17 Top Subway Secret Menu Items To Try in 2025

There’s a good chance you’ve been eating at Subway, unaware of the existence of the Subway secret menu — hidden away deep in the recesses of the kitchen. Or perhaps you don’t know how to order the innovative Subway off-menu items and shy away from asking in case you embarrass yourself?

Well, shy away no more! This article will guide you in satisfying your Subway secret menu craving by finding the perfect sub so you can eat to your stomach’s content. 

Whether you want to relax with a special sub after a long day or you’re looking to bond with your gang over the various Subway secret menu items, these delectable meals are a secret worth knowing.

 Jump to Section

• Does Subway Have a Secret Menu?
• 17 Best Subway Secret Menu Items
• How We Created This Subway Secret Menu Guide

Does Subway Have a Secret Menu?

Yes, and the best part is that you can customize the meals to your liking. The Subway secret menu is something of an unofficial offering by the brand, consisting of old Subway-style creations and new combinations worth the hype. Innovations like the foot-long Italian B.M.T., Meat Feast and more lie in wait for the perfect moment to be discovered by foodies like yourself. 

As far as ordering from the Subway secret menu goes, simply request your meal by name or show them the ingredients from the How To Order guides below.

17 Best Subway Secret Menu Items

1. Pizza Sub

The Subway secret menu pizza sub is a savory delight that offers the convenience of a sandwich but tastes like a pizza. It features cheesy layers, marinara sauce and toppings of your choice. 

You’ll have to be specific with your order, since it’s a unique Subway secret menu item. To create it, order your choice of bread, followed by marinara sauce, cheese and toppings. Some of our favorite toppings include salami, olives, mushrooms and pepperoni. 

Toasting is optional, but make sure to finish this Subway off-menu item with a sprinkle of seasoning. We recommend trying oregano and red pepper flakes. 

How To Order

• Bread
• Marinara Sauce
• Cheese
• Your Choice of Toppings
• Seasoning

2. Chicken Cordon Bleu

If you’re feeling a little indulgent, be sure to try this savory Subway secret menu item. It combines tender chicken breast, Swiss cheese, ham, and the usual vegetables and sauces for a tasty meal that will instantly transport you to a five-star restaurant.

To order it, ask for the bread of your choice (Italian herbs and cheese is the most recommended), followed by grilled chicken breast slices, ham and oodles of Swiss cheese that will later melt into heavenly gooeyness. You can also customize this Subway secret menu item further with vegetables and sauces of your choice.

How To Order

• Bread
• Grilled Chicken Breast Slices
• Ham
• Swiss Cheese

3. Sweet and Sour

Give the usual Subway classics a tasty twist by ordering a sweet and sour sub. This Subway hidden menu item requires some customizations to one of two existing Subway sandwiches to get the perfect tangy and sweet flavor profile.

Start by asking for a standard menu item — either the sweet onion teriyaki chicken or the chicken teriyaki. The former is one of the best subs on the regular menu, according to Study Finds, which may influence your decision. 

Next, ask for honey mustard and sweet chile sauces, as they’re the stars of the Sub. Further customizations of this Subway secret menu item include adding your choice of vegetables and cheese. 

How To Order

• Sweet Onion Teriyaki Chicken or Chicken Teriyaki Sub
• Honey Mustard 
• Sweet Chile Sauce
• Your Choice of Vegetables and Cheese 

4. Deconstructed Breakfast Taco

Subway combines its unique take on a taco breakfast with classic flavors to highlight its signature ingredients in this morning meal. To order this Subway breakfast item from the secret menu, all you need to do is specify the name and the ingredients you want. 

Start by asking for a deconstructed breakfast taco on flatbread with egg whites and steak. Next comes the vegetables, which comprise a combination of spinach, guacamole, red onions and sliced tomatoes. Finally, it all gets topped with Chipotle sauce for one of the best meals to start your day.

How To Order

• Deconstructed Breakfast Taco
• Your Choice of Protein
• Cheese
• Vegetables
• Condiments

5. Spicy Nacho Steak

Craving some steak and chips? Then the Spicy Nacho Steak is all you need. This fiery Subway secret menu item features the zesty flavors of a freshly cooked steak dripping into cheesy Doritos, finished off with vegetables for added crunch. 

Ordering this Subway secret menu item is easy. Simply fill up your bread with steak, Chipotle Southwest Sauce and shredded Monterey cheddar, along with nacho cheese Doritos, bell peppers and onions. Have it toasted and then add more vegetables or seasonings as you’d like. 

