries to rest. The key to freezing fudge successfully comes down to two factors — the quality of the ingredients used to make the fudge and the attention paid when prepping it for the freezer. Once you understand this, nothing stops you from mastering the art of freezing your favorite treat and savoring it at your discretion.
For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.