9 Best Cookie Sheets of 2024
The best cookie sheets to have in your kitchen cupboards are durable, versatile and high-performing. These types of baking sheets can do it all, from roasting vegetables to baking chewy, golden cookies.
Are your cookie sheets underperforming and in need of an upgrade? Below, we cover the nine best cookie sheets on the market, which we hand-selected for quality and versatility. From baking sets to the best sheet pans for baking, hopefully you find the perfect cookie sheet for your kitchen below.
Jump to Section
- Best 3-Piece Baking Sheet Set: Nordic Ware Baker's Delight 3-Pc Set
- Best 2-Piece Baking Sheet Set: Nordic Ware Prism 2-Pc Baker's Bundle
- Best 2/3 Baking Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's 2/3 Baking Sheet Pan
- Best Half Baking Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's Half Sheet Baking Pan
- Best Quarter Baking Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's Quarter Sheet Baking Pan
- Best Jelly Roll Baking Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's Jelly Roll Baking Pan
- Best Non-Stick Cookie Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's Non-Stick Cookie Sheet
- Best Bakeware Set: Anolon Advanced Bakeware 5-Piece Bakeware Set
- Best Stone Cookie Pan: Nordic Ware Deluxe Square Pizza Stone With Rack
1. Best 3-Piece Baking Sheet Set: Nordic Ware Baker's Delight 3-Pc Set
The Nordic Ware Baker's Delight 3-Pc Set is one of the best cookie sheets sets because it is durable and versatile. The three-piece baking sheet set contains a half sheet baking pan, a quarter sheet baking pan and a jelly roll baking pan. Made of pure aluminum for superior heat conductivity, these Nordic Ware baking sheets also have galvanized steel rims to prevent warping and spills. You’ll have a pan for every baking need, from a big batch of cookies to toasting nuts or roasting vegetables.
2. Best 2-Piece Baking Sheet Set: Nordic Ware Prism 2-Pc Baker's Bundle
The Nordic Ware Prism 2-Pc Baker’s Bundle contains a half sheet baking pan and a quarter sheet baking pan. Both pans are some of the best cookie sheets around because they are made from durable non-stick aluminum and designed with a prism grid to provide easy release and increase airflow for uniform browning. It’s an essential set of Nordic Ware baking sheets for home bakers!
3. Best 2/3 Baking Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's 2/3 Baking Sheet Pan
Mrs. Anderson's 2/3 Baking Sheet Pan is one of the best baking sheets on the market. Two-thirds the size of a full sheet pan, this commercial-grade rimmed baking sheet is the largest sheet pan size to fit in a standard home oven. Made of 19-gauge aluminum with a beaded rim, this pan will stand the test of many a batch of cookies. The size of this baking sheet makes it one of the best cookie sheets for baking large batches of cookies, a useful option for large families or events.
4. Best Half Baking Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's Half Sheet Baking Pan
If you’re on the hunt for the perfect half sheet baking pan, Mrs. Anderson's Half Sheet Baking Pan is a smart choice. Made of non-porous, durable aluminum, this half sheet pan will be your go-to pan for cookies, sheet pan dinners, breads and more. It’s also freezer safe, further increasing the versatility this pan provides in your kitchen and making it one of the best cookie sheets in your arsenal.
5. Best Quarter Baking Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's Quarter Sheet Baking Pan
For smaller baking jobs or smaller ovens, a quarter sheet baking pan is nifty to have on hand. We love the Mrs. Anderson's Quarter Sheet Baking Pan for its price (less than $10!) that doesn’t skimp on quality. This is one of the best cookie sheets because it’s rimmed, freezer safe and made of durable aluminum.
6. Best Jelly Roll Baking Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's Jelly Roll Baking Pan
Another hero of small ovens (and of course, jelly roll cakes), a good jelly roll pan is non-stick, has a 1” rim and fits standard jelly roll baking mats. The Mrs. Anderson's Jelly Roll Baking Pan ticks all the boxes, making it one of the best jelly roll pans on the market.
7. Best Non-Stick Cookie Sheet: Mrs. Anderson's Non-Stick Cookie Sheet
The best nonstick cookie sheet without a rim is Mrs. Anderson's Non-Stick Cookie Sheet. This cookie sheet is made of sturdy carbon steel with a non-stick coating, so your cookies slide right off with ease. Professionals rave that the rimless sides promote airflow while baking, so your cookies achieve consistent browning and crisping.
8. Best Bakeware Set: Anolon Advanced Bakeware 5-Piece Bakeware Set
Whether you’re a beginner baker or replacing your well-loved pans, the beautiful bronze Anolon Advanced Bakeware 5-Piece Bakeware Set is a quick way to snag some of the best cookie sheets and pans you need to start baking. This five-piece bakeware set contains two 9” round cake pans, one 9” square cake pan, one cookie sheet and one cooling rack.
9. Best Stone Cookie Pan: Nordic Ware Deluxe Square Pizza Stone With Rack
Did you know you could bake cookies on a pizza stone? Just grease your stone, scoop your dough and bake! We think the best pizza stone for the job is the Nordic Ware Deluxe Square Pizza Stone With Rack, a high-heat pizza stone made from ceramic. It even includes a stainless steel rack for easy serving!
Join 200,000+ Culinary Enthusiasts
Whether you’re a classic half-sheet pan kind of baker or really into the pizza stone (who knew it could bake cookies, too?), hopefully a cookie sheet on this list of the best cookie sheets filled the gap in your bakeware. Make this your excuse to break in your bakeware with your favorite cookie recipe or learn a new one in an online baking class!
For even more ways to elevate your kitchen, check out chef-recommended cookware in the Cozymeal Shop.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.