How To Order

• Bread
• Steak
• Chipotle Southwest Sauce
• Shredded Monterey Cheddar
• Nacho Cheese Doritos
• Bell Peppers
• Onions

6. Subway Old-Cut

This Subway secret menu item is more about recreating an old-time classic sandwich cut rather than what goes between the slices of bread. To order this unique meal, ask the sandwich artist to prepare a sub of your preference, but let them know, in advance, to cut the bread in a "V" shape. You can explain how the cut goes if the food artist is unsure.

How To Order

• Your Choice of Sub Cut in a “V” Shape

7. The Wing Effect

The Wing Effect sub likes to leave its meat hanging. Off the sides, we mean. Like the Old-Cut, this Subway secret menu creation is more of a sandwich hack than a special menu item. 

The sandwich artist prepares it so that the meat of your choice is left to hang from the sides of the bread instead of being tucked in neatly. You can order this Subway secret menu item by asking them to prepare your sub “wing-style,” which gives it the wing effect, or by requesting that the meat be left to hang off the sides. 

How To Order

• Your Choice of Sub Ordered “Wing-Style” 

8. Chicken Parmesan

Although it was taken off the roster back in 2010, you can still recreate this classic as a Subway secret menu item. You’ll have to be specific with every customization, as it's a standalone item. 

You can enjoy it by ordering a sub with roasted chicken, marinara sauce and Parmesan cheese, accompanied by seasonings and toppings like black pepper, olives and spinach. 

How To Order

• Bread
• Roasted Chicken
• Marinara Sauce
• Parmesan Cheese
• Your Choice of Seasonings and Toppings

9. The Footlong B.M.T.

This Subway signature, according to legend, stands for "Bigger. Meatier. Tastier." As the story goes, this Subway secret menu item was born from a truck driver’s hunger for a hearty meal on the road. As you can expect, the flavors are intense, and if you don’t have the appetite to finish it on your own, then this is one of the best Subway sandwiches to share with someone else.

To order it, ask for the B.M.T. If the sandwich artist isn’t clear on what you mean, ask for eight double portions each of meat and cheese, nine layers of bacon and extra bread in between. Don’t forget to add every vegetable on the roster and any sauces or seasonings you prefer. 

How To Order

• Bread
• Eight Double Portions Each of Meat and Cheese
• Nine Layers of Bacon
• Extra Bread
• Your Choice of Vegetables, Sauces and Seasonings

10. Autumn Roasted Chicken Sub

Autumn comes alive on your plate with this tasty meal from the secret menu at Subway! The sweet and savory flavors of apples and roasted chicken, combined with a drizzle of the perfect sauce and crunchy vegetables on top, will make you savor every bite.

To recreate this delicious Subway secret menu sub, have the sandwich artist put roasted chicken, bacon, crisp apple slices and Swiss cheese on the bread, along with green peppers, spinach and cucumbers. Don’t forget to ask for a generous drizzle of barbecue sauce. 

How To Order

• Bread
• Roasted Chicken
• Bacon
• Apple Slices
• Swiss Cheese
• Green Peppers
• Spinach
• Cucumbers
• Barbecue Sauce

11. The Ultimate Celebration

And truly so, since this high-protein fast food option is a celebration of juicy meats and gooey cheese in every mouthful. That is, until this Subway secret menu item is devoured into non-existence.

Ask for a large sandwich with the following ingredients: eight pieces each of salami and pepperoni, six pieces each of turkey and roast beef, as well as Swiss cheese. Have this roasted well, then add sauces, seasonings and vegetables to your liking. It’s a great Subway secret menu item for people who love salty and nutty flavors, but if you’d like to tone down the meaty elements, be sure to add acidic toppings.

How To Order

• Bread
• Eight Pieces Each of Salami and Pepperoni
• Six Pieces Each of Turkey and Roast Beef
• Swiss Cheese
• Your Choice of Vegetables and Seasonings

12. The Feast

As the name suggests, this item from the secret menu at Subway is a feast combining every standard deli meat with customizations that include even more meats. It may sound like it costs an arm and a leg, but considering this Subway hidden menu item is filling enough to share with someone else, that makes it a relatively cheap fast food option.

To order this unique Subway secret menu item, request a sandwich with ham, turkey and roast beef. Add salami and pepperoni to double the meat, and top it off with oodles of cheese, plus your choice of vegetables, seasonings and mayo, if desired. Finally, add any additional Subway sauces you’d like to double the zing before enjoying your feast. 

