9 Best Casserole Dishes for 2023
Whether attending a summer potluck or hosting a holiday dinner, investing in the best casserole dishes will certainly make your recipes stand out from the crowd. A quality casserole dish can last a lifetime and be used for a variety of meals and desserts. From traditional round cast iron pots to the classic rectangular ceramic dishes that show up at every potluck, the best casserole dishes come in all shapes and sizes.
Each of the best casserole dishes has unique features and functions that set it apart from the rest. Which casserole dish is the best for you? How do you choose the right casserole dish for your needs? Here are nine top choices for the best casserole dishes for your kitchen.
Jump to Section
- Best for Everyday Use: Staub 3-Pc Rectangular Baking Dish Set
- Best for Potlucks: Staub 13x19” Baking Dish
- Best for Dinner Parties: Staub Rectangular 2-Pc Baking Dish Set in Rustic Ivory
- Best for Feeding a Crowd: Mrs. Anderson’s Lasagna Pan
- Best for Versatility: Staub 3-Pc Mixed Baking Dish Set
- Best One-Pot Wonder: Staub Cocotte Round 4Qt in White
- Best for Aspiring Chefs: Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 3 Qt. Round Covered Casserole Dish
- Best for Small Portions: Harold Import Co. Personal Lasagna Pan
- Best for Small Kitchens: Nordic Ware Nonstick Compact Ovenware Casserole Pan
1. Best for Everyday Use: Staub 3-Pc Rectangular Baking Dish Set
The Staub 3-Pc Rectangular Baking Dish Set is a versatile collection of enameled and scratch-resistant dishes in three popular sizes. These adaptable dishes are microwave-, freezer-, broiler- and oven-safe and can also be used to serve salads or desserts, making them some of the best casserole dishes for the everyday home cook. They are easy to clean and can be stacked for convenient storage, perfect for a weeknight dinner.
- Price: $89.95
2. Best for Potlucks: Staub 13x19” Baking Dish
The Staub 13x9” Baking Dish is the perfect dish to impress at your next potluck. This is one of the best casserole dishes due to its versatility, durability and vibrant color. The ceramic dish is safe to use in the oven, microwave or under the broiler and it safely stores leftovers in the freezer. It does not scratch easily and is resistant to both impact and thermal stress.
- Price: $76.95
3. Best for Dinner Parties: Staub Rectangular 2-Pc Baking Dish Set in Rustic Ivory
The timeless elegance of the Staub Rectangular 2-Pc Baking Dish Set in Rustic Ivory is a stunning addition to any dinner party. These twice-fired enameled ceramic dishes are highly scratch and cracking resistant while gently retaining heat from oven to table. Its expert craftsmanship and elegant nod to traditional bakeware make this set one of the best casserole dishes for any host or hostess.
- Price: $58.99
4. Best for Feeding a Crowd: Mrs. Anderson’s Lasagna Pan
Mrs. Anderson’s Lasagna Pan is a deep-dish wonder and one of the best casserole dishes to feed a hungry crowd. The award-winning pan is specially designed for deep-layered recipes with its uniform heat distribution resulting in perfectly baked casseroles, baked pasta and desserts. This versatile pan is microwave-, oven- and broiler-safe.
- Price: $51.95
5. Best for Versatility: Staub 3-Pc Mixed Baking Dish Set
The Staub 3-Pc Mixed Baking Dish Set is practically all you need for perfectly baked casseroles, lasagna, pies and desserts. This set includes three of the best casserole dishes to bring versatility to your kitchen including a traditional rectangular pan, an oval casserole dish perfect for lasagna and a classic ridged pie dish all with convenient handles. From savory to sweet, these ceramic dishes bring elegance and functionality to every recipe and are safe to use in the oven, microwave, under the broiler and in the freezer.
- Prices: $99.95
6. Best One-Pot Wonder: Staub Cocotte Round 4Qt in White
The Staub Cocotte Round 4Qt in White is made in France and brings timeless elegance and versatility to your cookware repertoire. A classic workhorse for one-pot dishes including stews, roasts, casseroles and soups, this chip-resistant piece is sure to be a standout in your kitchen. The traditional round design includes self-basting spikes and the cast iron cooks and browns food evenly for a consistent result every time.
- Price: $309.99
7. Best for Aspiring Chefs: Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 3 Qt. Round Covered Casserole Dish
Channel your inner Julia Child with the Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 3 Qt. Round Covered Casserole Dish. This classic design with a modern twist is both multi-functional and elegant as one of the best casserole dishes with a lid. The cast iron and porcelain bakeware is ideal for searing, grilling, braising or simmering as well as being oven- and broiler-safe. Create incredible meals in style with this timeless option for best casserole dish.
- Price: $69.95
8. Best for Small Portions: Harold Import Co. Personal Lasagna Pan
The Harold Import Co. Personal Lasagna Pan is the best casserole dish when you want smaller portions. This microwave-, oven- and freezer-safe dish serves up your favorite recipes from lasagna or macaroni and cheese to breakfast bakes or banana bread. This porcelain dish is perfect for singles, couples or roommates.
- Price: $30.95
9. Best for Small Kitchens: Nordic Ware Non-Stick Compact Ovenware Casserole Pan
For those in need of a versatile pan that doesn’t take up much space, invest in the Nordic Ware Non-Stick Compact Ovenware Casserole Pan. Perfect for cooking up smaller meals for one or two people, this aluminized steel pan can be used in a toaster oven or conventional oven. Whether making a meal from scratch or reheating leftovers, this convenient little pan is the best casserole dish for a tiny kitchen — and it's a budget-friendly buy at only $11.
- Price: $35.95
A quality casserole dish is an excellent investment for every home cook. Whether you’re making dinner for two or feeding a crowd, these dishes are versatile, durable and the perfect addition to any kitchen. Choose the best casserole dish to suit your needs and lifestyle for a long-lasting piece that will help you create impressive recipes for every occasion.
For even more chef-recommended cookware, check out more items in the Cozymeal Shop.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.