10 Best Muffin Pans for 2023
Having the best muffin pan for your baking needs will ensure that you turn out successful muffins every time. Maybe you have a favorite size, style or material that requires a specific pan. Or maybe you’re preparing for some online baking classes and you’re looking for a few pans to add to your arsenal for muffin season.
Whatever the scenario, we’re here to help you find the best muffin pan to give you the sweetest baking experience possible.
How do you know which would be the best starter muffin pans to buy? How do you choose the best muffin pan versus the best cupcake pan versus the best mini-cakes pan? With so many options available, a bit of guidance may be in order. The list below will help get you started.
Jump to Section
- Best Silicone: Mrs. Anderson's Baking Silicone Muffin Pan
- Best for Shortcake: Nordic Ware Shortcake Baskets Pan
- Best for Muffin Tops: Mrs. Anderson's Silicone 6-Cup Muffin Top Pan
- Best Oversized: Nordic Ware Naturals Jumbo Coffee Shop Muffin Pan
- Best Non-Stick: Mrs. Anderson's Non-Stick 6-Cup Popover Pan
- Best for Cakelets: Nordic Ware Dinosaur Cakelet Pan
- Best Bite-Sized: Nordic Ware Naturals 24-Cup Petite Muffin Pan
- Best for Bundtlettes: Nordic Ware Heritage Bundtlette Pan
- Best Looking: Nordic Ware Bundt Charms Pan
- Best Covered: Anolon Advanced Bakeware Muffin Pan With Lid
1. Best Silicone: Mrs. Anderson's Baking Silicone Muffin Pan
With Mrs. Anderson's Baking Silicone Muffin Pan in your collection, you’ll have a sturdy silicone muffin pan that lets you turn out a dozen precision-baked traditional muffins every time. The soft, flexible surface makes it easy to clean and a breeze to store, and the material will maintain its original shape and non-stick quality for years to come. We love this one for both its flexibility and durability, which makes baking even more fun.
2. Best for Shortcake: Nordic Ware Shortcake Baskets Pan
Give your muffin making a whimsical twist with the ingenious Nordic Ware Shortcake Baskets Pan. The innovative wells create a channel in each cake, perfect for filling with fruit, custard, cream or any other filling you can dream up. It’s the best muffin pan by far for making your own special shortcakes, and we love how many fun ideas it's bound to inspire!
3. Best for Muffin Tops: Mrs. Anderson's Silicone 6-Cup Muffin Top Pan
Leave those needless muffin stumps in the past with the miraculous efficiency of Mrs. Anderson's Silicone 6-Cup Muffin Top Pan. The broad, flat wells allow you to create six muffin tops — the best part of the muffin — without wasting batter on the bases. We love the innovative design that allows for maximum heat circulation and airflow, which gives you superior results in your bakes. They’re the best blending of a cookie, a muffin and a pancake you’ll ever create!
4. Best Oversized: Nordic Ware Naturals Jumbo Coffee Shop Muffin Pan
If your love lies with oversized muffins like the bulk warehouse retailers carry, then the Nordic Ware Naturals Jumbo Coffee Shop Muffin Pan is the best muffin pan purchase for you. The brushed aluminum surface resists warping and rusting, and the generous wells give plenty of baking room for your favorite batters. It's also a superstar of heat conductivity, making for exceptional baking.
5. Best Non-Stick: Mrs. Anderson's Non-Stick 6-Cup Popover Pan
Make sure your muffins turn out with crisp, sharp edges every time with Mrs. Anderson's Non-Stick 6-Cup Popover Pan. The best non-stick muffin pan on the market also features a unique cup-in-wire design, which means quicker cooling. And the deep wells will give you tall bakery-style muffins all year long. Want to take it beyond muffins and popovers? We love that this versatile pan can even be used for cupcakes and mini coffee cakes!
6. Best for Cakelets: Nordic Ware Dinosaur Cakelet Pan
If you’ve never realized before that dinosaur-shaped cakelets even existed, the Nordic Ware Dinosaur Cakelet Pan will open your eyes! This charming claw-shaped cake pan has eight molded channels in the shapes of tyrannosaurs, triceratops, stegosaurus and brontosaurus. If you're looking to get your little ones more involved in the kitchen, this is our top pick for making baking even more fun. The best muffin pan for making delicious dinosaur cakes will take your muffin-baking to prehistoric proportions!
7. Best Bite-Sized: Nordic Ware Naturals 24-Cup Petite Muffin Pan
You’ll turn out bite-sized treats by the dozens with the warp-free and rust-free Nordic Ware Naturals 24-Cup Petite Muffin Pan. With 24 channels to fill with each batch, you can create brownie bites, tiny cupcakes, adorable tassies and more. It comes with the sturdy Nordic Ware construction and surface, making this a clear must-have for your best-of-the-best muffin pan collection.
8. Best for Bundtlettes: Nordic Ware Heritage Bundtlette Pan
Mini-bundts are all the cake rage these days, and with the Nordic Ware Heritage Bundtlette Pan you can skip the line at the bakery and create them in your own kitchen. The contemporary whorl pattern gives a modern feel to six beloved classics per batch, and the molded handles double as hangers for a farmhouse-style wall display.
9. Best Looking: Nordic Ware Bundt Charms Pan
If you’re in the market for something even fancier than mini bundts, the best muffin pan for you is Nordic Ware Bundt Charms Pan. Its 12 copper-colored aluminum wells hold six distinctive designs for turning out elegant tea-sized cakes embossed with scallops, swoops, angles and more, making them lovely enough for your most special occasions. We love the charm and classic appeal this pan offers to bakers of all skill levels.
10. Best Covered: Anolon Advanced Bakeware Muffin Pan With Lid
The best muffin pan for preparing, carrying and storing your amazing muffin creations is the Anolon Advanced Bakeware Muffin Pan With Lid. Not only do you get durable heavy-gauge steel construction for even heating, but you also get a frosted lid to keep your cakes fresh and protected during transport. No more messy foil dragging across those fresh-baked tops!
Muffins can be so much more than just the traditional bakery counter offering these days. With designer shapes, whimsical molds and wide-ranging sizes available, you have every opportunity to take your muffin baking to the gourmet limits and turn out some truly artful treats.
For even more of the best bakeware, check out chef-recommended cookware in the Cozymeal Shop.