14 Best Buffalo Sauce Brands Ranked in 2025

The best Buffalo sauces on today’s market all hail from the culinary genius of one American restaurateur. This popular sauce was originally invented by Teressa Bellissimo to pair with leftover chicken at the Anchor Bar in Buffalo, New York. However, as the National Chicken Council explains, it didn’t take long for her creation to find a place in the hearts of Americans.

Today, good Buffalo sauce goes far beyond a delicious coating for wings and is now paired with many dishes. It has also transcended the U.S. borders, reserving a spot for itself in the cupboards of foodies around the world. 

And as with most popular foods, there are now countless Buffalo sauce brands to choose from, which presents something of a conundrum. That’s what we’re here to solve.

Whether you’re looking for the top-rated wing sauce or the all-around best store-bought Buffalo sauce to enjoy with everything from pizza to mac and cheese, your palate is sure to be pleased by what it finds in this guide.

 Jump to Section

• How We Ranked These Buffalo Sauces
• The 14 Best Store-Bought Buffalo Sauces Ranked
• What Is the Best Buffalo Wing Sauce?

How We Ranked These Buffalo Sauces

At Cozymeal, our top priority is bringing food lovers together with the culinary world’s “best in show.” Our approach to this includes facilitating exceptional culinary experiences like cooking classes and food tours in cities around the world. It also includes a trusted, considered and meticulous editorial approach to exploring the ever-evolving world of food.

To put together this ultimate guide to the best Buffalo sauces, we scoured the internet, reading through real customer reviews on platforms like Yelp, Google and Reddit. We also added our own input by consulting team members to find out which Buffalo sauces they rate highly. 

The result? A flavor-packed snapshot of what heat-seeking food fans and culinary experts really think are the best Buffalo sauces on the market.

The 14 Best Store-Bought Buffalo Sauces Ranked

14. Dougie’s Premium Buffalo Wings Sauce

Don’t let Dougie’s position in this guide fool you: it’s absolutely one of the best Buffalo sauces on this list. It’s just that, well, it’s not technically a Buffalo sauce.

One giveaway is its deep-red color, far removed from the bright orange usually associated with the best Buffalo sauces. Its consistency is also more like a barbecue sauce. 

However, if you’re reading this guide to the best Buffalo sauces hoping to find something to satisfy your sweet tooth, this could be it. We actually think it would be a real summer BBQ crowd pleaser.

Just note that it doesn’t really bring any spice to the party. Sure, there’s some smoke flavor there, and it would absolutely pair well with wings. It just doesn’t tick enough of the authentic “Buffalo” boxes to warrant a higher spot on this list. 

13. Hot Ones Original Buffalo Hot Sauce

This one’s not the best Buffalo sauce, but it’s not the worst, either. Disappointingly, the brand name (Hot Ones) and the product title (Buffalo Hot Sauce) are in stark contrast to how this actually tastes. Translation: it’s mild.

Of course, that’s fine if you’re happy without too much fire in your food. And we'll say that the real butter in the ingredients list lends this sauce a velvety texture that’s actually pretty pleasant. 

What’s more, flavors of celery, smoked paprika, molasses and chipotle really add depth to the overall experience. We just can’t quite shake the feeling that it really should be hotter.  

12. Mikee Buffalo Style Wing Sauce

In 12th place, we head to the hotter end of the spectrum in a bid to find one of the best Buffalo sauces for fiery foodies. Once again, however, there are factors in play here that restrict Mikee’s product to a lower spot on our list.

Reviews suggest that it comes with an aftertaste that’s unique. It also has a texture that’s not quite as smooth as we’d like with a Buffalo sauce. It’s almost as if it blends two different types of hot sauce. 

Sure, there are touches of classic Buffalo sauce flavor, but there’s also something in the taste that reminds us of Sriracha, and we struggle to see how it would cut through the fatty richness of chicken like other sauces in this guide to the best Buffalo sauces.