How To Order

• Bread
• Ham
• Turkey
• Roast Beef
• Salami 
• Pepperoni
• Your Choice of Vegetables and Seasonings
• Mayonnaise

13. More Please

If you’re looking to impress someone with your creativity, this is the best custom Subway sandwich for you. The More Please is a unique Subway secret menu item that gives you the freedom to customize as you like.

It tastes, well… however you want it to. Order more bread if you’d like; more meat, more cheese or more toppings, whether that’s seasonings, vegetables, mayo or sauces, all to create the ultimate sub that only you can think of.

How To Order

• Your Choice of Sub With More of Anything

14. Eggs Florentine Flatbread

Touted as one of the healthiest items at Subway, this macro-friendly fast food meal is a quick Italian breakfast-cum-lunch that fulfills your protein intake. Although not on the regular menu, loyal customers rate it as one of the best fast food breakfast sandwiches, which has encouraged many Subway sandwich artists to become familiar with its make-up.

To get this Subway secret menu item, ask for egg whites, banana peppers and red onion, as well as black olives and any Italian dressing, all wrapped in a super fluffy and light flatbread.

If you’d like to boost the protein content even more, go for one of the healthiest breads at Subway, the Hearty Multigrain, in place of the flatbread. This simple switch adds an extra 5 grams of protein, although the sandwich’s total calories increase by about 60.   

How To Order

• Flatbread
• Egg Whites
• Banana Pepper
• Red Onion
• Black Olives
• Italian Dressing

15. The Big Philly Cheesesteak

As straightforward as it sounds, this cheesesteak sub combines the goodness of rich steak with the creaminess of cheese in a filling sandwich. Sitting gracefully on the Subway secret menu, this popular item will satisfy your cheese and steak craving, and is much easier to eat on the go.

Order this foot-long Subway secret menu item with three helpings of steak and double the cheese, sauces, vegetables and seasonings. Have it toasted and let the cheese coat all the ingredients before you dig in.

How To Order

• Bread
• Three Portions of Steak
• Cheese
• Your Choice of Sauces, Vegetables and Seasonings

16. Tuna Melt Sub

If you’re in the mood for something fishy, choose the tuna melt sub from the Subway secret menu. It's a simple sandwich with straightforward ingredients, and you can customize it as you like. 

You can get this Subway secret menu item by ordering a sandwich with tuna salad and adding cheese — we found that cheddar and provolone are both good choices. Have the sub toasted till the cheese melts, and enjoy your meal.

How To Order

• Bread
• Tuna Salad
• Cheese

17. The Chicken Pizzaiola

Combining chicken and pizza in a Subway sandwich has to be one of the smartest ideas ever thought up. Since it's not a customized version of a meal on the regular menu, you’ll have to describe the ingredients needed to make this Subway secret menu item. 

Ask for the bread of your choice, roasted chicken breast and pepperoni. Have this toasted with cheese and marinara sauce before adding vegetables and seasonings. The result? That zingy pizza flavor that we all know and love.

How To Order

• Bread
• Roasted Chicken Breast
• Pepperoni
• Cheese
• Marinara Sauce
• Your Choice of Vegetables and Seasonings

How We Created This Subway Secret Menu Guide

As is the case with all hacks and off-menu items from restaurants, finding the secret menu for Subway can prove to be a challenging task for many. However, the Cozymeal team has the necessary expertise and experience to track down the various meals and present them in a way that’s easy to understand.

With more than a decade of experience in the culinary field, we understand what passionate foodies are looking for when researching their favorite brands, restaurants and products. This knowledge has led us to create detailed guides on various food topics, such as this one on the best Subway secret menu items. 

We created this guide by doing thorough research, which included reviewing information from forums and social media platforms, such as Instagram, Facebook and Reddit. However, we also thought it necessary to try the Subway secret menu items ourselves so that we could present a combination of information not only from foodie experts online but also from our own team members.

The thing about Subway’s secret menu is that it hides its specialties in plain sight. Whatever you fancy and however hungry you are, the Subway secret menu is full of variety, keeping things fresh and allowing you to make the most of your meal as you wander in search of your next gastronomic adventure. 

Hopefully, now that we've unearthed some of the best Subway secret menu items, you can overcome that shyness and order your dream sandwich with confidence. Whatever your choice, you can now satisfy that craving for something new and delicious every time you visit this popular deli.  

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.