If you like hot stuff, you may enjoy this one. But if you need the tang of true Buffalo in your life, it’s probably best avoided.  

11. 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Hot Honey Wing Sauce

If you’re on the hunt for the best Buffalo sauces, there’s a good chance that you’re doing it to level up your favorite chicken wings. And if that’s the case, this bottle from 365 by Whole Foods Market might just be for you.

Just note that it doesn’t quite hit those classic spicy, tangy, creamy and rich notes that characterize the best store-bought Buffalo wing sauces.

On the plus side, its slightly thick consistency coats chicken beautifully, and if you have a sweet tooth, hot honey is rarely a loser. In this case, we think it’s a good contender for 11th place, but doesn’t quite break into top 10 territory. 

10. Texas Pete Buffalo Wing Sauce

Texas Pete Buffalo Wing Sauce hits what we would consider the “sweet spot” in terms of heat, hovering just above “mid-hot.” It also just about manages to deliver the creamy, zesty tang that is most associated with the best Buffalo sauces.

But there’s nothing that really makes it stand out. It’s also on the thin side, which is strange given that it’s labeled as a “Wing Sauce.” We think the main issue lies in the fact that it’s actually made with a base of Texas Pete Original Hot Sauce. 

In other words, it’s not a dedicated Buffalo recipe. This is fine if you’re a fan of the original product. But if you’re not, and you believe that there’s no shortcut to achieving the best Buffalo sauce, you’ll probably agree that 10th place is fair.  

9. Tabasco Buffalo Style Sauce

Leaning on the base of vinegar and cayenne pepper, for which people love (and sometimes hate) Tabasco, this particular product is well worthy of a spot among the top 10 best Buffalo sauces.

There’s plenty of heat, and the vinegar base cuts through rich foods with delicious results. The drawback is that it’s less creamy than others on this list. 

It’s pretty thin, too, which marks it down among the best store-bought Buffalo wing sauces. But all in all, as far as flavor goes, it’s pretty darn good.  

8. Buffalo Wild Wings Medium Sauce

Our next bottle is thick, creamy and absolutely one of the best Buffalo sauces on this list for chicken wings. That’s not surprising, given the restaurant chain that makes it. What’s slightly disappointing (depending on your palate) is the amount of heat.

We get it — a national chicken fast food chain like Buffalo Wild Wings needs to draw as big a crowd as possible, and not everybody likes full-on fire in their food. And don’t get us wrong, it’s not exactly mild. But it falls short of that “mid-hot” sweet spot that earns others a higher place on the list of best Buffalo sauces. 

7. Sweet Baby Ray’s Buffalo Wing Sauce

Known and absolutely adored for selling some of the best BBQ sauces on the market, did you know that Sweet Baby Ray’s also makes one of the best Buffalo sauces?

It’s orange (like bright, in-your-face, Buffalo orange) and delivers delicious notes of garlic and paprika that complement an almost perfect level of cayenne pepper heat. 

Whether you need solid tailgate food ideas or are just having a night in with take-out wings and pizza, this sauce is your ultimate wingman. 

6. Noble Made Dairy-Free Hot Buffalo Sauce

Don’t let the angry red owl on the bottle put you off. Sure, this is one of the best Buffalo sauces for those who like heat, especially given its brave-but-bold inclusion of habanero peppers. 

But it’s not so hot that it’ll dissolve your taste buds. It’s also deliciously sugar-free — ideal for keto dieters — and is made with olive oil instead of butter. And don’t worry, it retains that creamy, velvety texture that Buffalo fans love.  

5. Chef Hak’s Organic Buffalo Sauce

For those who don’t mind dairy-based sauces, Chef Hak’s inclusion at the top of this guide to the best Buffalo sauces might seem strange. But for those who don’t want dairy in their Buffalo sauce, this plant-based sauce is one of the best. 

It’s light and pretty runny, which does affect how well it adheres to wings (including plant-based versions). But used with other dinner food ideas like salads, mac and cheese, and pizza, it’s hard not to like this one.  

4. Steve’s & Ed’s Garlic Buffalo Wing Sauce

Given the name, this is not the best Buffalo sauce to eat on a date. Do so and you’ll probably need to talk behind your hand for the rest of the evening. 

But if you’re among friends, this has to be one of the best flavored condiments in the “Buffalo” category. It’s buttery, peppery, and — you guessed it — garlicky. It’s also thick enough that it’ll coat your chicken wings to perfection. 

3. Primal Kitchen Original Buffalo Sauce

Here’s another of the best Buffalo sauces for vegan and dairy-free diners. Made using avocado oil, this bottle from Primal Kitchen pours perfectly, is a great texture for dipping and coating all types of wings. It also features that gorgeous orange color that characterizes the best Buffalo sauces. 

The flavor? Pretty good. It’s oddly sweet and sour, but we kind of like that. It has a bright kick of pepper and is none-too-spicy. 

Of course, if you really like heat, you might want to try another bottle. But if a mid-hot condiment curbs your cravings (and you can get past the less-than-generous size of the bottle), you’ll probably agree that this is deserving of a spot near the top of our list of the best Buffalo sauces.

2. Frank’s RedHot Wings Sauce

One of the most glorified names in the world of wings, Frank’s RedHot is synonymous with the best sauces. And don’t think for a second that we’ve included it at the top of our list because it’s one of the most well-known brands. 

In our experience, brands with as much hype as this one rarely live up to it. But in this case, we feel that Frank’s sauce is rather undersold. The fact is that it’s one of the all-time best Buffalo sauces. 

If you’ve never sampled Frank’s, firstly, where have you been? It’s made with distilled vinegar, delivering to your palate a tantalizing tang that cuts through just about anything rich you might pair it with. 

Aged cayenne peppers give it its signature kick, while salt and garlic powder round out the profile with savory notes that keep you dipping for more. The consistency? Thick and sumptuously sticky — just what you need for a perfect plate of wings. 

1. Cholula Caliente Wing Sauce

Another sauce that we’d describe as “a classic for a reason,” Cholula’s Wing Sauce is a worthy sister to the brand’s deified Original Hot Sauce. It comes with the same signature wooden cap, although you’ll be popping that off just as soon as you get a chance.

Especially when you learn why this earns the top spot on our guide to the best Buffalo sauces. Despite its affiliation with the brand’s Original Hot Sauce, it’s not overly spicy. But it has absolutely tons of flavor, all of which is perfectly rounded and even offers a touch of sweetness. 

It’s velvety, which is a big tick. It’s also the right amount of thick, making it perfect as a dip, as a drizzle for pizza, and — as you’ve guessed by the name — a coating for wings. 

What Is the Best Buffalo Wing Sauce?

Despite its best efforts, even the best ranch dressing can sometimes fail to deliver the tangy trip to Flavortown that your tastebuds need on a Friday evening. Especially if you’re enjoying a plate of wings with a cold one after a hectic week at work. Often, only the best Buffalo sauces will cut it, and in this case, we would say that Cholula Caliente Wing Sauce is the greatest of them all.

It’s velvety, thick enough to glaze your wings, and delivers a rounded medley of flavors with a delicious touch of sweetness. It’s also spicy, but not so spicy that you’ll need to down your beer to cope with it. 

However, no matter your budget and spice level preference, you’re sure to find the perfect Buffalo wing sauce for your needs in this guide. So, why not try as many as possible to get a personalized answer to this question? 

Whether you’re hoping to level up your weekend plate of wings or looking for an all-rounder that can pair with an array of comfort food favorites, we hope this guide to the best Buffalo sauces has helped you find what you’re looking for. 

From vibrant orange sauces that are sure to please the purists to those that promise to curb vegan and dairy-free cravings, the best Buffalo sauces come in many forms. All that’s left for you to decide is which you’ll add to your basket first!

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.